Toni Storm

[10.0] "One of the great characters in all of wrestling, and she gave us one of the great feuds in all of wresling, all the while solidifying the AEW Womens World Title in my mind as a great fucking title. Her work was always on the cusp of a breakout, she was always excellent in-ring, but the timeless one is where she truly became something of a legend. She's earned a 10, as I truly believe the Timeless Toni gimmick will live forever."

[9.0] "One of the greatest characters in wrestling as Timeless Toni Storm. Not among the absolute best in-ring, but can have very good matches with right people and works hard to make things interesting."

[8.0] "She is a terribly underrated wrestler. The way WWE treated her was absolutely disgraceful--it's one for the history books. She could easily have been a top champion on the weekly shows, but why bother, right? She did great work in NXT and NXT UK, but never got a proper shot after moving to the main roster. It's a good thing she moved to AEW, because she looks fantastic there. Her character, booking, and title situation are five times better than what she had in WWE. Her feud with Mariah May is the highlight of her career (IMO). I hope she shows even more down the line and proves to WWE why they should have backed her. Her AEW gimmick is pure gold. I can't remember the last time a gimmick like this worked so well. Does she have what it takes? She sure does."

[6.0] "Toni Storm has been poor for her entire career prior to WWE, with WWE and AEW and then she got real good at the beginning of last year just so she can get back to her poor performances again for the last almost 11 months"

[10.0] "Toni Storm's reinvention is one of the best ever. She didn't just put on a bandana and cut her hair or grow it long and wear a kerchief, she completely changed her look, style, and promos. She went from solid hand to leading the division. Her promos have panache and flair and have yet to get stale. She's not featured in women's main event feuds every week like others in other places which is why she's still great."

[4.0] "Never understood the appeal. Her TCM (Turner Classic Movies) gimmick and having a black-and-white entrance get-up for her AEW run got stale extremely fast. Not all that great on the mic, generic Aussie accent and doesn't do anything she can say and do, that would make you want even more from her. If it wasn't for the fact that she had a rabid fanbase like "she can wrestle and doesn't have fake boobs! " I felt that she would be thrown out the door and be forgotten about as like say Jillian Hall. She did have a few good matches on the indie scene worth noting about but, her "Timeless" (or whatever it's supposed to be called) just didn't do anything that maybe perhaps other girls could do with a gimmick like that and make it even better. if someone else had that gimmick, would she pull it off even better than Toni? Maybe...but, alas I can't say I'm fan at all."

[7.0] "Toni Storm is one of AEWs big success stories, a genuine star in the wrestling world and one of the most visible female wrestlers in the world. She's pretty good in the ring, not show stealing but good."

[10.0] "Like always, WWE forfeit a generational talent because they book her wrong. AEW change her character to one that fits her perfectly, and she becomes a once in a lifetime talent. Insanely good in & out of the ring."

[10.0] "Toni storm is the definition of "the complete package". Since late 2023, she's been the best part of the women's division and the only person that's debate for that is Mercedes Mone, imo. While her first matches during her timeless weren't the best, her character work and promos have always been top notch. Since 2024 she's also been having incredible matches. Her feud with Mariah May is what I consider to be the best feud in women's wrestling history in north america. Apart from Mariah May's reign being transitional. Everything she and Mariah did felt top notch. She's one of the best promos today, they're yet to feel stale or repetitive. She's going to be heavily missed for the rest of 2026."

[9.0] "I became a fan of Toni pretty much the second I laid eyes on her even though I could see where criticisms of her work at the time came from, however since becoming Timeless she has just completely stepped it up another level from there. Easily the best character work in wrestling currently and her feud with Mariah May should go down as one of the best of all time. Aside from that, she seems to get better and better in the ring with every match, which is awesome to see. Easy to forget she's only 30 as well which I hope means she's still got decades left in the tank."

[10.0] "Toni was already very cool and a great wrestler for some time before creating one of the best characters that wrestling has ever seen. Many wrestlers are cool or good at wrestling, but very few are able to craft a gimmick that is much more interesting than that. She has since evolved the character in so many different ways that I have complete faith in her abilities to carry it on for many years to come. I don't know how long it will be before men and women have equal time on the card, but Toni has brought that day forward significantly. More mental and campy gimmicks in wrestling please, we have enough badasses and cool wrestlers."

[9.0] "Her character isn't my cup of tea, but you can't argue she's the most over woman in AEW and maybe most over person period. I appreciate the commitment to the gimmick and think she is a fantastic worker in the ring. She's understands how to put a match together and has had some of the better matches of the last few years. Her promos can be very good, but can also be quite absurd and rely on shock value instead of substance. Gimmick is getting sort of stale and needs something new before the crowd inevitably turns on it."

