[5.0] "A one match show, and even that match isn't really a five star classic, I feel if it was it'd be more higher regarded anyway. Nothing was too awful. The first two matches weren't that good but were necessary for storyline progression. TJP and Fire Ant looked interesting on paper but was little to write home about and a bit sloppy at times. O'Reilly and Cole had a match that started awkwardly but slowly worked into something half decent before finishing. The Tag Team Street fight was the second best match on the show by some distance, a fun, but otherwise paint by numbers brawl with a few cool spots and the crowd were into it. The actual tag title match had its moments but always slowed down especially when WGTT were in control as well. Steen and Edwards was pretty bad to be honest, kind of slow and unengaging. Roddy and Lethal was a bit better but still very bland. Main event started pretty slow but to be honest when the "no selling" from Elgin started it was actually really fun and the crowd were really into him as well. Some great transitions (to be expected with these two) and strikes certainly elevated it. Absolutely not a five star match perhaps even today, but in comparison to what was around it was very exciting to watch. Finally, I don't know how this show appeared when it originally aired, but the camera work and audio is truly awful on the DVD release. I'm not sure if Kelly and Nigel were supplied with crap mics but they were either too quiet and when they shouted they were deafeningly loud, not great at picking up sounds of strikes/weapons/and chants either, although the atmosphere for the most part was awful anyway. The camera work isn't as bad, but it rivals it at times and it jerks like fuck in the main event especially when filming from the ringposts."

[6.0] "A show that was elevated considerably by its main event which was up there for ROHs best match of 2012. The remainder of the show is a bit underwhelming although it wasnt horrible. Matches that felt like they were about to get into their next gear came up short delivering just fine matches like Generico/Jacobs. Strong/Lethal was solid (and notable for Roderick becoming a triple crown champion in ROH.) Steen/Eddie was fine but could have been stronger. Bucks/ANX and WGTT had their moments. Fire Ant/TJP was fine. Cedric/Ciampa tried despite it largely being a squash. Kyle/Coke suffered from the PPV brownout and was the low point of the show. A show that could have been stronger with a better layout and some better booking."