Butcher

[6.0] "Probably I am one of the few person in the entire world who loved the Butcher and Blade tag, miss them everyday since Blade had a back injury. Butcher as a single wrestler is just okay. Clearly he is better with his partner. Cool gimmick and presentation tho."

[8.0] "Thought he had a solid but short lived reign as AEW world champion. The fans love him, bought ice cream cream for the arena on his debut night! I'll always have a soft spot in my heart for him!"

[3.0] "Short career, but he is very much done. He looks like someone who no longer has anything new to show, like someone who has fallen to a point of no return. His age was never helpful in his career and currently his matches are extremely slow and with clumsy movements, he usually looks lost in the ring most of the time."

[6.0] "Good big man in the ring. He has not impressed me on the mic or with charisma. Has found a good role as a tag team specialist with the Blade. He has been a part of some really good tag matches in AEW but has not made an impact as a singles competitor."

[9.0] "perfect wrestler for his size, and he looks amazing and powerful everytime he steps on that ring, the guy is just great."

[7.0] "For the few years of experience he has in wrestling, he is doing very well. Aside from being a wrestler, he occupies his free time as a guitarist for a Rock group, that's the reason for his inconsistency."

[7.0] "Very interesting big man with a fitting character but I don't know what he has to offer since he started his career late for his age but I wish him well."

"Butcher, Blade and Bunny seem like the only good fit for the Hardy Family Office stable as they're money hungry mercenaries. If they were the only team in the faction it'd be easier to feature them as credible contenders for the tag team championships, which is their rightful spot."

[6.0] "You ever look at a guy and think "This guy just looks like a wrestler"? That's the Butcher. He couldn't have picked a better gimmick for himself. In the ring I don't mind him at all-- a heavy style and he makes it look good. He's likely best suited as a tag guy, but he does his job well."

[7.0] "He might have the best look in wrestling right now. The kind of wrestler you want to watch on appearance alone, in the ring he really gets his role, would love to see more of him to get a better idea of his ability."

[6.0] "Has a good & unique look. AEW really should consider taking him & Blade more seriously & stop booking them to lose. He's a guy I want to see more from. He's no spring chicken, so time is not on his side."

[5.0] "Very strong look, but lacking in presence. Solid big man worker but nothing special, works best when the spotlight isn't on him."

[7.0] "Great look, and has a pretty good brawling style, with some low-key technical ability as well. I could see him having a nice solo career, but that has to start pretty soon, cause even though he's only been wrestling since 2016, he's already 43, so he doesn't have too much time left. He looks like a badass though and carries himself as one, and that's what you want to see in wrestlers, instead of dudes that look like fans doing wrestling cosplay. Have rarely heard The Butcher talk, but he has a great way of emoting with facial expressions and such."

[8.0] "Andy Williams has everything going for him. His powerhouse wrestling style is very entertaining and refreshing for the us indy scene. He also has a very cool appearance, a scary looking man. He has been doing great stuff with Pepper Parks, with whom they are known as The Butcher and The Blade. Williams could have a bright future ahead of him."