[7.0] "Balor Club was WWE trying to cash in on the popularity of Bullet Club in Japan. I think it works as these three do have good chemistry together and made Balor feel like a bigger deal."
[9.0] "Finn Balor is incredible and the history with Anderson especially made this group really special. Really the only real knock I have is that they wanted to keep Balor as a face, while Gallows and Anderson are able to play that role but excel so much better as heels. The group wasn't pushed consistently enough to leave a long or lasting impression, and I would've loved if they went on a dominant heel run with a lot of title gold."
[5.0] "Never saw Balor as a great fit with The OC and frankly, the version with AJ Styles is better. But this was also a very short-period and didn't had the proper booking. For me a lot of people just rated by their names. It would be interesting to see a proper Bullet Club inspired group in WWE but it was easy to predict that they would choose to not do that."
[5.0] "Balor club was a worse version than the OC. The club would not have had the expected impact. Finn should have joined the OC instead of creating an inferior version."
[6.0] "Never really got into them, they weren't bad but they weren't particularly good either. Kind of just around and you always want a little more than that or I did at least."
[5.0] "Hey it's pretty nice that we gave Finn Balor two people that could take pins for him for a while. That's pretty nice for Finn Balor you know. Not that I blame them. :)"
[4.0] "It's fucking bullshit. That group do nothing, and means nothing. Why that group have rating 8+? FOR WHAT? He dont have good matches, he dont have good segments, it just exists. Group for hype on stupid idiots who waiting real "Bullet Club" in WWE, BUT, its booking kill all what have NOT WWE."
[9.0] "Though they have been booked pretty inconsistently in WWE, all three men have show they are great performers inside the ring. Gallows and Anderson have a great tag team dynamic and are both charismatic and funny outside the ring."
[10.0] "I love Finn Bálor, and I love Gallows and Anderson. They have the chemistry, they have the ring ability, they have mic skills, and it was only a matter of time before the first founder of the Bullet Club and his stablemates came together within WWE. The Balor Club even went over on Raw 25! These guys are one good storyline away from becoming stars. Superstars, even."