DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?
Name of the event:
AEW Dynamite #238
Type:
Attendance:
2.177
Broadcast type:
Live
Broadcast date:
24.04.2024
TV station/network:
TBS


This text is hidden because it is only available in German language. Please click this line if you do not care and want to view it anyway.

All workers
7.12
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 240
Number of comments: 74
10.0 2x
9.0 28x
8.0 82x
7.0 65x
6.0 38x
5.0 11x
4.0 6x
3.0 4x
2.0 3x
1.0 1x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 7.12  [240]
Average rating in 2026: 6.00  [4]
Average rating in 2025: 7.20  [5]
Average rating in 2024: 7.14  [231]
Your Options:
Other:
Rjepic1 wrote on 03.09.2024:
[7.0] "AEW returns home to Daily's Place! I always like the look of Daily's; it has a very unique vibe. This was a very good show that didn't quite reach great levels for me. The match of the night here in my eyes was the debut of the Casino Gauntlet match type; I'd heard a lot about this gimmick, and I found it quite fun. The worst match was the main event, but pretty much exclusively because Hobbs unfortunately got hurt. The angle with The (New) Elite laying out Tony Khan was great and all, but I thought the best segment of the night was actually Willow's Championship Celebration; Willow vs Mercedes feels like a big match. Surprisingly my least favourite segment was the Mox segment at the start of the show. Pretty fun first show post-Dynasty."
Will Morris wrote on 15.07.2024:
[7.0] "overall a pretty fine show. the swerve match felt like a waste and deeb setting up a programme with storm is not something i massively care about. i'm still not a massive fan of babyface mone but the next match stipulation was great, even though they never really explained what was going on. will gave some great sequences and made everyone else look great. hopefully jericho gets off tv soon as the future of this gummick doesn't look promising. shame about the main event with hobbs getting injured but i am excited to see takeshita. the closing segment was a bit silly, especially tony's selling."
TheRefBump wrote on 02.07.2024:
[4.0] "Awful stuff. For a bloke that just won its world championship, he was on the undercard (The match opened with a midcard feud between two wrestlers) with a midcarder and they cut to a storyline in the middle of a world title holders match, and then no mention of him again. Oh my god. This is dumb"
Pro Wrestling 1948 wrote on 05.05.2024:
[8.0] "Very enjoyable episode, really liked seeing Kyle Fletcher, and liked the foreshadowing with his interview with Don Callis. Also liked the Mina vs. Anna Jay match. Loved the Casino Gauntlet Match with Ospreay, Jay White, and Lance Archer. Moxley and Hobbs delivered in the main event."
Paul04 wrote on 04.05.2024:
[5.0] "A terrible Jericho segment, an OK match with Swerve but not the best follow-up, a meh women's match, a fine Willow/Mercedes segment, a boring main event, but the closing angle was hilarious and while the Casino Gauntlet was messy if was still a fun match"
MaveDeltzer wrote on 02.05.2024:
[5.0] "This episode had matches and a Daily's Place atmosphere which both dragged and ADHD levels of story advancement. I'm not entirely against the latter if it'll get things back on track so long as every week isn't quite as hectic as this was. Jericho is funny as a smarmy heel who plays into the crowd reactions but the idea of another Jericho faction doesn't interest me so much. I prefer the idea of Jericho being the one to latch onto others like a vampire rather than having guys like Big Bill come to him. The Tony Khan segment was kind of terrible in execution but I'm so starved of an interesting story that I don't care. Just make me went to see what happens next. I still maintain that Swerve as a face instead of a heel or edgy anti-hero with Nana as comic relief is a mistake, but they went all in on the "moment" and made him full face, it seems. Dull matches, a muted atmosphere, and probably too much happening story-wise, but I'll take too much story over none at all. Stronger matches could have made this a high-paced episode."
Nevermore42 wrote on 01.05.2024:
[8.0] "The strength of this episode really wasn't in-ring, where most of the matches weren't anything special. The World Title match between Kyle Fletcher and Swerve Strickland was good, but lacked the edge that comes when the finish is actually in doubt. Mina Shirakawa vs. Anna Jay was good for an Anna Jay match, but still a little disappointing. The Gauntlet Match between Will Osprey, Dante Martin, Jay Lethal, Jay White, Komander, Kyle O'Reilly, Lance Archer, and Penta El Zero Miedo was the match of the Night, managing to capture the fun of the Royal Rumble without completely ripping off the rules. Finally, we got an IWGP World Heavyweight Title match between Jon Moxley and Powerhouse Hobbs, which was severely hindered by an unfortunate injuy to Hobbs."
