[9.0] "Extremely underrated wrestler and champion who is also one of the most consistent workers in the division and hasn't had a single below average title defence so far. Deserves more credit for her in-ring work"
[8.0] "Surprised she isn't rated higher. Very solid offence in the ring, great at telling a story through her matches, and great sense of her own character. Very good worker who would be massive asset to any division."
[7.0] "I think she's quite above average. She can at least speak into the mic and is somewhat charismatic. Though, her action in the ring is really good. She could pull out good matches as a champion. I liked her match with Lola, Tatum, and Kendal. I wouldn't mind her as a champion."
[3.0] "It would be foolish to deny the fact that she has basic ring skills, but Jacy does nothing to stand out from her special contemporaries such as Sol Ruca, Giulia, Vaquer or Jordynne Grace. Her ability to tell any sort of story in-ring is nonexistent, & Fatal Influence was the shit of nightmares, I can't remember a single match that stood out for me with that stable. Her promos are dime a dozen & stale AF. Add to this the fact that she has now sustained 2 injuries in 2 years, & that makes her an injury prone bore of a worker whom knows her 10 moves & wouldn't know a lick of psychology if it were to kick her in the face. It's amazing that she's this bad after 9 years; one would figure that in 9 years, you'd pick up a lick of psychology, even accidentally! She should consider taking up a different sport."
[8.0] "I've always been a fan of Jacy, she's charismatic and looks like a star. But recently she has really taken that next jump. She knows what she's doing in the ring, and she plays her role very well."
[4.0] "Jacy is fine but just that. She doesnt really excels in anything. She just fine in the ring and on the mic. If she wasnt the leader for Fatal Influence I honestly think she would've ended up like Gigi. The other girls she's with have way more potential than her. Also that second title run was so unnecessary. They didnt let Tatum have her moment. Tatum and Izzi could've had a title feud."
[8.0] "I liked her. I hadn't seen her before. A friend of mine who also watches WWE introduced her to me. I felt sorry for her when she and Naomi got into an argument. I was hoping she'd become closer friends with Bianca because of it, but unfortunately, she disappeared. Overall, she's a great wrestler and has great fighting skills."
[1.0] "Am I missing something with her? NXT's women division is by far the deepest division they have and they give HER the belt not once but TWICE. Can't wrestle, nothing special on the mic, just put the belt on Monroe or Grace, or Ruca, or Zaria, or Tatum or anyone else besides the people in fatal influence."
[10.0] "Jacy was my favorite member of toxic attraction and is my favorite member Fatel influence. she's underrated in everything, promo skills, wrestling skills, her looks. she has great facial expressions. I was very happy when she became the Nxt women's champion and was sad when she lost it(still happy for Tatum) she should have held the tna knockouts championship longer. she's been my favorite wrestler this year and I am happy for all her success."
[4.0] "She just doesn't have it and I'm not quite sure what NXT see in her to justify a near 6 month title reign. She has been in NXT for a longer time than Wes Lee was and she still doesn't seem in any position to be called up. She always seems to be the one that survives cuts and I'm not sure why because in a number of instances her peers that were cut even had more upside than her."
[7.0] "Jacy is a very solid heel, she's always trying to gain heat & her in-ring work is perfectly fine too. She's not necessarily a star, but she's the kind of wrestler who would be an asset to every promotion."
[10.0] "My biggest crush of 2025 by far. She can spark both hatred and sympathy in the blink of an eye. Her look is always incredible, she's got great in-ring ability, and she manages to look strong while still playing her "weak" heel role perfectly. Even her finisher, which seems pretty simple, often looks great in execution."
