DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?

Chris Benoit vs. Dean Malenko

Match

86.8.07
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 136
Number of comments: 39
10.0 9x
9.0 43x
8.0 51x
7.0 25x
6.0 3x
5.0 2x
4.0 2x
3.0 1x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 8.08  [136]
Average rating in 2026: 7.67  [6]
Average rating in 2025: 7.95  [19]
Average rating in 2024: 7.86  [22]
Average rating in 2023: 8.44  [18]
Average rating in 2022: 7.65  [17]
Average rating in 2021: 7.64  [11]
Average rating in 2020: 8.38  [8]
Average rating in 2019: 8.33  [3]
Average rating in 2018: 8.17  [6]
Average rating in 2017: 8.71  [7]
Average rating in 2016: 8.11  [9]
Average rating in 2015: 8.00  [3]
Average rating in 2014: 9.00  [4]
Average rating in 2012: 9.50  [2]
Average rating in 2011: 9.00  [1]
Your Options:
Other:
Rhasta wrote on 25.03.2026:
[4.0] "Lifeless match with a dead crowd that couldn't care less. It's a 27 minute match that felt 40 minutes. It's evenly paced the entire time, never goes into higher gear, no good near falls and fails to engage the crowd in any shape or form. The crowd booing the restart is spectacularly hilarious. Neither of them were over at this point so giving them that much time is asking for trouble and this is the result."
psychostar wrote on 01.03.2026:
[7.0] "This was a really good technical match that was hindered dearly by two factors -- the godawful crowd that could care less about any of the action in the ring, and the double overtime rulings. This went on way too long, especially considering the crowd and setting, and both times the match was restarted the crowd just poured in the boos. The actual wrestling was great, but it was just the wrong place to try something like this. ***1/2"
GeneralKroth wrote on 04.06.2025:
[8.0] "This is a very good match that was terribly booked for the mere fact that it happened at this particular pay per view. Benoit and Malenko put on a technical clinic that would've been appreciated by any live crowd other than the Sturgis bikers, who had no idea who these two were and couldn't care less. The crowd is completely dead throughout and loudly boo during overtime, which in my opinion distracts from the stellar in ring work. A real shame as this would likely be remembered as one of the best technical matches ever otherwise."
Ruthless Attitude wrote on 05.03.2025:
[9.0] "This was an amazing match that really deserved a better crowd than this. It's not very surprising to see that two of the best wrestlers to ever lace a pair of boots had amazing chemistry and great back and forth moments where they couldn't put each other away. It starts out fast, but its unbelievably gruelling under the heat as it goes along. I have to say though I don't see the point of having a time limit there if the referee is just going to call infinite overtimes and honestly a time limit draw would have been a better finish than what ended up happening."
JacquesRougeauCanHaveMyWife wrote on 13.11.2024:
[5.0] "They overdid it with the overtimes to the point that the crowd booed at the announcement of the second one. The technical stuff and chain wrestling was phenomenal here, but the pacing unfortunately was a little bit off and I couldn't really get myself invested in this. Both guys had better matches that actually popped the audience."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 18.06.2024:
[8.0] "If you over look the constant interruptions of the match and the dead audience, this was a good match. Both men are technicians with great chemistry and were able to put an in ring masterclass."
PapaTango wrote on 06.04.2024:
[9.0] "Impressive performance from both men. Benoit and Malenko always had great chemistry whether they were booked as a teammates or foes. The technical prowess displayed in the match is nothing short of magnificent."
Deen wrote on 06.01.2024:
[4.0] "Decent technical wrestling match but it gets super tedious to watch by the time the first overtime starts. A good chunk of this match is just doing a random move and going for a cover with no tension built up at all. The crowd obviously did not help but they really did not do anything for people to care about who is going to win. Woman is the most entertaining person on the screen most of the time as she is the only one showing any kind of emotion. A dirty finish for a match like this is just the icing on top of an already crappy cake. Poorly paced and heatless match that should not have gone ~30 minutes long in a venue like this. Malenko continues to show why he is one of the most boring wrestlers of all time (muh workrate)."
Sweetteajay wrote on 13.11.2023:
[8.0] "This is an awesome bout that is undeterred by several outside factors that ultimately have no bearing on the overall quality of the match. Obviously the atmosphere is different than a traditional PPV setting, though I find the bikers in the audience more novel than I do a nuisance. Even though the match ran long and quite unnecessarily ventured into two overtimes, this really is the kind of match that should be able to win an apathetic or unknowledgeable crowd. Technically crisp, Benoit and Malenko just laid into each other with STIFF shots; unfortunate parallels aside, Benoit's intensity in the ring in really unmatched by few others. He even took some gnarly Suplexes here, including a Release German where he landed right on the back of his head(! ). There's a lot here to like, and as long as you can stomach Benoit at his most physical, it's a really enthralling encounter. ****"
CMFunk007 wrote on 19.07.2023:
[9.0] "It upsets me that this crowd got a free show, had a match like this on it, and then booed them. These fucking ingrates at Sturgis wouldn't know a good wrestling match if it bit them in the ass. And this was spectacular. Easily the match of the night."