LIJ369 wrote on 29.04.2024:
[7.0] "Good show but couldve been better following the PPV. Swerve vs Kyle was long but good 3.75*. Mina vs Anna was ok 2.5*. The Gauntlet match was really good but the rules were too complicated, all the mini one on ones were fun though 4*. Moxley Hobbs probably was gonna be good but injury that away. And I thought the Tony khan angle was great (other than his selling) interesting to see how Kenny and maybe Hangman play in"
diarchtct wrote on 29.04.2024:
[9.0] "Really good episode of Dynamite. I was pleasently surprised by the back-to-back women's segments in the first hour. Everyone gets more TV time, we have so many different characters in the women's division now, it's night and day to previous years. Willow Nightingale is a true star, she has natural charisma that outshines Mercedes Moné by a mile. Moné is fulfilling her heel arc, which we all suspected was happening. Now that we know this is the direction for her, the previous segments make a lot more sense. The gauntlet match was a wonderful surprise, getting better by the minute. Definitely did not expect WIll Ospreay to enter, but the execution was great and it's the right step for Ospreay's young AEW run, leading into the next inevitable banger match at DoN, where he either wins the title or gets screwed to enter a blood feud over the summer (Jay White maybe? ). They also continue his differences with Callis, who now slowly gets annoyed by Fletcher losing all of his matches. Again, great continous storytelling, expands every week. The highlight was the main segment where the Elite return to their roots of being the biggest heels in wrestling. A fantastic little detail is how they did not hit a Meltzer Driver in years, and saved it for this massive moment. This is where long-term storytelling pays off. Hope The Elite take over as on-screen bosses now and Tony Khan disappears from TV for a longer time. Apart from the Hobbs injury and match, I can't fault this episode. 9/10"
Rossg17 wrote on 28.04.2024:
[7.0] "The opening segment with OC being attacked by Trent Beretta was surprising to see, not as surprising as Chuck Taylor attacking Beretta which was good to see and Taylor challenging Beretta to a fight in the parking lot was good to see. Swerve Strickland vs Kyle Fletcher: It was an okay match, both could have used their athelticsm abilities a bit more to be honest, could have been 4 or 5 minutes less which would have made it better [***]. Mina Shirakawa vs Anna Jay: It was an okay match, I didn't think there was chemistry there much between these two, the match went on a bit too long to be honest [**1/2]. Will Ospreay vs Dante Martin vs Jay Lethal vs Jay White vs Komander vs Kyle O'Reilly vs Lance Archer vs Penta El Zero Miedo: An exciting to watch match, a unique match that had some unique moments, Komander hitting the hurricanrana on Lance Archer through a table was surprising, some interesting interactions, Ospreay winning the match and becoming the No 1 contender for the International Championship at Double or Nothing was good to see [****1/4]. Jon Moxley vs Powerhouse Hobbs: Not a bad match but also could have been longer but due to the injury of Hobbs, they had to put the wrestler's safety first, Mox winning was obvious [***]. The closing segment with Jack Perry and The Elite attacking Tony Khan was shocking to watch"
Retro Ricky wrote on 28.04.2024:
[5.0] "The show was built around an angle involving Tony Khan, which might not be the best way to respond to allegations that he's the new Dixie Carter. (And, in fairness to Carter, she did a better job on screen in 2014 than Khan did in this show.) There's a chance that the show-long angle creates some intrigue and kept audiences around, so it can't be panned, but the relatively weak payoff (oh how surprising that heels attacked a babyface) and largely uninteresting matches might just generate more disappointment than anything else. In the other angles, Thunder Rosa was given an excuse for not continuing her pursuit of Toni Storm, which is correct, and Kris Statlander was given just a little babyface shine for being Willow's supportive friend. It must be said that there was (and perhaps is) an opportunity to build around Swerve Strickland and that opportunity is being squandered."
WrestleGenie420 wrote on 28.04.2024:
"Great episode that followed up on from a great PPV(Dynasty) with agreat ending. Jack Perry an the Elite closed out the show with a captivating segment, and TK didn't do half bad himself."