[7.0] "Incredible adherence to kayfabe and character, but the character in question has gotten stale and quite frankly cringe beyond belief over the last few months. Toni storm is incredibly talented in ring and on the mic, but her promos tend to go off into just lame directions that pop very few people. Still, her work as Timeless toni storm was incredibly fun to watch as it started and grew."

[9.0] "Arguably the wrestler with the best gimmick in the entire decade. The woman that made what can be consider the first revolution for woman wrestling at AEW, Toni motherfucking Storm ladies and gentleman. Never was a huge fan of her, her rock n roll gimmick never caught my attention (and I'm a rock n roll guy) for me consider her a wrestler proper for world title levels. Leave WWE and join AEW clearly changed her to best, her Timeless gimmick is so much fun and can be extended until how long she wants it to be. Exhale charisma, started kinda raw in ring but for some reason after the match against AZM on Collision, she started cooking. Legendary feud and match with Mariah May (god rest her soul) and I hope we have much more to come."

[9.0] "Toni has one of the best characters in AEW, she's so entertaining to watch and she's also very great in the ring. Toni before this timeless gimmick was fine already, but when she became timeless, everything changed for the better for Toni. She's also very lovable and very goofy as well, both of those combine really well. Also, she became incredible on the mic with this timeless gimmick"

[6.0] "The timeless gimmick Toni is doing was good, but it's gotten old now. She has sacrificed a lot of her in ring talent to make the character work and it's let to her becoming extremely boring, none of her matches interest me at all."

[10.0] "I would've already given Toni a 9 in 2021 because I love her in-ring style but after completely re-inventing herself, she's become one of the best parts of wrestling. I enjoyed the Timeless gimmick from the start but disliked how much it hurt her ring work, but since turning face, she has created a great balance where her ring work is back to being great. She seems like such a likable person too."

[10.0] "Timeless Toni Storm is easily the best gimmick in ALL of wrestling at the moment if not top 5 all time. She is just so consistently perfect. Her promos are special, EVERY, TIME. She builds her matches so effortlessly to a point where you can't NOT look forward to and watch it. Now, her in-ring ability is just as good. Even with AEW's truly fantastic women's division, she still excels and puts on clinics very often. She just turned 30 and the wrestling world should be extremely appreciative of what she has done and with how much is left for her to do. We. Are. Blessed."

[9.0] "As someone who was relatively underexposed to good women's wrestling before AEW's arrival, Toni Storm is one of the most notable women's performers I've been able to watch consistently. An amazing promo and quite the worker, and has had multiple amazing matches so far during her AEW run. Along with this what I have consumed of her Japanese career has been great as well. My favorite Toni Storm moment is her match with Mone, and I will always remember watching it for the first time. In total, amazing."

[10.0] "The greatest women's character in the history of professional wrestling & its not even close. Toni is truly the total package & when is all said & done can very well end up being the greatest of all time"

[10.0] "She might be my all-time favorite female wrestler. I've never been fascinated by a female wrestler ever before like ''Timeless'' Toni Storm. She is an absolute icon of the business. The greatest female gimmick in wrestling history already. She's women's wrestling's The Rock when it comes to charisma. I've never seen any woman with such a unique charisma as hers. Also. she's a beast on the mic when it comes to cutting a promo, segment, or a vignette. Furthermore. an amazing wrestler in the ring with such brilliance in different styles especially Joshi-esque and hardcore. And she's only 29 years old. By the time she retires, she will go down as one of the top 10 greatest females in the sport. Chin Up, tits out, and watch for the shoe."

[8.0] "There have been *very few* wrestler rises in the 2020s as satisfying and as fun-to-watch as Toni Storm's has over the past few years. Take a look at where Toni Storm was at the beginning of the decade versus where she is now to get a good idea. Originally, Toni Storm was someone who had great potential, her in-ring work along with her Power Rangers-adjacent theme made for a good wrestler to look out for, but things didn't go necessarily correct for Toni and eventually she ended up in AEW. Her beginning there was good but it wouldn't be until late 2023 where Toni Storm would leave the horrendous stable known as 'The Outcasts' and went out on her own to show the world that her potential was limitless, and of course, TIMELESS (no pun intended)! When Toni started with the Timeless character, it was an immediate hit and she won back the world championship not so long after losing it. Her feuds with the likes of Mariah May and Mercedes Mone were cool to watch and credit where credit is due, the matches she's had with them were great, even though her other matches have been lackluster and forgettable at best unfortunately. The Timeless character is just amazing though, take a look at the content she has had with Muscle Malcolm, Denise Salcedo, even the post-show scrum reporters; Everything Toni has done and said during the interviews have been fantastic and a breath of fresh air. I am a Jamie Hayter fan but I wouldn't disagree with anyone who says that Toni Storm is a lock for AEW Women's Wrestler of the decade, she has to be near the top after all. Great work all-around by Toni Storm and I will say this; Give Toni a Tony Award!"

