[7.0] "A pretty fun show overall. Even though there were several matches which were mediocre, the pacing still felt pretty good and I had no trouble staying interested throughout. The ending of this show is sure to divide opinion with most seemingly leaning towards hating it, but I personally enjoyed it. If you only have time for a few matches, I'd go with the X Division title match, the Call Your Shot Gauntlet (most here seem to have not liked it but I thought it was fun), and Christian Cage vs Josh Alexander. Purazzo vs Mickie James wasn't so bad either."

[9.0] "Great Show! With 3 great matches(Cage vs. Alexander, Deonna vs. Mickie and Maclin vs. ELP vs. Trey), as well as the rest ranging from decent to good(no bad matches), I really enjoyed this show! Other than the Good Brothers retaining, I was cool with the rest of the results. Really interested to see how the Moose/Alexander story plays out...if it ends with Josh getting payback, than I'll be good. Overall, it was another good PPV from Impact!"

[4.0] "The opening (without the knockout's match) and the closing of the show were great, everything else was mostly average and boring. A typical Impact show. IInspiration/Decay (4) Miguel/ElPhantasmo/Maclin (8) HeathRhino/DeanerDoering (3.5) Gauntlet (4) GoodBrothers/BULLETCLUB/FinJuice (4.5) James/Purrazzo (6) Alexander/Cage (8)"

[9.0] "Very strong show, every single match delivered especially the deonna vs mickie, the main event and the x-division title match. The ending was INSANE, I honestly didnt saw it coming at all and even though i really wanted to see josh as champion that moment was one for the books."

[8.0] "Really good event overall. X Division stole the show once again. The knockouts match was great as well and the main event was really good. I'm even a fan of Moose winning at the end. It gives a lot of heat on Moose, especially the photo of him hovering over Alexander and his wife and child after winning. It will give Alexander an even bigger moment down the road. Don't know why some people can't see the storytelling here. Nothing bad at all and some great matches."

"I missed The IInspiration vs. Decay. From what I have seen, this PPV was really good all around. I'm fine with Decay dropping the belts; they are more so psychological predators, benefit from staying in the hunt than holding the gold. The X-Division title match stole the show. EL Phantasmo showing how great he is all day, every day. Maclin outperformed himself. Once his promo starts evolving, he will start making waves. A few years ago, I thought it would be, and was hoping for, Dez to be in this position, Trey showing he's able to be The guy now. I didn't expect much from Heath and Rhino vs. VbD. I hope they don't waste Doering. After the Doc Gallows match, I would like to see him against the other big guys like Cardona, Fulton, and Shera. Call Your Shot was a fun time. Sam getting revenge and eliminating Meyers was great. Good Brothers still holding the titles is disappointing. It was a solid match, and I thought Bullet Club would be the ones to take the belts, not eat the pin. I hope they will have a proper feud after this. It's been teased for a while. Mickie James is starting her retirement tour on a high, and the match was awesome. Deonna is still one of the best. It would have been nice to see her become the new longest reigning champion. Josh Alexander put on one of his best performances with Christian. Moose cashing in so soon, and while Josh's family was still in the ring, is some savage booking. This rivalry with Moose is going to launch him into the stratosphere."

[6.0] "The show was good for something but overall a bit chaotic for my tastes. I think the Moose stuff is even good but already without the momentum he had."

[5.0] "Great card and decent booking heading into Bound for Glory but Impact always goes Impact and finds a way to bungle what could have been an amazing night of wrestling. Watch X-division title match and Mickie vs Purrazzo. The rest wasn't great."

[4.0] "Bad show, very boring with only one really good match (X-Division bout), and the ending is one of the worst of this year"

[5.0] "This show was all over the place, with both good and bad moments throughout. It feels impossible to rate, so I think a 5 is the way to go. Main event was good, however Moose cashes in to become Impact World Champ once again."

"After tag team match, I already started to think this show is the essence of today's Impact Wrestling: simple but logical booking (I even predicted Sam Beale eliminating Bryan Myers before he entered Gauntlet xD) but... not something special, which would give them attention they need so much. It looks like Impact management thought the same, because they completely shocked me by booking of last two matches. They made their young, rising superstar end her historic reign by losing to 42 year old Mickie James who is signed to different company (after awesome match, but still...WTF') and ruined greatest moment of Josh Alexander's career. Shame."

"OK Show. Right people won, The final 2 matches and the X division match were good, but the rest of the matches were below average. The IInspiration debut seemed off to me, Moose winning the gauntlet was the right choice, the Good Brothers retaining wasn't. Mickie winning was a nice surprise, and the ending whilst controversial, and even though I didn't like it at the time, It is a great decision, giving moose a lot of heat, Making Alexander more of a babyface you can get behind, and creates a world title feud for the next few months that doesn't rely on AEW."

[6.0] "Fine show Overall. The X division triple threat and the World Title Match were the highlights of the night. The rest of the matches were decent or passable Didn't really like the cash-in at the end."

[8.0] "Great matches (Alexander vs Cage, women? s title and the X Division title match), good matches (tag titles) and enjoyable filler (Gauntlet and Heath & Rhino vs VBD). I enjoy Impact? s presentation of pro wrestling but something still feels a little small time about the atmosphere at their events. All the same Impact persists with a good roster and good matches and put on a good show. I think Moose was a mistake. I? d be open to giving him a chance in a position they? ve clearly wanted to put him in for a long time but since he is an abuser I am not interested."

[7.0] "If you omitted the gauntlet match and Heath/Rhino vs VBD, this would be rated higher. All the title matches ranged from good to excellent. A lot of very strong wrestling overall. Kind of let down by the poor lighting of the audience stands, visually they needed it to be brighter. It was sold out venue of 1500 after all."

[7.0] "Lot of good wrestling on this show. Few moments that soured me on it, but nothing that kept me from overall enjoying the event. Call your shot gauntlet is what it was. A few really fun moments that stood out and the right man won. The ending match had been fantastic and was set to end the show on a positive note. While I was gutted to see Moose cut in, it fit with his narrative of believing he deserved to be the champion so I can accept it. Tag title match was a dud for me, because the concept of 3 teams but only two men in the ring will never not be awful."

[6.0] "Yes, I gave a 6 to a show that had three matches rated 8. That's because Impact somehow thought it was a good idea to cut Josh Alexander's legs out from underneath him by having Moose cash in on him and take the title immediately. Why? Just let Alexander have a bit of time with the title, plus Moose is a relic of the last few years, not to mention the other baggage from outside wrestling that he brings. It just diminishes Alexander to win something he's already won, plus this was the biggest show of the year, so it's not going to be as big when he wins the title back eventually. Rest of the show was very good with a lot of title changes."