DarekPetrelli wrote on 28.04.2024:
[5.0] "The episode was written with the ass, you have a new world champion crowned at the ppv and you put an undercarder segment as opener. Segment that btw I liked for what it was, I was expecting something really really childish and instead it was ok and for once they had continuity with the "story" of the s word. I don't mind an exhibition match with the new world champion but the slot was weird, they should have opened with Swerve to tell everyone that he is the most important thing going on..but whatever. Mina vs Anna Jay was fine.. Jericho was my favorite wrestler growing up, tbh I loved his run as AEW Champion too. But what I'm looking now is a grossly fallen star. They could have saved the gauntlet for next week, trying to build it up and create some anticipation...at a certain point it was just background noise for me.. I was really looking forward to Mox vs Hobbs but oh well. I don't know how to judge the final segment. Part of me says it's an interesting direction... part of me tries to compare it to other angles like that and bursts out laughing because my god everyone involved is terrible... except Mr Shahid who lowkey I think is perfect for wrestling."
NickJammer2221 wrote on 27.04.2024:
[3.0] "There was 1 relatively good match with the opener and 1 very good match with the tag match with Ospreay over delivering yet again but sadly that was it for the show. Very poor womens match and a God awful main event even before Hobbs injury and then a dreadful angle at the end involving Tony Khan breaking his promise to be an on screen character as a cheap ratings ploy. Please do better! I give it 3 for failure to delivery on most fronts for the show and like with the Punk footage, Tony Khan using himself to boost ratings is a short term result at best."
RCO1982 wrote on 27.04.2024:
"This was a fantastic episode of Dynamite! I wasnt sold on the Casino Guantlet at first but it was a really fun match with some great spots. The end with Jack Perry and TK even though it was predictable I enjoyed. I also love how TK is wearing the neck brace during the NFL draft to keep the story going and Kayfabe alive!"
WAKA Flockanoku wrote on 26.04.2024:
[6.0] "I had a difficult time deciding on a rating for this show. The main event was a disaster and only two matches on this show stood out to me as good, one of them being tainted by a strange booking decision. However, the ending to the show was a lot of fun and added a lot of intrigue on where AEW is going next. While the in ring action felt lackluster and the main event hurt the show a lot, the final segment of the night did save the show from mediocrity for me. Say what you want about Tony Khan taking a more active on screen role, but I'm heavily interested in seeing where this story goes because of it. [MOTN: Casino Gauntlet Match]"
EvPOz wrote on 26.04.2024:
[2.0] "They did a great PPV and now its back to the usual bad TV show. Trent getting away from the Best Friends and being a serious heel could be good, but he has to get away from them, a feud with OC would be fine if he can be serious and Trent wins and moves on, Chuck T is too goofy and wrecked the first segment. Swerve v Fletcher, why is the new champion going 15 minutes competitively with a midcarder who doesn't win anything? Why is he jerking the curtain? Why didn't he get any promo time? Awful start to his title reign, and it's a shame, the guy deserves better. Match was pretty decent, but they had some trouble working together. **3/4. Rosa v Deonna could be a nice little feud. Mina v Anna Jay, what a train wreck, they just did stuff to each other non-competitively and it didn't look any good and couldn't work together when they tried. Anna Jay is learning but needs to be carried and Mina doesn't speak English and can't carry people who speak her native language anyway, the match shouldn't have been booked. DUD. Serena taking the belt off Toni would be a blessing, glad to see her, but she'll job again. That #1 contender match looked like a mess, didn't pay enough attention to it to rate it. Jericho, this is better than that cringey faction he had last time he turned heel, but this is a guy that just needs to go away. Moxley v Hobbs, one of the most uninspired IWGP title matches I've seen, it was really bad and Hobbs was no threat. *. Oh and the angle.. Jack's heart punch was so lame, Tony's selljob was hilarious, the bad Meltzer driver from the Bucks, the dressing room coming out minutes after the Elite left the scene, if you want crap, keep praising crap. A reinstatement angle where Perry goes after Tony wouldn't be that bad, but this was executed so badly. It was comedy, and Okada was actually hilarious looking clueless out there. Why couldn't Tony hesitate on reinstating Perry, and Perry throws one good looking punch to the face and runs out through the crowd, ending it on a cliffhanger while the dressing room storms the ring (because this angle wasn't about Perry, it was about the Bucks). Shad Khan looks more intimidating than anyone who was in the ring."
