"Overall it's a solid show from top to bottom. Sure none of the opening matches really stand out, but that's made up for with three really good matches to end the show."

[9.0] "This was a really good show with clean in-ring quality matches, while having decent storytelling. I'm very excited to see Saori Anou fight Saya at queendom."

[5.0] "Un show très moyen avec aucun match vraiment marquant même si les deux derniers sauvent un peu le show sans être exceptionnel.Tout les match solo ont des longueurs ce qui a pas vraiment aider a l'appréciation du show."

[5.0] "Crimson Nightmare was a show that lived up to its name. Not a disaster, but certainly a dark reflection of where Stardom stands right now. The in-ring quality was there at points, but the heart was missing. The undercard was flat, the booking uninspired, and the main event failed to capture the magic that once defined this company."

[7.0] "A weird show with great in-ring performances, underwhelming storytelling and baffling booking decision. Fairly enjoyable in a vacuum, will make you scratch your head if you are invested in the promotion."

[9.0] "Very good PPV from STARDOM with three really good title matches on the top. The end confirm that STARDOM being the Saya Kamitani show. Saya Kamitani against Momo Watanabe was great main event match between those HATE members. Kamitani is truly the MVP in 2025. Konami get the "Goto Moment", yes, SHE DID IT FINALLY. Forced to think of Hana or Kyona through this victory for her first big singles title. It was about time. That came as a surprise, SLK gave his best this year. Hazuki and Mei Seira had an awesome High Speed match, the showcase of this show. Kashima vs Bozilla was fun and the rest of the matches were pretty solid."

[5.0] "Worst stardom PPV of the year, mid undercard, very questionable booking decisions, disappointing world title matches. Just a disheartening show really. Mei vs Hazuki and Saki vs Bozilla save this from being a complete flop."

[5.0] "Crimson Nightmare had its moments, but overall it summed up Stardom's current direction: solid wrestling, little spark. The World of Stardom title match with Momo should've been a statement match, but it never reached that emotional high. Kamitani's path to Wrestle Kingdom feels inevitable, and while she's clearly the centerpiece of the promotion, the overexposure is starting to drain the intrigue. The talent is there, but the storytelling feels mechanical and predictable instead of exciting. At this point, nothing and no one else seems to matter in this promotion."

[8.0] "Delivers from top to bottom in terms of in ring quality. The title matches in particular really took this up to feeling like a truly big ppv event, despite how close we are to Queendom. The lackluster build to the main event and unfortunate fizzling out of what could have been the next huge story in the main event scene, was very disappointing. Since that was seemingly due to an injury I can't judge too harshly, especially since they still had a barnburner of a match and left the door open for the rivalry to be picked up down the line."

[8.0] "As expected STARDOM delivers again. They have been on a roll in 2025. Attendance is climbing and climbing, and with the casuals and critics putting out all their "STARDOM is cold" stories, this was anything but that, and it's been like that for a while. I'm sure the attendance number will prove that as well. So many stories and interesting stuff coming up for STARDOM including the Tag League which begins at the next show!"

[9.0] "Another fantastic PPV from STARDOM with some really good title matches on the card. It wasn't one of their big PPV's but they delivered really well. Saya Kamitani against Momo Watanabe was a superb main event match between those HATE members. Kamitani is truly the MVP in 2025. Konami did it finally and won her first big singles title. It was about time. That came as a surprise. I'm curious whats next for Starlight Kid. Hazuki and Mei Seira had an awesome High Speed match. Hazuki with super cool gear. Kashima vs Bozilla was fun and the undercard matches were pretty solid."

[7.0] "Good show Stardom today, with an entertaining opener, the team matches were not bad except one, fun match between Saki Kashima & Bozilla, finally the 3 championship matches responded present, starting with an excellent Highspeed match, then a very surprising result for the Wonder title, to end with the match of the evening with Saya Kamitani who keeps her title in the match of the show, not to mention the after match with two BANGER IN COMING that were announced, Saori Anou who challenges Saya Kamitani for the World Of Stardom at Dream Queendom on December 29 and Syuri who will face Saya Kamitani at Wrestle Kingdom 20 for the NJPW Strong Women's and IWGP Women's Title."