[10.0] "Good worker, very young, good looks and charisma. Her move-set is a little underwhelming, but is showing she can adapt over time. I'll be interested to see where she winds up in a couple years, but definitely has the potential to be a huge player. **EDIT** this was before the Timeless gimmick, this woman has completely turned her career around and if she keeps this up, she will be known as the best gimmick in women's wrestling history."

[8.0] "One of my favourite female wrestlers ever. She's good in the ring and also outside. Her promos are cool, she's pretty, she's classy and she has a cool gimmick. And she definitely knows how to be provocative! Love her."

[10.0] "Toni Storm is one of the most complete women's wrestlers of all time. Early in her career she mixed athleticism with crisp technical wrestling, but what makes her stand out today is her mastery of in-ring psychology, character work, and promo ability. She has proven herself across the globe from Stardom in Japan (where she won the Cinderella Tournament, the 5? Star GP, and became the first foreign World of Stardom Champion) to WWE (winning the 2018 Mae Young Classic and the NXT UK Women's Championship), and now AEW, where she has become a record-setting Women's World Champion multiple times. Her accolades are endless: Stardom MVP, Mae Young Classic winner, ESPN's Female Wrestler of the Year (2024, tied with Roxanne Perez), and a career filled with 4-5 star matches, including one of the most brutal and bloody matches ever against Mariah May. On top of that, her "Timeless" persona has turned her into easily AEW's biggest attraction, polarizing to some, but unforgettable to everyone. I have heard many people say they watch AEW only to see Toni Storm. Whether you love her style or not, Toni Storm is one of the most prominent wrestlers of this era, and easily one of the biggest reasons people tune into AEW."

[3.0] "I've never liked toni storm and her new character while at least something unique is so absurdly overrated. She is bad at promos, she always was but now they promote a sense of cringe i can't express with words. She is bad at wrestling, can't keep a pace and can only hit big moves which for some reason is seen as something impressive. I just have never enjoyed a single toni storm match because i don't think she has the in ring abilities to make it happen and when one of her matches delivers is usually becaus the other part is way too good"

[10.0] "She's the full package: 10/10 gimmick, 10/10 in-ring ability, 10/10 mic work, and a 10/10 reign that proves she's TIMELESS."

[10.0] "Literally the reason i started watching aew, she was always very good in ring especially during her nxt era but since she switched to aew and started her "timeless" gimmick her promos are incredible, one of if not the best female speaker in pro wrestling, we can also include to her acollades being part of the best woman feud of the decade with Blake Monroe (fka mariah may). Let's hope AEW continue making her the face of the company because she really deserves her flowers."

"This wrestler is awesome! Toni creates here performence in to another world. The gimmick of here is also awesome, maybe the best women wrestler right now ?"

[10.0] "Best character in wrestling currently, could have an interesting storyline with a piece of paper. The courage it must have took to go from her past self to this one was great to see and it has paid off tenfold. Long may it continue, she deserves all the praise she has received."

[9.0] "She was great everywhere: Independent, AEW, WWE etc. But I think she could be a main-eventer in WWE, how she was good booked and her feud against Charlotte. Anyway, she's one of the faces of woman's division in AEW and champ"

[8.0] "Oooh I'm not sure about this one. Toni Storm is a great talent, both in the ring and outside. She's charismatic, can cut a promo and is almost the full package. BUT the Timeless gimmick isn't working anymore. It was fun at first, but got stale after a few months. It reached it's peak during the May feud as that stuff was fully amazing. But the gimmick just..... doesn't work for me. I find it to be too much in all aspects and I actually feel like it's dragging down Toni Storm more than it's elevating her. But not to take anything away from her, she had one of the best feuds of women's wrestling ever and as I said is a total package."

[9.0] "Toni Storm is one of the best wrestlers of her generation. She combines strong striking, crisp technique, and an undeniable star presence. Whether in the UK scene, WWE, or AEW, she consistently delivers matches that feel important. Her "Timeless" character in AEW has unlocked a new level of charisma and character work, making her segments as entertaining as her in-ring work. Few wrestlers adapt as smoothly across styles and promotions as Toni Storm has shown she can."

[10.0] "Toni is an icon with the best wrestling gimmick I've seen since the Wyatt Family back in 2014. Toni's in-ring skills are also top notch, and she's recently had one of the greatest feuds in recent memory (with Mariah May, another amazing wrestler). Toni deserves all the awards and recognition she's getting. Hope to see her on the silver screen someday."

[10.0] "The women's GoAT. I really can't think of any female wrestler with the combination of talents she has. She's a brawler in the ring who redefined herself as maybe the most interesting character in wrestling history. She's beautiful, hilarious, amazingly physical in the ring, amazing on the mic, and even funnier on commentary. Her recent "Hollywood Ending" will be an all-timer for women's matches as well. Easiest 10/10 there is."