Kinsman wrote on 26.04.2024:
"Dynamite 4/24/24 Happy to be in dailys place, feels like home for AEW. 8.00 Also The Youngbucks entrance with Jack Perry is extremely fun, happy to see Perry back. 8.60 Trent Vs Cassidy: seems to be an ok feud, I never paid attention to them as a group, so this doesnt impact me in any way. Thats just me though, Im sure others are enjoying this in some way. Hopefully Ill get into it in the future. 4.50 Moxs promo was fine. 5.00 I like that swerve opens and Kyle Fletcher is an absolute beast in the ring. So good first match choice for Strickland. 7.80 Crowd is loud. 8.00 Swerve Vs Fletcher: Pretty good technical wrestling to start. Swerve is such a fun wrestler. Fletcher selling the bump on the floor made me laugh. Fletcher catching swerve after that ringside rope was really smooth, love stud like that. Swerve Stomp on the apron was cool, great selling from both. Fletcher countering the house call into an heel hook was smooth. Amazing moment where swerve catches Fletcher with a kick from that ground and smoothly transitions to a brain buster. Fletcher refusing to use a table was a nice moment. Good kick out by Fletcher, house call finish was good. Match was good overall. Though its difficult to feel any stress during these matches, as we kinda know swerve is garanteed to win. 6.50 Kenny! 8.00 (get well soon) Thunder Rosa Vs Deanna Perazzo is fine, dont really care tbh. 4.50 Mina Vs Anna Jay: Shirakawa is extremely charismatic. Her in ring energy is really infectious. Nice missle dropkick from Mina. Fairly uneventful match. 5.00 perfectly meh. Timeless Toni storm is always a good thing, teasing Serena seen vs Toni storm, should be a good match if it happens. 6.80 Willows celebration started of kinda corny, but now Im excited for Mercedes Vs Willow. 7.50 Fun mini segment with Alex trying to get a scoop. *double tap* 7.00 Gauntlet match #1 contender match: Dante Martin is always fun to watch. That kick the Pienta does with his opponent on the top rope is always cool to see. Cool chain reaction leg takedown. The pop for spreads entrance was beautiful. Cool moment between jay white and will. Super stiff shots from lance. Amazing DDT to Ospreay from Kommander. Ospreay vs ORiley section was sick. Interesting choice, I wouldve assumed ospreay wouldve faced swerve at wembley, but I cant see him losing clean anytime soon as it could remove his legitimacy for the title, so he cant really lose to Roderick. So maybe an international vs AEW world title winner takes all match at all in? Idk, great match tho. 8.3 The learning tree is a confusing and frustrating booking choice. And the big bill conclusion is a whole bunch of nothing. 3.00 Mox Vs Hobbs: terribly boring, wanted it to end half way through. 2.00 Takeshita vs Mox should be good, some excitement from that 6.00. Shibata should absolutely squash Jericho, he wont though sadly. 2.00 Jack Perry vs Tony khan: you know what, I like this. 7.00 This show was mid to ok, mostly mid. 5.72"
coppercowries wrote on 26.04.2024:
[7.0] "What a wild night. For those who watched on Fite, like me, there weren't any major audio issues, so I didnt have that problem detracting from the episode. The matches weren't the best tonight, but that was more of a booking problem then performance. Swerve should've gotten mic time, but looks like they're doing that on Saturday. I enjoyed the ladies match and that whole story evolving. I also thought the Casino match was alot of fun. Sucks about Hobbs getting injured, he's a favorite of mine. Now, the other stuff. GREAT promo from Willow and Mercedes. This was the first time I thought Mercedes didn't just sound like a robot. She was passionate and natural. And Willow killed it. The Jericho schtick was...to be determined. Could be ok, but we'll see. Loved the through thread of the Elite, leading up to the most cracked out, fantastic attack on Tony Khan ending with a TK Driver! Tony Khan has paid for his crimes."
Zimbabouix wrote on 26.04.2024:
[9.0] "That was peak pro wrestling TV right here, the closing segment was awesome with TK taking the bump for the biz. But the wrestling was cool too, except unfortunately for the Moxley vs Hobbs because of an injury. Swerve vs Fletcher was really good, the gauntlet match was great with a white hot Ospreay winning it. Anna Jay vs Mina Shirakawa was good too. The Elite rules AEW and I love to see it, can't wait for the next episode with the Kenny Omega return!"
