DeutschEnglish
You are on the public version of the site. | Log In | Register | Password lost?
Name of the event:
ROH Death Before Dishonor 2023
Promotion:
Attendance:
2.898
Broadcast type:
Live
Broadcast date:
21.07.2023
TV station/network:
Bleacher Report Live

Singles Match
Gravity defeats Komander (w/Alex Abrahantes) (10:05)
Samoa Joe (c) defeats Dalton Castle (w/Brandon & Brent) by referee's decision (14:12)
Claudio Castagnoli (c) defeats PAC (18:36)
Athena (c) defeats Willow Nightingale by referee's decision (20:31)

All workers
89.3.69
Current Total Rating (?)
Valid votes: 152
Number of comments: 33
10.0 28x
9.0 67x
8.0 43x
7.0 12x
6.0 2x
5.0 0x
4.0 0x
3.0 0x
2.0 0x
1.0 0x
0.0 0x
Average rating: 8.70  [152]
Average rating in 2026: 8.67  [3]
Average rating in 2025: 9.00  [6]
Average rating in 2024: 8.33  [9]
Average rating in 2023: 8.72  [134]
Your Options:
Other:
Reprise wrote on 08.08.2024:
[8.0] "I thought it was pretty good and overall a very fun show, but nothing blew me away until the main event, which was the real standout for me. It's one of the best women's matches I have seen in years."
RealGrapsThomsen wrote on 01.08.2024:
[8.0] "This was a really fun show, lots of fun multi-man matches and the two world title matches were in ring clinics, especially the womens, Willow and Athena should run it back in the meat future."
Prince Osborne wrote on 22.01.2024:
[8.0] "Despite a few questionable decisions (Joe & Athena retained championships, lack of depth in the six-man pool, etc.), Death Before Dishonor was a rock-solid show with most of the boxes checked for an investable entertainer. Claudio & PAC were rough & tough in their encounter which made me crave for a longer version while the team of Aussie Open was gifted for their white-hot momentum magnetism. There wasn't any lag in the quality as well as the storyline drive/continuity. A 'thumbs up' night for Team ROH! 7.5 out of 10 points!"
otoboke wrote on 01.01.2024:
[6.0] "Best match of the night was obviously Mogul Embassy vs. Leon Ruffin & Six Or Nine. The rest ranged from okay, to good. How this is sitting at 8.69 is beyond me, frankly. Such a score says to me each match is great to banging. There's simply no banging match here, and the vast majority is decent."
Allie wrote on 25.12.2023:
[9.0] "I had the HONOR of seeing this show in person. It was definitely a top 3 PPV of 2023 for me... IMO there wasn't really a low point. I quite enjoyed Kommander v Gravity to start the show. Being a huge Willow fan, I might be a little biased in saying that the main event was by far my favorite match of the night, but it seems like I'm definitely not alone in thinking that. The 4 way tag match as full of excitement, and with the Death Before Dishonor match... there's nothing like seeing a man fall off of a 20 foot ladder through a table."
