[5.0] "Rough main event here, but the rest of the card is decent I really liked both Danielson matches but what else is new."

[6.0] "A show that's pretty all over the place in terms of quality. There are some really good matches here, like Dragon v Collyer, and Punk v Cabana, but then you also have the clusterfuck that was the 4 way scramble and then the main event which was just very slow and bad, with Homicide and the Carnage Crew obviously compensating because of how immobile Abdullah the Butcher was. It's a show of decently high highs and very low lows and overall, while this show definitely isn't worth watching in full, both the Dragon matches and Punk v Cabana are definitely worth seeking out. MOTN - American Dragon v Chad Collyer"

[7.0] "I'd say this just barely edged out a 7.0, largely because of how much I enjoyed London vs. Dragon, but most of the card is pretty solid. Styles vs. Xavier is a pretty good title match even if Xavier isn't main event material, the two first round tournament matches are solid, the Scramble is one of 2002's better efforts, and Cabana vs. Punk is an interesting piece of history. The main event is ugly, but gave me a laugh, so if you take it for what it is you might get some fun out of it as well. There is quite a lot of diversity in terms of wrestling styles on this card, which kept things interesting. I can understand why you might just stick with London vs. Danielson and skip the rest, but those who watch the full show should be able to find something else that they enjoy."

[6.0] "This show had some great matches, specially the #1 Contender's Trophy Tournament and CM Punk vs Colt Cabana, but the rest of the card was pretty bad. The main event was horrible, Abdullah the Butcher couldn't even move and all they showed was him stabbing the Carnage Crew with a fork. It's bad stuff."

[6.0] "It's a decent show. The only real problem with it is the appearance of Abdullah the Butcher for what would thankfully be his only appearance in Ring of Honor."