Squall182 wrote on 12.02.2023:
[7.0] "Unsurprisingly unbelievably technical wrestling between these two superstars. But everything around the fight with the public that was bored and the issue of the time limit that honestly seems a bit silly to me overshadows the good fight that it was. Still worth a look."
Red Mage Riot wrote on 09.02.2023:
[9.0] "Another great match in front of the wrong audience. This is a technical masterclass in front of a crowd that just doesn't have the patience for it."
5nicoShuffle wrote on 02.12.2022:
[6.0] "This is yet another example of a match that would have been great anywhere apart from here. Benoit & Malenko try to put on a classic, but it really doesn't have the spots or drama to make it one, they just look like their trying to run out the clock, which they do... twice. By the second extra time, the fans really have had enough, and so had I to be honest. It just feels like a long match just for the hell of it."
cactus wrote on 29.09.2022:
[5.0] "Seeing as this event is happening at a motorcycle rally where a lot of people in the crowd aren't going to be wrestling fans per se, they were smart to open this one up fast, with Benoit landing a double-leg takedown and striking down on Malenko. This soon turns into the match that you expect from these two, with a slow methodical pace as Benoit works on top. Benoit bullies Malenko and trash-talks him and that's all the personality you are getting from this match. We get a neat exchange where they trade nearfalls by countering each other pin. Everything looks crisp, but there isn't much else to write home about. Malenko is a terrible babyface as he has the charisma of a carrot. He doesn't sell particularly in a way that would make the fans get behind him. The time limit initially expires, but the referee calls for five minutes overtime. The audience is so disinterested in this match that they actually boo when overtime is announced. Things get a little more interesting during the overtime as Benoit works over Malenko's leg and he actually starts selling in a halfway compelling manner. Malenko rolls Benoit up in a cradle, but the overtime expires. The fans are downright furious when the ring announcer announces that they will be getting five more minutes of overtime. Woman gets involved and costs Malenko the match and this one is thankfully over. This felt similar to the ECW Malenko/Guerrero series. If this match happened in ECW, the mutants in the crowd would be clapping like seals. This had slightly more going for it than those matches as there is an actual face/heel dynamic, but 27 minutes of dry wrestling in front of a disinterested crowd is going to be hard to watch. Crap on the crowd all you want, but these two gave them no reason to care about what was happening in the ring."
arrancar wrote on 17.06.2022:
[6.0] "It's a shame that such a good match was wasted on such an uninterested crowd, but the match's structure definitely didn't help them. They both impressed with their intensity, aggression, physicality, and athleticism, but their technical exchanges and minimal character work made it hard for the crowd to maintain their already minimal enthusiasm (given that neither guy was an especially popular star to begin with). They had a handful of good high spots that were intermittently spaced out, but then they'd always return to their slower technical-based exchanges which, while enjoyably professional-looking from a wrestling fan's perspective, would have been confusing and uninteresting for the casual fans who were invested in wrestling because of the soap opera elements and the larger-than-life characters like Hogan and Sting, and didn't really care for actual wrestling in their wrestling shows. Even discounting the crowd's bias, it still wasn't the best decision for the match to go so long and had TWO overtime sections, especially since neither man ever really upped their urgency or creativity to sell the magnitude of those overtime sections or to sell just how important the potential victory was for both men. Also, for as good as their general physicality was, there were definitely a few exchanges and spots where they had lacking impact or slightly awkward technique, which the crowd would likewise remain unmoved by. And after all of that, Benoit got the win via a roll-up after Woman distracted Malenko on the outside. What a disappointing finish for an underwhelming match that was basically doomed to fail. The crowd may have been pretty bored, but at least I was decently entertained. ***1/4"
Giantfan1980 wrote on 03.06.2022:
[7.0] "This is the match where the crowd started getting bored and booed halfway through. Idiots! Jimmy Hart talks to Malenko on his way to the ring. Probably has something to do with Sullivan/Benoit. Benoit controls the first portion. Benoit tries a tombstone but Dean counters into his own and plants Benoit but only gets a 2 count. Malenko drops Benoit on a charge then goes for the cloverleaf but Benoit counters into a small package for 2. Were nearing the 30 minute time limit and Benoit slaps on a lion tamer but Malenko still manages to get to the ropes. The time limit expires but the ref agrees to allow a 5 minute overtime. Benoit presses the attack and goes for a series of pins then goes for a Texas cloverleaf. Dean goes for the ropes but Benoit pulls him to the center of the ring. Malenko won't quit so Benoit releases it. Enzuiguri knocks Benoit for a flip! Malenko with a bad leg now. Overtime expires and were going into double overtime, the fans boo because they don't know from nothing on pro wrestling. Woman interferes and Benoit gets the pin almost 30 minutes in in double overtime. That finish bugs me."