ISimon1912 wrote on 12.09.2023:
[8.0] "One of the most solid shows of the year and another good PPV from ROH in the Tony Khan era, which is very competent with its main shows. Gravity vs. Kommander (***1/2), Joe vs. Castle: worst match of the night (**), Four Way Tag (****1/4), Six Man Tag (***1/4), Shibata vs. Garcia (****), Fight Without Honor (****1/4), Claudio vs. PAC: match of the night (****1/4), Athena vs. Wiilow (***3/4)"
exzachly wrote on 31.07.2023:
[8.0] "Damn good show. Entertaining throughout that continues to carry the spirit of ROH, albeit with a very modern feel. Each match felt different to the previous, with the last three feeling especially important. Ive really been enjoying these ROH ppvs. Match #1: Gravity v. Komander (**3/4) Exciting and fast lucha libre action to open the night. Great showing out party for Gravity and Komander continues to be a highlight of 2023. While there were a few ropey spots here and there, the action was still thrilling and an enjoyable way to kick the show off. Match #2: Castle v. Joe (**3/4) These two couldnt be any more opposites in terms of character and presentation, yet they each traded holds, suplexes, and strikes in a really nice contest. Castle continues to work his way up to the high status he held in the late 2010s ROH with his charisma and pure entertainment. Match #3: Aussie Open v. Best Friends v. Kingdom v. Lucha Bros (***1/2) All gas, no breaks between four great teams. While this was a multi man spot heavy match at its core, a story was still managed to be told, as every team minus Aussie Open familiar with the other and Aussie Open largely being the wild card. Nice to see them pick up the win as well after having to vacate both the NJPW tag team titles. Match #4: Embassy v. Ruffin & Six or Nine (***) This one surprised me at how entertaining it was despite the lack of story, but its three big men vs. three smaller men. Simple formula that delivered and allowed the Embassy to remain looking strong. Match #5: Garcia v. Shibata (***3/4) Danny Garcia is absolutely a sports entertainer and this arch of him attempting to abandon his roots as a techinal wrestler is far more entertaining than maybe what has been shown in AEW. Great technical exchanges with expert character work, up to the final adherence of the Code of Honor following Shibatas victory. Match #6: Dark Order v. The Righteous (****) This Fight Without Honor was exactly that: a fight, especially involving Uno and Grayson. Dutch and Vincent also are great characters within this story, as it seemed like the battle of two cultic ideologies attempting to conquer the other. Excellent hardcore brawl that had each spot feeling important within the context of both the match and the story. Match #7: Claudio v. PAC (****1/4) When this match was announced, I knew it would be something special and it delivered on all fronts. PAC might be the best seller in the world and Claudio continues to etch his name in the conversation of best ROH World champions. This was fluid but maintained a high level of intensity. Match #8: Athena v. Willow (****1/2) A big fight feel worthy of the main event. There last match on ROH TV was a great match, but this was a war, calling back to that match before devolving into chaos with each woman attempting to win using finishers of past ROH womens legends. I think this match should have seen a title change, but as Athena continues to impress, I cannot complain to see her reign continue. Both of these women are having career-defining years in 2023."
DanTalksRasslin wrote on 29.07.2023:
[9.0] "TK-era ROH continues its trend of overperforming on shows with very little prior build. The double main event here was excellent, with both Athena vs. Willow and Claudio vs. PAC providing great action, and you can kind of take your pick as to which was better (I'd give the women's match a slight preference, but it's really a toss-up). The six-man hardcore match was also notably very good and should help to make both Dark Order and the Righteous at least somewhat relevant again. Overall a great show throughout, and I especially appreciate the variety on display; it was a "little bit of everything" show with a lucha match (Gravity vs. Komander), a technical match (Shibata vs Garcia), a classic pro-wrestling match (Joe vs Castle), a multi-man match (Six Man Tag Title), a multi-way tag (Tag Title match), and the aforementioned hardcore match and two big-time main events; pretty much any kind of fan can find something to like here."
