[6.0] "Haley J has a ton of charisma and knows how to get the crowd going. She is a solid second-generation superstar in the ring. Biggest issue is her character might not be something that attracts a lot of the bigger companies. Still young and has a ton of potential to grow and get bigger opportunities."
[7.0] "She's brimming with charisma and attitude, which makes her instantly engaging in the ring, but her bell-to-bell work still needs refinement. JCW provides a consistent platform, yet facing the same opponents in similar matches limits her growth. There's clear potential, and reports of WWE interest highlight that; with the right opportunities, she could develop into a true star. For now, she's improving steadily, just at a slow pace."
[9.0] "Saw her on Netflix show Wrestlers and loved her, hope she becomes one of the worlds best.Great heel and her feud with her mum was class.So overall, one of the USAs best, OVWs finest and great wrestler, I hope she becomes the best."
[7.0] "I am not sure why people are rating Haley J this highly at this point in her career. I struggle to think of any wrestler in history, male or female, whom I would rates 9 out of 10 three years into their career. That said, Haley has a lot going for her and is impressive."
[5.0] "From what I've seen of her work, she is packed full of charisma and attitude but needs to work on her bell to bell work. Staying in OVW where she will seemingly face the same people in the same type of matches with the same crowd can only do so much for her. I remember reading the news of her having interest from WWE and I really wish they would have signed her so she could grow into a real star and gain the experience and skill, but for now she is still there just very very slowly improving."
[8.0] "Despite her size, Haley is one tough woman who can mix it up with any of the other women on the roster and take a true hit every now and then. Also a very charismatic wrestler allowing for the producers to make a nice broad range of story lines for her."
[4.0] "Haley J is so charismatic and has a lot of personality. She's a big character. She's a natural with her personality. As a wrestler she really needs to get out of OVW and travel. She has a lot of fundamentals but getting out and around would help her a lot. She feels stagnant where she is as a character and wrestler"
[9.0] "9.0 Haley J is an absolute master of the promo. At her young age it's amazing how well she connects with the crowd, either heel or face, in exactly the way she means to come off, and has them esting of of her hand immediately. Her in ring style is good old fashioned Memphis-style technique + brawling. Watch this one- she was #bornbetter ."
[9.0] "She is one of my favorite female indy wrestlers. So good on the mic and great in the ring as well. Never gotten to see her live, but I've seen clips from IWA MS and OVW and more recently it was really cool to see her in a couple Dark matches on AEW."
[5.0] "A decent wrestler with a lot of potential despite her inexperience. Her biggest barrier is her trashy and borderline racist gimmick. She imitates AAVE and relies on negative tropes of African Americans to generate a response. If she wants to move out of OVW and onto a national wrestling stage, she needs to change her attitude and repackage her character completely. She has talent and charisma, but gimmicks like this don't belong in 2021 (nor did they ever)."