ZooWee wrote on 26.04.2024:
[7.0] "A solid Dynamite. Nothing too crazy here other than the show closing angle. Really controversial for some reason even though it really shouldn't be. It positions the new Elite as the top heels in the company and I don't care what anyone says, Tony Khan taking a Meltzer driver is objectively hilarious. Such a goofy angle but it achieved what it set out to do. The wrestling was mostly fine across this show. The opener between Kyle and Swerve was pretty good and the Casino gauntlet match was a super random but very fun concept for a match that was executed very well by the talent involved in it. The main event was also shaping up to be quite good but unfortunately got derailed because of Hobbs' injury so I'm wishing all the best for him. There was one notably bad segment on the whole show and of course it involves Chris Jericho. I get that he's trying something new but I'm just sick of seeing him on TV and I think that sentiment is shared by most people who watch AEW weekly. And from the looks of things he's getting a new group too. Literally why? Do we really need what is essentially gonna be the JAS with a different name? I just don't see this working for me and the fact that he's probably gonna beat Shibata next week annoys me to no end. Other than that though this was a fun episode of Dynamite, with a great closing angle and some solid matches throughout the night too."
ThuggaloPark wrote on 26.04.2024:
"This was easily the best episode of Dynamite this year. The energy is Daily's Place is always unmatched. I like how Okada has been treated like a big deal. Swerve is in for a good run as AEW World Champion long as he stays healthy. Chuck Taylor finally said the "s" word on TBS. Excellent episode from top to bottom. I also think Jericho's self-aware "Learning Tree" is going to be more compelling than the J.A.S was"
WeHateOkada wrote on 26.04.2024:
[9.0] "Dynamite in Daily's Place just hits different. The first three matches were all amazing and the crowd was molten hot throughout. I loved the Best Friends segment, and Chuck FINALLY saying "the s-word" after all these years was genuinely a fantastic moment. Everybody in the gauntlet match looked great but Lance Archer is built for these kinds of stipulations and this was a great showcase for him. I'm digging the self-awareness of Jericho's new gimmick and whilst the segment had an awkwardly anti-climactic ending, I think Big Bill makes great sense as a protégé for Jericho. Swerve looks like a million bucks as AEW champion. The last half hour of the show wasn't quite as good as the rest of the night - despite some really explosive moments from Hobbs, the main event underwhelmed, and the closing angle is certainly interesting and different, but it's also relying heavily on the idea that I give a rat's ass about TK, which at this point, I really don't. Still, a lot of good stories being built right now (including, possibly moreso than ever, in the women's division) and this felt like a majorly important episode."
Chorizo wrote on 25.04.2024:
"Great show, liked the Willow promo, Gauntlet match was an interesting style and had some great wrestling and the ending angle has me very interested for rampage/collision!"
HBKisGod wrote on 25.04.2024:
[4.0] "Main event ending was incredibly interesting and I'd love to see where they can go with it but some main points that I'm griping with - if Punk was fired for lunging at TK, shouldn't these four be sent to the Sun for PILEDRIVING the guy? I will say, Shad Khan made this show for me in SECONDS, he has an aura of authority the show's lacked since Day 1. Jericho was unwatchable and I guess Big Bill is being pulled into the Vortex next. Swerve being put in a nothing match with the least important Callis Family member is poor and being upstaged on his first show as champion is... not great, but he can recover with his kickoff promo on Collision and *hopefully* a good first feud, maybe unfinished business with Keith Lee? Moxley/Hobbs was fine, hope the big guy's ok and... I'm interested in Takeshita/Moxley, that could make some money. Women's division is a tale of two stories, that being TBS title interesting, World title uninteresting (that Toni/Mariah feud needs to come sooner rather than later) - where's Jamie when you need her? Decent, but underwhelming for a Homecoming."
Cal1641 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[5.0] "Underwhelming show especially for one in daisy's place. Casino Gauntlet Match was the best and then the main event segment was interesting, hopefully not too much TK on screen though, he's best in Limited appearances. Wish Swerve had more to do on this one but glad he's getting a #1 contender next week. Next week's show actually sounds interesting."