arrancar wrote on 29.07.2023:
[6.0] "Wildly high ratings here for a merely alright show. Komander vs Gravity was really overly showcase-y and messy at times, though there was definitely still some great athleticism and creativity. Ultimately alright. ***. Joe vs Castle was pretty underwhelming. Joe had moments of explosive offence that was fun, but Castle's responses unfortunately weren't that exciting, though still fine, and their chemistry was merely okay. The stuff with The Boys and Stokely was annoyingly distracting, too. **3/4. The ROH Tag Titles 4-way was a standard, good multi-man spotfest. Aussie Open and Lucha Bros were obviously the most flashy and athletic, but The Kingdom deserve credit for being effective heels who were also quite athletic and physical, while Best Friends were mostly uninteresting and still too irony-laden. There were lots of overly cooperative but still pretty fun spots/exchanges throughout, though nothing exceptional. ***1/4. Kaun, Cage & Liona vs Ruffin, Wato & Taguchi had moments where it was uncoordinated, heatless, and poorly paced, but it improved quite a lot as the match went on, since Cage and co. proved to be decently aggressive powerhouses while the babyfaces proved to be endearingly energetic and resilient. ***. Shibata vs Garcia was pretty good and the clear MOTN for me, with Shibata, the legit grappler, dragging Garcia, the faux grappler, to his best ever match. I actually kinda liked Garcia as the slimy, cocky, dorky 'sports-entertainer' heel up against Shibata's 'warrior' attitude, fierce striking, and perfectly applied submissions. Both sold well for each other and had some good trades. A few cheesy and goofy moments but nothing too bad. ***1/4 - ***1/2. The Fight Without Honor 6-man tag wasn't bad but wasn't for me. It was 45% underwhelming weapon/prop spots, 45% underwhelming brawling, and 10% somewhat okay spots and sequences. The tacks and the big table bump off the ladder were decent, but nothing else interested me. **1/2. Claudio vs Pac was quite good. It started slow but developed into some nicely physical and athletic exchanges with good intensity and strong chemistry. They sadly fell into a predictable pattern and pacing as they traded and went for their big spots, but their technique remained really good, and they still had a few pretty creative and impressive sequences. The distraction in the finish was lame, and the match had lost steam by that final 1/4th anyways. ***1/4. Athena vs Willow was perfectly alright at best, with underwhelming chemistry and weak storytelling being the biggest issues. Every would-be 'cool' exchange looked somewhat unconvincing, with Willow mostly being to blame, while Athena, despite having good in-ring work, had annoyingly hokey character work. There were also some normal issues of obvious cooperation and slight sloppiness. The idea of their callbacks to previous ROH women's wrestlers was dumb and needless, and their big-move trades still lacked proper chemistry and impact. ***"
suNn wrote on 27.07.2023:
[9.0] "My only real extent of watching weekly ROH is just having them run at 2x speed just so I know what's happening going into the PPVs like these, because every time I get to a show like this, the quality is consistently high. Only below-average match was for the trios belts and the lucha opener had a few awkward moments, but otherwise a solid event."
outbreakrt wrote on 27.07.2023:
[9.0] "Easy to denigrate for not having that one "oh my god this is the best match ever" moment, but looking at it as a whole this is just an absurd level of quality. 8 matches and 3/4 of them are great to excellent, a huge variety of styles, just plain great wrestling wrapped up into a tight package. It's just insane to see a PPV that is this consistently great and I'm incredibly glad that I decided to throw this on despite not really keeping up with ROH right now."
ParkwayDriver wrote on 24.07.2023:
[7.0] "A show that had a mostly nonexistent build despite three months between PPVs that ended up being around the level of all of the previous TKROH PPVs. The show largely got better as it progressed which was appreciated. Athena/Willow would be my MOTN with the Dark Order match a bit behind it."
The Luke Glazier wrote on 23.07.2023:
[7.0] "Didnt have high hopes for the show due to the lack of build, but feel it did enough of a good job to be considered one of the better PPVs from North America. Kommander v Gravity **.25 Samoa Joe v Dalton Castle **.5 Lucha Bros v Best Friends v Aussie Open v Kingdom ***.75 Taguchi, Master Wato, Leon Ruffin v Mogul Embassy **.25 Shibata v Daniel Garcia ***.5 Dark Order v Stu Grayson, Righteous ***.5 Claudio v PAC ***.75 Willow Nightingale v Athena ****.25"
wenemabandit wrote on 23.07.2023:
[9.0] "I had so much fun attending and rewatching this show. It was exciting all night through, even if there were some matches that weren't really for me. The Main event was incredible, overall just consistently entertaining. I had a damn good time and I will look back on this fondly. Especially for a show that didn't have a lot of build to it, I think they came through and overdelivered on that premise alone."
rgpick wrote on 23.07.2023:
[8.0] "Just about all the matches were very, very good as one would expect with the caliber of talent ROH has. There was little build to most of what went on here and I know some of that was out of TK's control. But not all of it and you need to have some stories to elevate a PPV like this."
