[5.0] "She has good stuff IN THE RING, however I just dont see anything that really makes her stand out gimmickwise/characterwise /storywise. You see the thing with CHIKARA is that you could have the most green wrestler with the most blandest stuff and they can instantaneously get over in the company. Edith was no except, but since going fully on the indies with this new name, its just..what happened? If she does get signed somewhere, shes going to need MAJOR work thats not workrate/in-ring abilities."
[8.0] "Formerly known as Still Life With Apricots And Pears in Chikara, Edith is a pretty talented grappler who has had a following in the Northeastern US, but seemingly hasn't managed to break through into a more national audience. She could use some more training in terms of promos, but she already got her wrestling style down pat, and will be hoping to make a name for herself in the coming years."
[7.0] "Edith Surreal is an overlooked wrestler, seemingly corralled to small Northeastern independents. She carries with her a unique presence, and her grappling can be absolutely vicious. She deserves more looks and opportunities to see what she can do."
[8.0] "I really didn't think much of her as Still Life in CHIKARA, but this is one of those times where the gimmick was holding her back. Since CHIKARA's suspension, she's come into her own as Edith Surreal with cool gear and cooler technical wrestling moves. A breakout is waiting to happen if she gets the platform."
[7.0] "I haven't followed Edith as closely since she left CHIKARA and changed the Still Life name and gimmick, but the matches I manage to catch are entertaining technical bouts. I don't think she had many standout promos in CHIKARA and I haven't heard anyone talk about her promo work as anything noteworthy, but her overall character and aesthetic combined with her wrestling ability makes her stand out amongst other indie wrestlers."
[9.0] "Edith Surreal is surely one of my favourite wrestler right now. A very good Techniker, who can invest me in basically every of her match. I really hope she will continue to improve herself in the future and that she will be a big name in the indys."