| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 11.12.2021 |  |
SAW Tag Team Title: The REP (Dave McCall & Nate Carter) (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) (10:52) PWM Kingdom Come VI - Online Stream @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 2 | 10.12.2021 |  |
Prolific (Isaiah Wolf & Marcus Marquee) defeat The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) (9:20) WAW It Was All A Dream - Online Stream @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 3 | 14.11.2021 | |
The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) defeat Jordan Blade & Masha Slamovich (6:36) PWM Underdogs - Online Stream @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 4 | 19.09.2021 |  |
The Blood Brothers (Maxx Mercy & Savage Sam) defeat The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) (11:43) ULW Heavy Metal: Chasing The Crown - Online Stream @ Boonton Elks Lodge in Boonton, New Jersey, USA |
| 5 | 11.09.2021 | |
MSP (Aiden Aggro & The DangerKid) defeat The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) (10:33) PWM JGeorge's Cinematic Masterpiece - Online Stream @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 6 | 28.08.2021 | |
The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) defeat Azrieal & Trey Felipe PWM Hot AF - Online Stream @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 7 | 03.08.2021 |  |
D2W Tag Team Title: JCruz & Ty Thomas (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) D2W The National Night Out - Event @ Rockaway, New Jersey, USA |
| 8 | 26.06.2021 | |
The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) defeat The Goons (Eel O'Neal & Myles Millennium) PWM Candy Coated Kingdom - Online Stream @ Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 9 | 15.03.2021 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Bar Brawl: Meat Locker (Adam Payne & Wrecking Ball Legursky) (c) defeat Chris Ryan & J-Heru and The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) and The Brick City Boyz (JCruz & Victor Chase) PWM The Ides of March - Pay Per View @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 10 | 13.02.2021 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) vs. The Brick City Boyz (JCruz & Victor Chase) - Double Count Out PWM The Roaring Twenties II - Behind the 8-Ball - Pay Per View @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 11 | 19.12.2020 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Four Way Gauntlet: Adam Payne & Wrecking Ball Legursky defeat The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) (c) and The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) and The Maine State Posse (Aiden Aggro & The DangerKid) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWM Kingdom Come V - Pay Per View @ Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 12 | 28.10.2020 |   |
ACW Tag Team Title: The Rapture (Jay Sky & Richard King) (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Alex Reiman & Steve Off) ACW/WWN Proving Ground - Online Stream @ Gulf in Port Richey, Florida, USA |
| 13 | 07.02.2020 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: JCruz & Ty Thomas defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! D2W Wharton Winter Warfare - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 14 | 18.01.2020 |  |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat The Apostles Of Chaos (Chris Benne & Logan Black) Synergy Tomorrow Comes Today - Pay Per View @ Hillsborough Township, New Jersey, USA |
| 15 | 03.01.2020 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat JCruz & Ty Thomas D2W Dawn Of Champions - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 16 | 21.12.2019 |  |
Filipino Heat (Cabana Man Dan & Daniel Perez) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) Pizza Party Pro Pie Hard - Event @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 17 | 06.12.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat JCruz & Ty Thomas (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! D2W Big Holiday Bash - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 18 | 23.11.2019 | |
Kill The Magic (Aaron Bradley, Mike Donovan & Steve Off) defeat Killian McMurphy, Steven Pena & TJ Crawford PWM We Are Champions - Event @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 19 | 01.11.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: JCruz & Ty Thomas defeat American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! D2W Fallout - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 20 | 19.10.2019 |  |
John J Iradi Memorial Northern Bracket Tag Team Tournament 2019 First Round: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Meat On A Mission (Cheeseburger & Hotdog Starkes) UPWA - Event @ Morris Knolls High School in Rockaway, New Jersey, USA |
| 21 | 19.10.2019 | |
John J Iradi Memorial Northern Bracket Tag Team Tournament 2019 Semi Final: Connor Reilly & Joe Scott defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) UPWA - Event @ Morris Knolls High School in Rockaway, New Jersey, USA |
| 22 | 05.10.2019 |  |
Three Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat The Elements (Iceberg & Pyro Pulse) and Defiance (Chris Cayden & Maximo Suave) WXW C4 Sinister Saturday - Event @ Game Changer World in Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 23 | 21.09.2019 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Four Way: The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) and Pimp That Meath (??? & ???) and Dan Gallagher & Steve Sanders - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWM One Vision - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 24 | 14.09.2019 | |
