[8.0] "A very good Collision for a show that usually is not nearly as comparable as Dynamite. But Bandido vs. Shibata was really fun, the 8-Man Tag was also a lot of fun, and even the Brian Cage match was surprisingly fun. Then the impromptu Darby Allin for being less than 5 minutes was really good. Then the Main Event was absolutely fire with having Mark Davis and Mike Bailey put on an absolute clinic of a match with gnarly spots, bumps, and great near falls that made this match awesome. This match also had a fun Fletcher commentary, and some great fan atmosphere. Overall, great Collision, and I hope that they can keep this up on the way to Redemption, and more importantly, on the way All In."
[5.0] "I liked the main event and thought the opener was okay even if I think Shibata's fingers-in-the-ears idea of a western heel is unbecoming, but I don't think there's much reason to care about most of the stuff on this show. Action-wise, the eight man tag wasn't actually that bad either, it's just hard to care about something which doesn't mean anything. Shida and Harley looked like they could barely pick each other up but I think they were lucky in that most of the rough spots didn't come across outright like failed choreography. Hangman comes back with a bad perm and a graphic which says he recently had a vasectomy and Andrade has a video which makes him look like a playboy stud. I wonder which gimmick will go further. The main event could have done with more selling, especially towards the end where I think too much was shrugged off to tease a comeback win, but I think both guys did well with 15 minutes and were fairly consistent in making Davis look like a powerhouse threat at close range and Bailey having to pick his shots. Fletcher also added a lot of intensity, urgency, and excitement to commentary."
[9.0] "Very fun Collision. Banger of a main event. Loved the 8 man tag. Darby can't turn it off even for a 4 minute match with Trent. Just a damn good time."
[8.0] "It's strange to say, but Hangman Page's lackluster return was the show's low point. The cowboy came back without any fanfare, and while he delivered a decent promo, it didn't convince me. He said he's a humble guy whose hobby is gardening, that he can't go for the world title, but that there are other titles he can aspire to, naming the various champions and trophies in the company. I feel like his return was rushed because they're trying to build something, and they didn't have enough time. Although the ROH World Championship isn't what it used to be, Bandido and Shibata had a good match, though I really don't like Shibata being a cheat; it doesn't suit him. Hikaru Shida and Harley Cameron had a match with its ups and downs, but now the women's division is heating up. There are real threats to the champion, Theckla, and factions are forming. If TopFlight, AR Fox, and Komander are involved in the tag team matches, at least that's appreciated. Cage dominated Zachary Went and Darby Allin, who had previously struggled to defeat Trent Barretta in a short but entertaining match. Mike Bailey was unable to overcome Dunkzilla, who managed to withstand his opponent's kung fu in a great fight that showcased contrasting styles."
[8.0] "A pretty fun episode of collision all things considered. We got a great promo from a returning Hangman to open the show setting his sights on the other belts in the company. We then got some really fun match between Bandido and Shibata and also the Death Riders vs Top Flight and friends. We got some nice promos from both Willow and Thekla about their ambitions to take on Mercedes. We also got Skye calling out Divine Dominion setting up a title match. Then we got a backstage segment with Willow and Maya setting up Those two and Hyan vs Mercedes, Megan and Lena in what should be a banger. We had to eh tv matches in Shida/Harley and Cage/Wentz which were alright. We got a fucking banger main event one of the best of the Year for me such a good sprint with so much great action and Davis elevating that national belt. Yeah probably the best collision in a while mainly thanks to a banger main event. Imagine my shock live Collison equals good show do it more."
[8.0] "Nice wins for Bandido, Brian Cage and Mark Davis. All three were good matches, and happy with the finishes. Harley was awesome as usual. Had to suffer through another Darby win."
[10.0] "an all timer Collision for me, exactly what i've been asking for on the show. more in ring promos from top guys like Hangman, Willow and Mox and we still had enough time for several background interviews/promos, and some fun vignettes. you can also tell this the first time in a while that the majority of the roster's top end is healthy because a random Collision from months ago wouldn't have Hangman, Mox, Darby, Kyle Fletcher, Willow, Shida, Orange Cassidy, Jay White and Bandido on the same show. plus the midcard is also great, Davis, Shibata, Speedball, Rascalz, Harley. Tv time is more valuable than ever."
[7.0] "It didn't quite reach the highs of Beach Break but was still a solid show overall. We got Adam Page back, the opener was strong and the main event delivered. That said, the final stretch of the show felt a bit rushed. For a moment, I actually wondered if they realized they were running out of time, because the last 3 matches just flew by one after another. In the end, I really enjoyed three of the six matches, while the other three didn't work for me. So I'd say it was a good episode but can't rank it any more higher"
[9.0] "The main event was amazing, the opener and tag match were good. Darby vs Trent is too short to be rated, but it was one of the best sub-5 minute matches I've seen this year."
[9.0] "Had no real expectations for this and didn't even really know the card beforehand. But wow, what a great show. Main event was incredible but Bandido/Shibata and the 8-man tag were great too, Harley/Shida was good, Harley's improvement has been drastic and Shida has really grown into her heel role, great promos from Thekla and Willow and of course a really strong promo from the Hangman and the return of the lower third. Glad they showed footage from the event at the Twins game too, that looked really cool. Absolute blast of an episode, 8.5/10."
[5.0] "A good main event, but the rest lacked quality, build-up, and suspense--or even any real stakes, in the case of the 4v4 match. Quite a few short segments between matches made the episode more enjoyable, starting with the BBG clip. The storylines surrounding the various women's titles are shaping up reasonably well, too. Finally, I found Hangman's promo rather basic and not much more interesting than what's going on with Allin or Sydal--positive, sure, but nothing truly memorable. Match quality: 3/6.5. Angles and non-match segments: 2.25/3.5. Bonus/penalty: none. Total: 5.25/10. Show watched on MyAEW."
[7.0] "Really good collision, I enjoyed it more than Dynamite this week (again). Hangman's return promo was very good, with Bandido/Shibata and Speedball/Davis being the other 2 main highlights."
[10.0] "This Collision felt like a Dynamite. That's the best bit of praise I can give it. We had some great matches (the main in particular was fantastic) and other promo stuff that helped push stories forwards. Shoutout to the crowd too who were electric and only got better as the night went on."
[10.0] "A fun and somewhat eventful show with the return of Hangman Page, some title defenses, a hot crowd and an excellent main event that may actually be one of my matches of the year. Live Collisions always hit a little bit harder."
[8.0] "Kind of a weird show. Oddly tepid return for Hangman despite mostly enjoying his promo (which isn't always the case). Then the show just declines continuously, especially with that tbs title match. Kommander's great performance didn't stop the death riders from killing the vibes (Mox tried to arbitrarily bury some people on the mic). Talking segments throughout the show were hit or miss with the bang bang gang being a positive standout. Wentz and Cage worked hard to get the crowd into their heatless affair, but the episode really began to turnaround with a very unique Darby squash (credit to Trent too) before the main event which was the collision moty so far imo. Fletcher was engaging on commentary and the show completely turned me."
[6.0] "Pretty tepid way to return Hangman. Also of note was Moxley immediately shitting on the team that just put him over saying it was too easy and flippy dippy guys can't beat the Dick Riders. He then takes a pot shot at Kenny that I'll be shocked if it leads anywhere because I highly doubt Moxley is gonna put Kenny over clean. The main event was really the only thing worth checking out. Fletcher on commentary was tremendous and the match was fantastic. I love both guys so was torn on who I wanted to win"
7x
12x
54x
27x
8x
2x
0x
0x
0x
0x
0x