[8.0] "I'll admit it. I once thought Jacy Jayne wasn't destined to be more than a solid hand in NXT. But I was wrong. Over time, she's proven herself to be far more than just "good enough." Today, she's become one of the most important and reliable performers on the brand. No woman has spent more time on NXT's current roster than Jacy. At first, I assumed that longevity was a sign she lacked what it takes for the main roster. But after seeing her shock the brand as a double champion, and now holding the NXT Women's Title for over 100 days, it's clear to me the reason actually is that she made herself indispensable. She's grown into a reliable worker who improves with every outing. More importantly, she's someone who makes her opponents look better, no matter the role. Jacy is my pick for NXT Wrestler of the Year. As a heel, her crowd control is unmatched, she can make any feud feel important. She's consistent, can always deliver fun TV matches, and is trusted with advancing storylines. Beyond the ring, she's praised as a locker room leader. She has patience with her opportunities and maximizes everything she's given. Whether in Chase U, Toxic Attraction, or Fatal Influence, she's repeatedly been the glue holding acts together, often outshining those expected to be the stars. She has what can't be taught: the ability to win while putting her opponent over, or to lose without looking weak. That balance makes her invaluable. On the mic, in charisma, and in character work, she's already miles ahead of most of NXT's roster. In-ring, she may not be the most dynamic worker, but she's more than capable, and getting better. Jacy Jayne may never be a perennial world champion, though I wouldn't rule it out. What's certain is that she has everything it takes to be a valuable main roster act: a strong midcard presence, a great tag team wrestler, and a reliable character who can elevate others. If WWE gives her the chance, she can be the kind of performer every company dreams of: versatile, dependable, and magnetic. I've become a fan, and I hope history will be kinder to her legacy than many expect."
[7.0] "Jacy Jayne is someone who, prior to her NXT women's title reign, I had very little in the way of thoughts or feelings about. Now? I'd consider her a very solid hand. Her matches don't tend to be exceptional, but they're also never terrible, her promos range from solid to pretty good, she has a great look and works well with Fatal Influence as a unit. I can see her having a very respectable run similar to a Chris Jericho - generally midcard and tag act with the occasional run in the world title scene."
[8.0] "She did wonders putting over women like Giulia and Stephanie Vaquer when they first came in. She plays the heel that makes other people look good so well. And now I'm glad that she's getting her flowers and having a pretty good reign."
[4.0] "She's very very average, she's stuck around a long time, but I have a hard time seeing what the company sees in her. Having her beat a woman like Jordynn Grace who has all the talent and intagibles to be a star is downright baffling."
[2.0] "I am sorry but why is this talent getting the push she is getting she isn't even top ten in any category you judge a wrestler by ( promos, workrate, charisma, athletics) where does she stand out? The only positive I can say is she somehow survived all her other toxic attraction members and that is hilarious because she was by far the weakest link. Anyways can't think of a stand out moment or anything in her career that would warrant such a push, until Jacy can show me she is even up to par on the main roster mid card I will happily bump up the rating as of now a overpushed talent who does nothing for me."
[7.0] "As a wrestler she seems to be competent from what I've seen and her character and mic work as a heel is very good. I can see her being a great talent to have in storylines to get babyfaces over, but other than that I'm not entirely sure what she has to offer without further examing her in-ring work so for now I'll just say serviceable wrestler, good charisma, good promo. Her match with Steph was excellent."
[4.0] "I don't know, she just never stood out to me in any form. Nothing about her is overly interesting. Her ring work and moveset are bland, she's a fine but generic promo and is just a fine heel. I'm open to giving her a chance, but she's not ready for it just yet. She's just, there I guess"
[4.0] "I've seen better and I've seen worse. She's just nothing to be excited about or invest in. Maybe all that will change but generally when a wrestler gets closer to 30, we're seeing everything they can offer. As of this review, of her 8 years in wrestling, 5 of them having been on NXT. Being on NXT for 5 years isn't really a good thing. Maybe she's choosing to stay like some others before her but considering she's not that good of a wrestler, I doubt it."
[3.0] "Someone who has never stood out. In the early days of Toxic Attraction, I remember her being very bad in the ring. She's very bland & flat. I see little character depth & almost no charisma. Sub par mic skills. Her new group seems like an attempt at Toxic Attraction 2.0 & feels like it's doomed to fail."
[8.0] "Jacy is officially growing on me, I see incredible potential in her, she is a badass and a good heel, her skills in the ring are becoming more powerful and credible. I still think she should have been the leader in Fatal Influence, but she still stands out a lot in the group, she has progressed in a good way as a wrestler."
[7.0] "Jacy Jayne has shown a lot of growth during her time in NXT. Saw her a little on the Indies and she was talented but did not stand out. Found a good role for herself with Toxic Attraction. She is solid in the ring and really good on the mic."
"I M P E C A B L E. Are the words that describes her. Jacy Jayne isn't just about "HAHAHA, ROCK N ROLL BITCHES! " She's about business! The attitude are something bigger in her, imppecable mic skills, her finisher maneuver, the Jacy Kick, are innovative, she got what it takes to be an STAR in the main roster, not only that, but her time in the indies "Avery Taylor" even with less than 7 years of experience she HAD an goddamn amazing impression! Cause' she's an beasty! I loved her in the time she stepped in the NXT ring for the first time, in a random battle royal in 2020."