South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) WXW C4 Tattooing For Autism VIII - Event @ Port Monmouth, New Jersey, USA |
| 25 | 06.09.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat JCruz & Ty Thomas D2W Upgrade - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 26 | 04.09.2019 |  |
Young Dumb N Broke (Griffin McCoy & Jordan Oliver) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (12:19) CZW Dojo Wars #229 - Event @ The Coliseum in Voorhees Township, New Jersey, USA |
| 27 | 02.08.2019 | |
JCruz & Ty Thomas defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) D2W Meltdown - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 28 | 28.07.2019 |  |
Elimination Four Way: Murder By Kicks (Ken Broadway & Matt Travis) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) and The Amazing Graysons (JP Grayson & Tommy Grayson) and The Psycho Drivers (Everett Cross & Smiley) VxS No BitchassNess - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 29 | 21.07.2019 | |
Elimination Four Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat The Devil Noodles (Dave Doll & Liam Jacob Noodle) and Fight Or Die (Chris Barton & Gabriel Skye) and Greatest Man Alive Incorporated (Adrian Santos & Greg Jones) CZW Dojo Wars Super Show 22 - Event @ The Coliseum in Voorhees Township, New Jersey, USA |
| 30 | 15.06.2019 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat The Dungeon Of Gloom (??? & ???) PWM Don't Stop Me Now - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 31 | 30.05.2019 |  |
Team LDN (Alan Lee Travis, Damien Black, Joey Scott, RJ Rude & Zane Bernardo) defeat Team Pro Wrestling Magic (Aaron Bradley, Channing Thomas, SJ Higgins, Steve Off & TJ Crawford) LDN - Event @ Ipswich Corn Exchange in Ipswich, Suffolk, England, UK |
| 32 | 30.05.2019 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat InZanely Rude (RJ Rude & Zane Bernardo) LDN - Event @ Ipswich Corn Exchange in Ipswich, Suffolk, England, UK |
| 33 | 28.05.2019 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Alan Lee Travis & Zane Bernardo LDN - Event @ Lewes Town Hall in Lewes, East Sussex, England, UK |
| 34 | 03.05.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat The Ice Crushers (Connor Reilly & Matty Ice) D2W Mayhem - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 35 | 20.04.2019 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Four On Three Handicap: Kill The Magic (???, Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Higgins' Heroes (???, ???, ??? & ???) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWM I Want It All - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 36 | 05.04.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title Three Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Ike Phillips & Victor Chase and The Ice Crushers (Connor Reilly & Matty Ice) D2W No Foolin' - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 37 | 03.04.2019 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Tough Guy Inc. (Bob Evans & Tim Hughes) UPWA The UPWA Comes To New Jersey - Event @ Wayne Pal Building in Wayne, New Jersey, USA |
| 38 | 22.03.2019 |  |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Everett Cross & TJ Crawford BCW Ann3versary: The Hard Way - Event @ St. Sebastian's Gym in New York City, New York, USA |
| 39 | 16.03.2019 | |
Evan Myers, Jason Carrion, John Tella & Mike Law vs. The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off), Adam Payne & The Meadowlands Monster - No Contest PWM Under Pressure - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 40 | 01.03.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title Four Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat The Filthy Family (Big Cal Stevens & Dirtbag Dan) and The Great Scots (Joe Scott & Kyle Angus) and The Ice Crushers (Connor Reilly & Matty Ice) D2W Battlelines - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 41 | 16.02.2019 | |
John Tella, Shawn Donavan & Steve Gibki defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) & ??? PWM Crazy Little Thing Called Love - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 42 | 01.02.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat The Ice Crushers (Connor Reilly & Matty Ice) D2W Wharton Winter Warfare - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 43 | 19.01.2019 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The Psycho Drivers (Everett Cross & Smiley) (c) defeat Aaron Bradley & Steve Off PWM The Show Must Go On - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 44 | 04.01.2019 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! D2W Dawn Of Champions - Endgame - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 45 | 08.12.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Three Way: The Psycho Drivers (Everett Cross & Smiley) defeat Meat On A Mission (Cheeseburger & Hotdog Starkes) and The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWM Rock And Roll All Nite - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 46 | 07.12.2018 | |
D2W Tag Team Title: The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) D2W Big Holiday Bash - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 47 | 01.12.2018 | |
Three Way: South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) and Defiance (Chris Cayden & Maximo Suave) WXW C4 Bells Will Be Ringing - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 48 | 10.11.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Mustard And Ketchup (??? & ???) PWM Shout It Out Loud - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 49 | 14.10.2018 |  |