Machavez21 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "Overall great show. It is not the best it has seen from start to finish, but it did have some very great and memorable moments. Lets begin with the 'New' Elite attacking the boss Tony Khan once he reinstated Jack Perry into AEW. This was great and if done correctly, it should build into a great storyline. All the women involved in both segments were great and had a decent amount of time, which is always great to see. The Casino Gauntlet Match was something I did not know I needed, but I enjoyed it very much. AEW should definitely keep the 'casino' theme matches as part of the Double or Nothing build or during the PPV. The Casino Ladder Match for the TNT championship would be something great as well. The downside for me was the fact of an 'eliminator' match, the match itself was great. However, I am not a fan of the tag of elimination matches for the championships. Just let the champ have a match without something on the line. Then the lowest, Chris Jericho. Jericho is at a point where he needs to take some time off from TV. The Big Bill-Jericho segment was just weird for me. Anyways, good Dynamite!"
sarahlicity wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "Watching live, I felt the show was disjointed in the first hour, but then the pieces started linking together, and by the time Ospreay set up the Tiger Driver only to back out of it, it was apparent to me that what wasn't the Tony/Elite Show was the Don Callis Show. I'm coming around to Callis as a heel and everyone involved is playing their part well. The jury's still out on whether they should've gone with the obvious booking path from Dynasty (BCC vs. DCF, then Ospreay fighting his way to Wembley) than the one they're going, but I was certainly entertained. The ending segment was pretty good too, and although I could see the inklings of the Elite as the new mega-heels, I really did not expect Tony to be taking bumps. And hey, fair play to Shahid for putting to bed the bad-faith "Shad's gonna step in and turn off the money tap" line by getting himself in the angle too."
The Elevated 1 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "Best thing on this episode was the Casino match and Tony Khan being sent to the Shadow Realm. Okada in the background cracked me up. Women's and IWGP match was pretty forgettable, but the opener was good. And again, the Casino Gauntlet was very entertaining. Solid episode overall."
Neutral wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "usually on AEW the highlights are the matches and the low points are the promos, however this episode was the complete opposite. Mox v Hobbs kinda sucked, Mina v Anna was fine, the casino gauntlet match was fun as hell and set up a lot of future osprey story lines. But holy shit the promo work tonight was incredible. The jericho promo did the classic jericho thing of pulling me back in after I thought I fucking hated him. The ending is the exact thing I wanted to see the scapegoat do. The willow mone segment actually got me excited for mone even though shes done fucking nothing (please use your most paid wrestler TK im begging). This episode made me fully realize damn, wrestling is really good right now."
TheHonestGuy69 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "A good show that advances many storylines with an original and successful ending. Maybe a main event not up to a dynamite but 2 hours well spent on fite without any audio problems."
Scott Blacula wrote on 25.04.2024:
[5.0] "The high points of the episode were Swerve's match with Fletcher, and Willow's Promo segment. Otherwise, the episode was pretty meh to me. The ending was...interesting. I have a sneaking suspicion that they're going back to the Elite focused main stories as they did a few years ago. I wasn't watching then, but everything I've seen doesn't seem up my alley. I"
PartyRockz wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "All of the promo segments for this episode hit the nail for the stories progressing into Double or Nothing. Mercedes cut what I think is her best promo yet in the company. Same for Willow. Had a great opener with Fletcher vs Swerve. The Best Friends promo was good, which is now leading to a match with Chuck Taylor against Trent. Mina had a good showcase against Anna Jay. Serena Deeb coming out was awesome. The casino gauntlet match was just pure fun. That was the highlight of the show for me. Mox vs Hobbs was decent. The end of the show was where things started to propel the Bucks & Jack Perry as great heels going forward. What a turn of events & memorable ending for the show."
BluThundrBmb wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "Very strong show for the women last night, a massive highlight but the rest of the show I feel like it missed out, Swerve feeling like an afterthough after his iconic and first of a king black world champion is extremely poor booking, horrible booking, and while I like Tony getting physical, i dont want him to be a full time character, the gaunlet match was a bit of a chaotic mess but thankfully it did turn out the White/Opsreay face off and Ospreay being followed up on is very good stuff, Ospreay getting more of a follow up than Swerve is my issue tho, Swerve NEEDS to be focused on, ALOT. Great showcase for the women tho, alot going on which is awesome, just a shame about the Hobbs injury I feel bad as he was really starting to get some great shit behind him."
