| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 07.04.2024 - today | Forever Rivals World Conquest Champion | 677 days | Matches |
| 21.11.2023 - 04.01.2025 | OVW National Heavyweight Champion | 410 days | Matches |
| 02.12.2023 - xx.xx.2024 | Premier Men's Champion | ? | Matches |
| 27.08.2023 - 31.08.2024 | NWA Worlds Heavyweight Champion | 370 days | Matches |
| 07.04.2023 - 09.07.2023 | NWA National Champion | 93 days | Matches |
| 09.07.2021 - xx.xx.2022 | ARW Heavyweight Champion | ? | Matches |
| 22.09.2019 - 22.09.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion (4x) | <1 day | Matches |
| 21.09.2019 - 21.09.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion (3x) | <1 day | Matches |
| 20.09.2019 - 20.09.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion (2x) | <1 day | Matches |
| 24.06.2019 - 24.06.2019 | WWE 24/7 Champion | <1 day | Matches |
| 05.07.2017 - 10.11.2017 | Impact Grand Champion (as Ethan Carter III) | 128 days | Matches |
| 16.10.2016 - 14.01.2017 | WC Ringmaster Champion (as Ethan Carter III) | 90 days | Matches |
| 09.04.2016 - 24.09.2016 | HOG Heavyweight Champion (as Ethan Carter III) | 168 days | Matches |
| 05.01.2016 - 08.01.2016 | TNA World Heavyweight Champion (2x) (as Ethan Carter III) | 3 days | Matches |
| 25.06.2015 - 04.10.2015 | TNA World Heavyweight Champion (as Ethan Carter III) | 101 days | Matches |
| 12.08.2010 - 04.11.2010 | FCW Florida Tag Team Champion (as Derrick Bateman; with Johnny Curtis) | 84 days | Matches |
| 12.09.2008 - 13.12.2008 | Firestorm Pro Heavyweight Champion (as Michael Hutter) | 92 days | Matches |
| 28.05.2006 - 13.10.2006 | AIW Absolute Champion (as Michael Hutter) | 138 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| AIW Absolute Championship | 138 days |
| ALW World Heavyweight Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| FCW Florida Tag Team Championship | 84 days |
| Firestorm Pro Heavyweight Championship | 92 days |
| Forever Rivals World Conquest Championship | 677 days |
| HOG Heavyweight Championship | 168 days |
| Impact Grand Championship | 128 days |
| NWA National Championship | 93 days |
| NWA Worlds Heavyweight Championship | 370 days |
| OVW United States Championship | 410 days |
| Premier Men's Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| TNA World Championship (2x) | 104 days |
| WC Ringmaster Championship | 90 days |
| WWE 24/7 Championship (4x) | <1 day |