American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Defiance (Chris Cayden & Maximo Suave) TOS Training Day 17: Aftermath - Online Stream @ Test Of Strength Dojo in East Hartford, Connecticut, USA |
| 50 | 13.10.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Three Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat The Ugly Ducklings (Lance Lude & Rob Killjoy) and The Psycho Drivers (Everett Cross & Smiley) PWM Creatures Of The Night - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 51 | 05.10.2018 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Jay Suarez & Justin Yeager D2W Honors 2018 - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 52 | 15.09.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: Meat On A Mission (Cheeseburger & Hotdog Starkes) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) by DQ PWM Not For The Innocent - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 53 | 07.09.2018 | |
D2W Tag Team Title Three Way: One Mean Team (Brian Johnson & Justin Pusser) (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) and The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) D2W Upgrade - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 54 | 03.08.2018 | |
The Jersey Muscle Society (Steve Gibki & Tony Vincita) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) D2W Meltdown 2018 - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 55 | 16.06.2018 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Fallah Bahh & Tommy Dreamer PWM Nothin' To Lose - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 56 | 09.06.2018 |  |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Jose & Scotty Priest WOW Extreme Heat 2018 - Event @ Funstation USA in New York City, New York, USA |
| 57 | 02.06.2018 |  |
The REP (Dave McCall & Nate Carter) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) SAW - Event @ Pinelands Regional High School in Tuckerton, New Jersey, USA |
| 58 | 01.06.2018 | |
The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat Fire And Ice (Matty Ice & Red Hot Russ) by DQ D2W Mercury Raising - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 59 | 05.05.2018 | |
Samuel Adams & Syler Andrews defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) WXW C4 - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 60 | 04.05.2018 | |
Matty Ice & Red Hot Russ defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) by DQ D2W Mayhem 2018 - Event @ American Legion Post #91 in Wharton, New Jersey, USA |
| 61 | 21.04.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Jonathan Edward Gale & Olly Lloyd PWM/LDN King of The Nighttime World - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 62 | 21.04.2018 | |
Ten Man Tag Team Rumble: Aaron Bradley, Adam Payne, Steve Gibki, Steve Off & The Meadowlands Monster defeat Alan Lee Travis, Hound Dogg, Jason Carrion, Olly Lloyd & Rex Dangerous PWM/LDN King of The Nighttime World - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 63 | 07.04.2018 | |
Samoan Legacy Cup Tournament 2018 First Round: South Philly's Finest (Jimmy Konway & Luca Brazzi) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) WXW C4 Samoan Legacy Cup Tournament 2018 - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 64 | 07.04.2018 | |
Samoan Legacy Cup Tournament 2018 Qualifying Four Way: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat DOA (Frankie Pickard & Tahir James) and The New Settlers (Angus Bedford & RJR) and The Elements (Iceberg & Pyro Pulse) WXW C4 Samoan Legacy Cup Tournament 2018 - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 65 | 03.03.2018 | |
WXW Elite Tag Team Title: The Zoltan (Kris Kage & Whiplash) (c) defeat The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) WXW C4 - Event @ Allentown, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 66 | 20.01.2018 | |
PWM Tag Team Title: The American Murder Society (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) (c) defeat Fit To Be Tied (Mike Graca & Smiley) PWM Domino - Event @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 67 | 16.12.2017 | |
PWM Tag Team Title Four Way: Aaron Bradley & Steve Off defeat The Down Boyz (Steve Gipke & Tony Scorese) (c) and The Amazing Graysons (JP Grayson & Tommy Grayson) and Glitz And Glamour (Jarrett Foster & Steven Sterling) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWM Kingdom Come II: Copacabana - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 68 | 11.11.2017 | |
Kill The Magic (Aaron Bradley, John Tella & Steve Off) vs. The Amazing Graysons (JP Grayson & Tommy Grayson) & Smiley - Double DQ PWM It's A Miracle - Event @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 69 | 16.09.2017 | |
Kill The Magic (Aaron Bradley & Steve Off) defeat The Down Boyz (Steve Gipke & Tony Scorese) PWM Ready To Take A Chance Again - Event @ Ridgefield Park Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 70 | 17.06.2017 | |
Team PWM (???, Hoost Traplash, Magic, Matt Sells & Triplelicious) defeat Kill The Magic (Aaron Bradley, Matt Ice, Mike Donovan, Ricky Martinez & Steve Off) PWM Could It Be MAGIC? - Event @ Knights Of Columbus Hall in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 71 | 15.04.2017 | |
Kill The Magic (Aaron Bradley, Matty Ice, Mike Donovan & Steve Off) vs. Team PWM (Hoost Traplash, Magic, Matt Sells & Triplelicious) - No Contest PWM Made It Threw The Rain - Event @ Knights Of Columbus in Ridgefield Park, New Jersey, USA |
| 72 | 19.03.2017 | |
Aaron Bradley & Steve Off defeat The StepDads (Radley Belmont & Wade Krueger) WOW A Day As A Warrior - Event @ Funstation USA in New York City, New York, USA |
