[5.0] "A pretty flat episode that somehow felt longer than it actually was. Queen Aminata versus. Skye Blue was the strongest match, while PAC versus. Ace Austin was solid but underwhelming and Kevin Knight with Kyle Fletcher continue to feel stuck in a direction that does neither man many favors, especially Fletcher. Roderick Strong leaving the Conglomeration at least moved something forward, but too many promos and segments lacked substance, and by the main event the show had largely lost my interest. Not terrible, just lifeless and difficult to invest in."

[6.0] "This really should have just been part of a 3-hour Dynamite, rather than a stand alone Collision. We get Kyle Fletcher in the opener, but they use the post-match hype Darby and Knight's TNT feud. Skye Blue gets pinned, and then we have to see Willow clear the ring, ugh. Best match was PAC and Ace in the main event. Loved Jay White, the Gunns and Andrade coming down for the save."

[4.0] "Aminata vs Blue was okay. The Jericho and Wayne thing was okay, too. Nigel used to joke that Nick's adopted name is "Cage", and now it feels like he's adopting Nic Cage mannerisms. He'll probably get more mic experience from this feud than any feud he's had prior. The Outrunners are just one of many examples of what will happen to you if you don't get out of the trios division like your career depends upon it. I hope The New Level have an exit plan in sight. Pac vs Austin was fine but who really cares about that match? The post-match brawl had its moments but these things are shortcuts for AEW when they can't create excitement through storytelling. Slap a post-match brawl on it and call it a day. And that's the final, lasting impression of AEW heading into All Out. Pac vs Ace Austin in a ten minute match no one cares about, and of which the winner was never in doubt, followed by a brawl between guys on the PPV's pre-show. Feels like we're in a refractory period following All In."

[8.0] "The 3rd hour is always tough but this is really worth watching for Queen vs Skye and PAC vs Ace alone. Two really strong matches."

[6.0] "Show was alright but going an extra hour and a half after Dynamite was too much. I did really enjoy the Skye Blue/Queen Aminata match.Other than that it was just kind of there."

[7.0] "Not much as a go home show, but I did find the in ring quality to be pretty good throughout all 3 hours."

[5.0] "This was a drag and somehow felt longer than the 1st 2 hours. Women's tag segment made me not want to see the match. No way RJ is behind this. Roddy exiting the glom was progress at least. I don't like the current use of Knight and Fletcher, plus the promos lacked substance. They're at different stages of their development and should probably be doing something else, especially Kyle. Jericho segment started off with a bit of promise but ultimately lacked substance. It's like these guys struggle to build a segment/program with something substantive or at least entertaining. Women's backstage promos were fine. While I always like Aminata's finish, the crowd and I were dead for most of this and it just kept going (a match that proves that you need to get the audience invested in characters first). You know the crowd is dead when Thekla and Willow can't really pick them up. By the main event, I was basically checked out, even though Andrade was cool to see."

[2.0] "A few good promos sandwiched between uninteresting matches. The women's match wasn't too bad, but the other two were predictable filler that didn't make anyone look good. An hour of mediocre show that pairs well with an already uninspired Dynamite and exposes the lack of excitement surrounding the weekly shows in recent months at AEW. Match quality: 0.75/6.5. Non-match angles and segments: 1.25/3.5. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 2/10. Show watched on MyAEW."