Rossg17 wrote on 23.07.2023:
[10.0] "Great PPV, enjoyed every match on the show, with the Main Event being MOTN in my opinion. Gravity vs Komander: Really decent lucha libre style match to open the PPV, Gravity winning was a surprise, some great lucha libre moves in the match (***3/4). Samoa Joe vs Dalton Castle: A decent match, Dalton Castle looked good against a savage like Samoa Joe and towards the end when Samoa Joe had Stokely Hathaway get The Boys ejected from ringside was funny (***3/4). Lucha Bros vs The Kingdom vs Best Friends vs Aussie Open: Fast paced, really good match with quite a few good moments, some great tag team wrestling and all 4 teams managed to look good and get at least one spot in, Aussie Open winning the titles was a good choice (****1/4). Leon Ruffin, Master Wato and Ryusuke Taguchi vs Mogul Embassy: Better than I expected, with the challengers taking as good as they got, but in the end The Mogul Embassy proved why they are a dominant group (***1/4). Katsuyori Shibata vs Daniel Garcia: Great wrestling from both Shibata and Garcia, Shibata giving a masterclass to Garcia, Shibata winning was the right choice (****). The Righteous and Stu Grayson vs The Dark Order: Entertaining but brutal match, lots of brutal moments and the selling from all involved was good as well (****1/4). Claudio Castagnoli vs PAC: Great match, mixture of power and athleticism made for a compelling world title match and and enjoyable watch (****1/4). Athena vs Willow Nightingale: MOTN, amazing Women's World Title match, both brought everything they had in the tank and more, Willow proved she can hang with the best and when she kicked out of the O-Face that was shocking and was on the edge of my seat towards the end of the match, Athena winning was okay but would like to have seen Willow winning the title but still made one of the best women's titles I've seen this year so far (****3/4)"
thesearemypolitics wrote on 23.07.2023:
"Ring of Honor played a big part in getting me into wrestling. While I missed the glory days of Danielson, Joe, and Punk, the Bullet Club, the mid-2010s period with the Elite running roughshod over the company still provided a tight hour of entertainment. The downfall and near death of the company always made me sad. So much history and so long as one of two or three North American alternatives to the WWE monopoly, just lost under the watch of a propaganda network. I got Honor Club a few weeks ago, mostly just to relive the stuff that introduced me to styles other than what the WWE was doing. With Death Before Dishonor, ROH provided subscribers like me a shock with one of the best shows of the year. From the predictably awesome like PAC and Claudio or Willow and Athena to the surprising hits like Dark Order vs The Righteous and even Shane Taylor vs AR Fox on the preshow, the card delivered up and down. The only dead spot for me was the six man titles match, although Taguchi throwing hips was fun. Although the halcyon days of ROH are gone, now being demoted to an existing company's second brand, if shows like this are the result, no one should complain. Absolutely a card that everyone should check out. Also shoutout to Big Stoke for his amazing character work during the TV title match."