HC7 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "This Dynamite was very good, as of writing I dont think the current rating accurately reflects the episode. If you just wanted great wrestling and no story progression that might make sense. All the matches were solid with the exception of the main but even then it wasnt horrible. The segments on this show helped progress stories and left on a cliffhanger story that would get people talking."
ahdude36 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[10.0] "Absolutely loved the Casino Gauntlet Match. Really cool concept and it clearly works because some of the wrestling in it was fantastic. Ospreay going for the International Championship will just elevate the title even further without hampering Swerves World Title run with Ospreay being the favourite to win it off him. People will probably complain about the Mox - Hobbs match but you can clearly see he injured himself probably 5 or so minutes before the match ended, which absolutely sucks. Swerve wrestling a match on his first dynamite as Champion, in Dailys Place was just great to watch. Him and Kyle Fletcher have immediate chemistry."
SpaceGhost wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "I liked this episode alot. the promo segments (even the Jericho one) were fun and kept my attention. The next challengers for belts all seem like potential classics. Takeshita v Mox . Deeb v Storm Ospreay v Strong. Mone v Nightingale. The starting and closing angles to bookend the show was cool. A rare show were best parts of the show weren't the in ring stuff. 9 outta 10"
bigotownsend wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "A fantastic follow up to a fantastic pay-per-view. Opened with a great match between Swerve and Fletcher and ended with one of my favourite closing angles in a long while. I question the decision to not have Swerve cut a promo following his big title win, but Im sure well get something like that next week with the announcement that theyll be determining his challenger for Double or Nothing. Shirakowa vs Jay and Mox vs Hobbs were fine, but the match of the night was the Casino gauntlet which was so stupid made no sense at all but was so much fun, and seeing Will Ospreay go at it with more members of the roster was really brilliant, his sequence with Kyle OReilly was incredible and I need to see a singles match between them in the near future. Im really excited to see where AEW goes from here because theyve capitalised on the momentum of Dynasty really well."
Rodrigo Andres wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "- What a great first appearance of Swerve as world champion. - Will Osprey being a crack - The women's division is getting better every day - Jon Moxley as IWGP Champion - Spectacular segment of the new Elite and Tony Khan, one of my favorites in AEW history."
Roodolph wrote on 25.04.2024:
[3.0] "What a bad episode of Dynamite. The final segment is embarrassing and Okada is useless. Swerve vs. Fletcher is full of errors. Ospreay for the international title totally random. Moxley vs Hoobs was one of the worst 2024 matches in aew. Man, dynasty was spectacular but this dynamite seemed booked by VKM."
ABQMIKE wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "Fun show. Introducing Elite 2.0 in a buzz worthy style worked. The Gauntlet Battle Royal was a new twist that can be used down the road and it was fun. The ladies got quality time and overall the show had people talking. Sometimes going out of the box shakes things up."
NoSell wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "This show absolutely flew by. There was no match that eclipsed pretty good but I think all segments hit. Especially the Willow promo and the attack on Tony Khan. The Gauntlet was also a lot of fun."
Belgian99 wrote on 25.04.2024:
[5.0] "WELP, here we go. Overall a very mid show, with 3 important flaws -> 1) Starting your show w/ sth as cold & unimportant & not with your NEW world champ, no celebration, no nothing.... ; 2) having your "main event" being some new TK shenannigans, in my eyes booking it above the world championship, that's also not good, even tho the story can be interesting if developped well; 3) how & why was Hobbs in a world title match, the IWGP WH title is supposed to be defended against the BEST, and sry Hobbs but you aren't... I understand the "oh cool the 1st ever IWGP HV title defense in Dynamite, in our home city", but plz then put more stakes to that..."
