[8.0] "A very fun little promotion that's about relaxing and embracing all the silliness of wrestling. As they continue to grow, the mystery of who is on the card isn't as much fun as it was early on. Cecil Nyx, Stu Grayson, and Psycho Mike are going to be there. At this point they should just advertise those 3. They also can only afford to run one tiny venue in Quebec. On the lighter side of gripes, the theme song is a miss. "Mystery Wrestling, it's the best thing" what a fumble. "Myster Wrestling, it's the bestling" was right there. I hope they continue to grow and are able to take it on the road some time."
[10.0] "This promotion is coming the closest to capturing the spirit of PWG in its prime, though a lot more on the comedy. Every single show, every single time, the commentary, the fans, the wrestlers are all just there to have a good time, and that's what they do! But on top of that, there's a lot of really great wrestling in here as well. This is a promotion I watch mainly as an escape from all the drama that we usually see. The only downside? They don't put on enough shows!"
[10.0] "Everything I need in wrestling. Surprises, good matches, ridiculous and original comedy characters, really bad match gimmicks done shockingly well, Evil Uno taking his shirt off on commentary. The shows are a blast, the shows are also completely unhinged. The only downside to it is that its not running every week."
[9.0] "Can we swear here? Who knows. MYSTERY Wrestling is one of the most fun promotions I've attended. Streams live on twitch with special guest commentators. Some of the most fun you'll have watching a show. Only downfall is it's venue's location."