SorryImLost wrote on 23.07.2023:
[10.0] "Despite the poor build, injuries and/or unavailable talent for the show, Death Before Dishonor was a fantastic night of pro wrestling. Tony Khan has been booked 5 of these PPV shows now and Im beginning to see the vision that hes trying to go for with this promotion. Tonights show felt like a new spin of the old black and gold NXT Takeover days in terms of match quality while still paying respect to the indies. While AEW maybe the 2nd biggest promotion in the world, ROH has subsequently became the biggest indie promotion like it once was during their peak. Even if you never watched any of the ROH episodic shows leading up to this PPV, if youre a fan of professional wrestling, you would still love this show and find it very enjoyable. It opened up hot with high flying Lucha Libre style wrestling with Gravity and Kommander, Joe and Castle had a decent match that adds a win for Joe on this incredible ROH TV championship run hes having, the 4 way tag team was great with Best Friends and Lucha Bros beginning a interesting feud, a hard hitting technical pure wrestling match between Shibata and Daniel Garcia, a hardcore match that showcased the Dark Order, Claudio and Pac had a fantastic World Championship match that could lead to BCC and Death Triangle mixing it up and the show ended perfect with a master class match between Athena and Willow in what is arguably the greatest womens wrestling match in America. As long as Ring of Honor continues to hit home-runs with their PPV shows like this one, just like NXT use to do with their Takeover shows, then ROH is doing its job perfectly. If youre a fan of pro wrestling then you will enjoy this show. Highly recommend checking it out."
sweezo wrote on 22.07.2023:
[9.0] "The build to this show was lousy and mostly non existent, but judging the show on its own merits this was a fantastic PPV. Athena/Willow was a worthy main event, and Shibata/Garcia was my favorite match for the former since his return from injury. Not a bad match on the card. Well worth your time and $40."
lovallis wrote on 22.07.2023:
[9.0] "THE BAD: This show had virtually 0 build to anything. This should not happen on a Professional Wrestling PPV, especially when you only have 4 a year. / THE GOOD: Everything on the show was fun. One of those shows where the crowd never got tired. I did not give this show a "9" because it is filled to the brim with some of the greatest matches you'll ever see, like a prime G1 show from years ago. I'm giving it a 9 because it is an extremely easy watch for I think any wrestling fan, and will have multiple things you will enjoy. Nothing under 3 stars. I believe 2 over 4 1/4. Give this a watch."
Mahdi wrote on 22.07.2023:
[9.0] "Amazing PPV Full of Great Matches, I Have a Great Hope For KomanderMqtch But It's Not Fun Like Supercard Of Honor Match, Facing Two Wrestler Like Samoa Joe And Dalton Castle was Fun And Entertaining tbh, These Two Have Nothing In Common LOl, I Didn't Expect From Joe To EuckerPunch Dalton Castle But Overall I enjoy This Match, ROH World Tag Team Title Was my Favorite Match, Fast And Entertaining , All four Team Were So Good, I Didn't Expect Aussie To Win The Title, All Four Team Deserves The Title, ROH World Six Man Tag Team Title The Only Random Match And I Didn't Expect To Much From It But it was Fun actually, ROH Pure Title this match was Good But I expected More, Fight Without Honor Match An Amazing Brutal Match, Exactly what I Want from this PPV, Blood And Tables, ROH World Title Main Event Was Amazing Too, Both Wrestlers Did a Great Job And I love The Ending too, Make way for further Story telling, ROH Women's World Title I'm not into woman s wrestling but this Match Was a good Match For Someone who Not interested in Woman's division."
Vinny Santos wrote on 22.07.2023:
[9.0] "A awesome PPV. The build of this could (and should) have been better, but when the bell rang, all the matches delivered something special. Personally, I rate 4 of the 8 matches with at least 4 stars, and I don't remember the last time this happened. Even the "worst" match of the night (ROH World Six Man Tag Team Title Match) was positive and got me invested. Athena and Willow put the performace of their lives there, in the best match women had in America this year, and since women wrestling in America is without much space this year, hardly will be topped."
costa95 wrote on 22.07.2023:
[10.0] "Very good PPV, Aussie open is back and is holding gold, Shibata and Garcia has my heart, fight without honor was brutal, gravity has a lot to offer, the six-man match wasn't a squash so i'm happy, really thought PAC was going to win Claudio but is only the beggining, Joe is champion forever, and the main event was AWESOME."
GetsugaTenshou3030 wrote on 22.07.2023:
[10.0] "Possibly the most consistent and versatile show of the year. The best commentary team in AEW, different types of matches, hot crowd for every match, and every wrestler on the card overdelivering"