Derek Joists wrote on 31.12.2021:
[8.0] "So, this was almost an amazing match, but it was hurt by two things. Firstly, it ended up with a stupid stipulation where they had a 20 minute time limit, but instead of letting them draw they twice added 5 minutes on to ensure a result - and had a dumb distraction finish. Why not just not have the time limit, or book it to finish in time' And secondly, the crowd could not have been less interested in a technical display, and hated the restarts. Normally that would be on the crowd, but in this case where they weren't wrestling fans it was on WCW failing to book matches to appeal to them. It's a shame as the match itself was a great technical match, and one of the rare times they faced each other rather than teaming together."
Nethandle wrote on 09.05.2021:
[3.0] "Extremely disappointing considering the two men involved and the general reception of this match. This went on for way too long, had no dramatic tension, and completely killed the crowd. People like to decry the crowd as if they didn't want to see wrestling and it's their fault that they stopped reacting to this match 10 minutes in, but the fact is every single match before this had no problem getting a reaction from them. What actually happened is this shitty match killed the crowd and they didn't do anything to bring them back, just did meaningless kickout after kickout with no flow, no intensity, nothing. Furthermore, why the fuck is there a time limit when you're just gonna call overtime? Not to mention the finish was complete shit. The most entertaining part of the match was the crowd loudly booing the overtime announcements because it meant this shitty match wasn't over yet and they were completely fed up with it."
tykechandler wrote on 06.04.2019:
[8.0] "If there is a time limit on the match then why in the name of FUCK is there overtime? WHY HAVE A TIME LIMIT TO BEGIN WITH. THIS DRIVES ME INSANE."
RatingsMachine wrote on 18.09.2018:
[10.0] "If this match was contested in front of an actual wrestling crowd, in front of people who wanted to watch wrestling, it would have blown the roof off the place."
jackleone wrote on 15.07.2017:
[9.0] "Amazing 30 minutes match, with two restarts. This is a great technical match and one of the best of 1996. Strong performance, solid and never tiring. The conclusion is terrible and unsatisfying but the rest is impressive. Great action, Dean Malenko finally shows how good he is with all this time to wrestle. ****1/4"
Mizzle Assault Ant wrote on 25.02.2017:
[10.0] "Fantastic match, it's all been said I'm sure but just a masterful display, a true clinic. Technical wrestling, brawling, striking, speed, intensity, this match had just about everything. Probably not the best crowd to put this match in front of, but who cares, it's a blast to watch 20 years later."
BigKev wrote on 01.12.2016:
[7.0] "I had high expectations going into this match and felt let down at the end. It was too long and felt repetitive especially towards the "overtime" periods, which was another issue I had with the match. The event venue and crowd don't do it any favors either. I don't account for that in my rating but it certainly has an effect on the enjoyment of watching the match. Hard to believe people consider this Malenko's best match as I can easily recall 10 matches with Guerrero, Mysterio, Ultimo Dragon, Jericho, etc that are better IMO. Personally, I'll take these guys as a tag team over being opponents any day."
RaviC19 wrote on 09.10.2016:
[6.0] "I gave this match ***. Technically very solid, but a problem I have with these kind of matches, and in particular when Malenko is involved, is that they tend to pretty boring with not many high, or interest moments at all."
TrevPuroFan wrote on 23.04.2016:
[9.0] "This was a great technical contest, with both guys countering eachothers offence, and throwing submissions at eachother. The overtime was really really good ****1/4"
Dowkesy wrote on 02.11.2015:
[7.0] "A good match but I'd be lying if I said I didn't expected more from these two great wrestlerd. The pace seemed a little slow at times and dragged slightly however the psychology of the match was good as was the story. All the moves were done very well and smoothly. I wasn't a fan of the ending however. My rating ***3/4."
eldenaaaaa wrote on 07.09.2014:
[9.0] "Much like how in the last review I mentioned that Psychosis & Rey Misterio Jr. brought the Lucha Libre style to the US, guys like Benoit & Malenko brought new breed of hard hitting technical wrestling that, along with the Lucha Libre, helped make WCW's undercard so great. This particular match was Benoit vs. Malenko and simply put, it was awesome! Really great technical contest. The only things that really hurt it were the two overtime periods (since when did we get those in regular matches? ) and the dead crowd who in no way shape or form deserved to see a match of this caliber. Benoit wins with some help from his girls on the outside."
Anatolik wrote on 25.03.2014:
[9.0] "Very impressive match in terms of directly wrestling, strong "psychology", tension was felt in every movement of wrestlers. A somewhat one-sided fight and the audience reaction was not very loud. 9\10 4. 25*"