[4.0] "Mis notas de WWE Live Smackville 2019: 1. WWE Intercontinental Title Match Shinsuke Nakamura (c) vs. Ali / ***1/4 (decepción de la noche) 2. Singles Match Elias vs. Kevin Owens / **1/2 (peor lucha de la noche) 3. WWE Title Triple Threat Match Kofi Kingston (c) vs. Dolph Ziggler vs. Samoa Joe / ***3/4 (mejor lucha de la noche) NOTA FINAL: 4 de 10. No se puede decir mucho de un Live Event que fue pasado como "especial" de su network, salvo lo de siempre, que en la previa tenía un cartel decente pero las luchas fueron muy decepcionantes. Una cosa que debo decir es que me hubiera gustado ver los dark match que no fueron grabados, como Black vs Andrade."

[5.0] "This was, like the "Shield's Last Chapter" special, really just the last half of a house show, and with that in mind, it was actually pretty good. Nakamura vs Ali and Owens vs Elias were both good, as was Elias' song segment preceding the latter (and that guitar solo was actually good! ). The main event was also fine as house show main events go, though we've seen plenty of Kofi vs Joe already, and I question the logic of putting Ziggler in there when his last PPV appearance was getting squashed by Owens in seconds at Extreme Rules. "Smackville" also has to be up there with the silliest WWE event names. Overall an OK hour-long show."

[7.0] "Pretty enjoyable for a live WWE Network special. Ali vs. Nakamura is the one match I recommend you see if you only want to see one match from this show, but the rest of the show was enjoyable."

[6.0] "This is a show that existed with matches that happened. (The Elias concert with KO interrupting was the best part) Ali vs. Nakamura (***), KO vs. Elias (**1/4), Kofi vs. Joe vs. Ziggler (**3/4) It's a bit disappointing that The Smackdown Women's Title Triple Threat didn't make it, that sounds like a match people would have wanted to see."