charliefiction wrote on 25.04.2024:
[8.0] "From an in-ring perspective, the three matches that opened the first hour of this episode were quite good (especially the gauntlet match, which also had the benefit of being a fun, novel format). While my Match of the Night was definitely Swerve/Fletcher, I thought the Mina/Anna match over-delivered as well. The untimely injury to Hobbs hurts the overall rating of both that match and the episode overall, but both wrestlers did they best they could do salvage the match (and the injury itself on a very ordinary move, so you can't blame them for excessive risk-taking). The format of this episode, however, was quite fun and paid off with an angle (EVPs vs Tony Khan) that has a lot of interesting possibilities from a booking perspective. And in the short-term, all the DoN angles look quite promising (esp. Ospreay/Strong and Mone/Willow). The Jericho/Big Bill angle remains something I'm neutral on. As with other recent Jericho stories, they usually start with a coherent set of motivations but get bogged down toward the end and eventually conclude with no definitive ending. So I'm taking a "wait-and-see" approach on this one. As an aside, the audio issues that plagued the TBS/US feed were inexcusable and annoying, but I'm not sure how to factor that into my score here."
kakkakikkare wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "A solid show in my mind. The casino gauntlet match was a very good match, Mina vs Anna and Swerve vs Kyle were both good, unfortunately the main event between Mox and Hobbs got shanked because Hobbs got injured. I enjoyed the non-wrestling angles of this show."
Vinny Santos wrote on 25.04.2024:
[7.0] "It was a fun show, good opener, cool women's match, very entertaining gauntlet match, and sadly a main event that was changed due to injury. The final segment was great, Tony isn't a great seller, but hey, I admire the courage for a man with no wrestling background to do this kind of things."
jejunestars wrote on 25.04.2024:
[5.0] "This episode was a mixed bag. It started out shaky, finished strong, but it was pretty far from a smooth ride. As far as story goes, this Dynamite delivered on its promise of fallout from Dynasty, and even with some lapses in quality, it had interesting segments (yes, even the one with Jericho) and two straight-forward plot lines: Don Callis and his guys try to take a shot at the biggest stars in the company and fall short, apart from the one guy whos an actual star and could break away anytime that he wanted to. Meanwhile, Jack Perry makes his return to TV in an attempt to be reinstated. Thats some good stuff. Thats conflict! Now as for the wrestlingwell, if the first hour was on episode of Rampage, then Id say it was a pretty good show (aside from those audio issues)! But this is Dynamite, and that second hour stunk, mostly because of that battle royale. Sure, it worked as a way to get some guys on the show and bring back some of that old Dailys place magic, but the stipulation is always a flop on TV, just my two cents. Would I watch this again in full? No. Are there some segments that Ill look back on in a year or so? Probably. Was it was successful episode? I cant say one way or the other. It didnt end in disaster, so thats worth something."
MMSultan wrote on 25.04.2024:
[9.0] "Crazy episode: 1. IWGP World Championship defended on TV first time ever and we're getting Mox vs Takeshita 2.An unexpected crazy gauntlet match with just a glimpse of the talent in that roster 3. The Elite destroyed TK, I think this is one of the hottest angles ever to end Dynamite 4. Swerve defended in his first night 5. Chuck finally gets his spotlight 6. Double or nothing already shaping very well in most segments"
RuSyxx wrote on 25.04.2024:
[5.0] "Kind of a mixed bag to follow what was an excellent PPV show. Ultimately it'll be remembered for Tony taking the piledriver to end it in the future, but there is some good stuff for the future. The tease of the schism for the Don Callis family was great. Powerhouse Hobbs getting injured in what was already not the best match of either man's career tainting what was being touted for the IWGP World Heavyweight Titles first TV defense in the US. Takeshita was teased as a challenger which is exciting but that's for the future. The Gauntlet was an entertaining match, but largely in spite of the match stipulation itself. I think a Gauntlet could work, but maybe just do it the way many Japanese promotions have done it where its a battle royal with pinfall/submissions, which is a better substitute for the old Casino Battle Royal than this is. Not the worst episode, but it was very angle based and the wrestling didn't supplement it well in this case."
adampagesfriend wrote on 25.04.2024:
"a pivotal episode for many reasons and some we may not know until further down the line. once again the women are shining as we see mercedes having another great segment, her and willow upped this feud even more. don callis family all over the episode and becoming a really intriguing stable/storyline. they've wasted no time setting up for double or nothing too. I'm coming around on 'the learning tree' jericho but we'll have to wait and see where this goes. only real bummer was the main event match since hobbs got hurt but everything else was great. bookended with the elite is what really made this episode shine. the entire closing segment with tony khan getting attacked by this new elite is something that will be talked about for years. it was surprising, hilarious, but intriguing as all hell. the storyline implications are endless and it's made aew feel even more must watch."