[10.0] "Toni is one of the most entertaining wrestlers in AEW right now. Her promos are a hoot, she is great on commentary and most importantly she is having good matches. Her Timeless character is one of the bes runs of all time and her feud with Mariah is an all timer as well."

[10.0] "One of the greatest wrestlers of all-time. Not only is she one of the best in between the ropes, her unique gimmick is one of the greatest I've ever seen. Like Undertaker did in the 90s, Toni is proving that heavily-gimmicked wrestlers can be taken seriously and have success as top wrestlers. Currently, she feels like one of the biggest stars in wrestling. She constantly gets the biggest pops, and when she's on TV, you pay attention. A true treasure and gift to wrestling fans everywhere."

[10.0] "Without a doubt, one of the best women's wrestlers working today, and one of the best characters ever to feature in wrestling. This past 2 years has solidified Storm in the history books of wrestling, a place that she has earned over and over. Her promos are fire, her matches are excellent, her character is perfection."

[10.0] "Fantastic all around wrestler. She perfected her craft in terms of the gimmick, character and promos but was struggling with in-ring performances but ever since she came back from her hiatus, she's having incredible matches as well. She's exceptional and is on the run of a lifetime, AEW is lucky to have her."

[10.0] "Toni Storm was good in NXT UK and fine enough in NXT/main roster WWE. She was fine when she started out in AEW too. A solid pick up, in spite of being part of the awful Outcasts group. She's been decent in the ring whilst rarely being spectacular. However, since morphing into "Timeless" Toni Storm she has become something else entirely. The highlight of the AEW women's division, which has gone from strength to strength whilst the men's side of things has floundered. She has delivered a number of memorable moments, outstanding promos and in the feud with Mariah May, a trio of great matches capped off by one of the very best American women's matches ever. She deserves all her flowers."

[10.0] "Talk about a gimmick develop! Toni Storm often wrestles as a generic rocker girl, nothing too flashy, but didn't stand from the rest. Timeless was her masterpiece if we talk about her character in the ring, it's just amazing. She makes every show memorable and sparks them with that "cinema" style. Her moveset may not be the most technical but she sure knows how the get the job done"

[9.0] "the next big thing in woman's wrestling. such a goat of the wrestling industry. timeless Toni my queen!"

[8.0] "One of the greatest character workers in the business, the only reason I don't give her a 10 is because she sometimes let her gimmicks hurt her matches"

[10.0] "One of the best wrestling characters of this decade with the wrestling chops to back it up. She was able to invent the Timeless Toni character and seamlessly integrate it into every single detail of her persona, matches, and promos. Genuinely hilarious promo. Her feud with Mariah May is one of the best AEW feuds of all time."

[10.0] "Toni Storm shines as a genuinely great and entertaining wrestler. Her "Timeless Toni Storm" persona stands out, arguably the best female gimmick today. Beyond the captivating character, she's a skilled in-ring performer. Her ability to blend compelling character work with exceptional wrestling talent makes her a top performer. She's a complete package, delivering both entertainment and athletic prowess."

[10.0] "One of my personal favorite wrestlers to watch is Toni Storm. She is the type of wrestler that people will one day hold a measuring stick up to for character work. An incredible character that mixes the over-the-top antics of wrestling with a serious nature of emotions. An absolute beast of a wrestler that has put on some banger matches with the likes of Mariah May, Jamie Hayter, Mina Shirakawa, etc. Toni Storm is overall a timeless performer who is one of the best to ever step foot in a pro-wrestling ring and will go down as such."

[9.0] "An excellent wrestler, she is so compelling, both through her character work / storylines, to also having great matches, williing to do a lot."

[8.0] "Very promising in the ring, gets good matches out of some pretty awful wrestlers. Wish we could see more of her. Now that she's champ again, maybe we will. Not much of a promo, I prefer her as babyface. They've got her with Ruby and Saraya now who can make up for her lack of promo skill. Hopefully some longer matchups with Jamie Hayter or someone like Athena will occur during this title run. Best you can hope for is 8 minutes on Dynamite and maybe a match right before the main event of an ppv that lasts fucking four and a half hours. Not familiar with her WWE work and she seems like someone who would do quite well in Japan. She has a pretty highly rated stardom run... EDIT: After a couple of years of her "timeless" gimmick, I'm re-evaluating her on promos, bumping that to a B+ and her overall score to an 8. B gimmick, A- worker, B+ on promos."

[8.0] "Toni has improved incredibly in her, with this character she has exceeded all my expectations, I love how she makes the character stand out and look fun to watch. In the ring I see her much better as time goes by, without a doubt the face of the AEW women's division."

[10.0] "One of the best in-ring workers in the game today and Timeless Toni Storm is a really good gimmick. Her growth as a performer from the time she was in the Outcasts to now is really good to see(she was the standout in that group too so it makes sense)."