[8.0] "Pretty good show. This honestly had a lot of similarities to WrestleMania 40 in my opinion as the main event was done in a similar manner. Shaggy 2 Dope showing up to this show was unexpected. Cogar vs. Nemeth was also good as well honestly. Caleb Konley vs. the Great Sasuke was amazing as well as you got Mr. Kennedy (yes, Mr. Kennedy and not Mr. Anderson) introducing the Great Sasuke. Effy vs. Willie Mack was somewhat disappointing but still was good. PCO coming back was a good move there to counter the Outbreak as well. Also, Super Humman showing up was a big surprise along with Fat Fuck Barrel Boy, George South, and Vampiro. Overall, a great ending to the Gathering of the Juggalos."

[5.0] "It felt rushed in my opinion but nothing was bad. I really like Caleb Konley vs. Great Sasuke, there was no way that was going wrong. The GCW title match was so disappointing that I actually fasted forwarded through it. The main event was bloody but I figured Tony was gonna win it. Tons of cameos filled the night and it was a lot of fun."

[5.0] "About on par with the previous night by the time it was done. The two best matches of the show were Atticus Cogar/Nic Nemeth and Caleb Konley/Great Sasuke. Some other matches got minimal time such as the women's four way and Effy/Willie which was disappointing. The main event had its moments but some of the chaos not involving the participants could have been a bit better. Crowd was not quite as raucous here as they were the previous show."

[3.0] "First things first that bait and switch on the exploding barbwire match left a sour taste in my mouth. The crowd tonight didnt seem as rabbid as the other 2 shows at the Gathering. The 4 way womans match was insanely short for no reason at all. Hell, now that I think about it everything was pretty damn short excluding the main event. PCO is back in GCW for the first time since the TNA Digital Media Title situation. Vampiro, Fat Fuck Barrel Boy, Mr. Kennedy(not Anderson), Super Human and Shaggy 2 Dope are some of the surprises on tonight's card. Shaggy and J finaly in a wrestling ring for the first time in along time was definitely a great moment from a pretty terrible match. Cogar/Nemeth and Sasuke/Konley are the only things worth anyone's time. A hugeeee step down from the other two shows that took place at the Gathering"

[5.0] "Just about passable. Cogar and Nemeth was the best match of this weekend despite not being great, more so due to a lack of time. The crowd wasn't quite as raucous this night which was a shame, but the atmosphere was still fun. Worse than last night, yes - maybe worth a watch or a quick skim through, just don't expect the matches to be groundbreaking - well, expect them to be very average and overly crunched for time. **1/2."