[9.0] "she was literally the best member of toxic attraction and my personal favourite. She is just a natural on the mic. Her role in the chase u storyline has been interesting. She is decent in the ring as well and i feel like her career has been boosted up a bit more than gigi's. Her future is bright"
[9.0] "She has such a lot of potential, before when she was in toxic attraction (TA) she showed up with gigi dolin making one of the best stables in wwe womens history, she did such a good work with dolin and mandy rose giving a second opportunity to her career, then when TA died she went solo and helped Thea but before she showed up on matches showing her in ring ability as a solo star and she really went hard on that. Jacy is one of the best in Nxt with other womens, she deserbes to be a champion again."
[7.0] "She has tons of personality and it's not bad in the ring, as a matter of fact, she has some very good matches, I still feel she has more to prove and unleashed potential, I want to see how much she grows in the future. She has proved she's a great tag team wrestler too, her time with Toxic Attraction was definetely beneficial for her."
[3.0] "I don't understand what some people see in Jacy. She is sloppy and unimpressive in ring, and her character work is just rotten. Her facial expressions are over the top in all the hokiest, fakest ways and her promos are awful. She comes across as so forced and like she's trying way too hard. She is completely unbelievable to the point of being obnoxious - and not in a good heel way. It's in a way that makes me want to skip all her segments. She is definitely on my list of wrestlers where I simply don't get it."
[3.0] "The weaker half of the former toxic duo jacy hasn't been able to get any fan support and is by far not the one to take off gigi has more fan support and much much more things to learn and to get better at while jacy just is really forgotten and will be the less successful one"
[8.0] "While injuries have slowed her tag team partner Gigi Dolin, Jacy Jayne has remained consistently great over the past year. Good in the ring, has charisma in spades, and is an EXCELLENT promo. While I don't think her and Gigi should split up yet, I think Jacy Jayne has a very lucrative and successful WWE career ahead of her."
[10.0] "Jacy Jayne is the best of Toxic Attraction honestly, her mic skills, in ring ability, her selling, her facial expressions are on point. She should be the star of Toxic Attraction but I hope they stay as a team in the Main Roster for a while. The Women's Tag Team Division needs it."
[8.0] "She is the best of the Toxic Trio. The most natural, the most charismatic, the most beautiful. She is also the best in and out the ring. She has a natural charisma and a strong personality. She is great on the microphone, you can notice how she is spontaneous and has incredible natural expressive and acting skills. She is also excellent in the ring. She also has a long experience and success in independent circuits. Already in her pre-wwe period you can notice her charisma and unique personality and her excellent skills in the ring and on the microphone. Notice that before NXT she already appeared in some WWE RAW Underground episode. She was already in the sights of the WWE that had noticed her talent already long time ago. Is a very great talent Jacy Jayne."
[7.0] "She is pretty decent. She is good interviews amd can be funny at times. Her in ring skills have improved. I like the her in the tag team with Gigi Dolin."
[8.0] "I followed some of Avery's matches and she was always very good in the ring. Currently I think she even surpassed Gigi, although she is also pretty good. I'm rooting for both of them and that both dominate the tag division"
[7.0] "My personal favorite in Toxic Attraction. She can do with improving her ring work, making it cleaner, but is easily the standout on the mic. You can't teach star quality."
[3.0] "Toxic Attraction as a stable is not very good at all. But Jacy is by far the weakest link of the group. She's...not good in the ring, and her promo skills are below average at best. She's the one I see having the lowest ceiling in the future."
[4.0] "I'm not sure why I rate Dolin and Cora Jade more highly, but there's an awkwardness in her in-ring work, and her character is grating, which is saying something in a faction as irritating as Toxic Attraction."
[5.0] "Jacy Jayne seems to have some potential, but she just does not stand out as part of Toxic Attraction with Mandy Rose and Gigi Dolan. I do not necessarily think Rose and Dolan are better than Jayne, but they certainly standout more both in and out of the ring."
[5.0] "There's clearly makings of a good wrestler in the former Avery Taylor, currently known as Jacy Jane. From the bits and pieces I have seen from her pre-WWE days, she can be decent. Her early NXT appearances weren't bad either, but of late she has been erratic and accident prone. Passable mic skills. Remains in the shadow of her more talented tag partner Gigi Dolin (Priscilla Kelly). However, she has the advantage of being in one of the few acts that new-look NXT is pushing hard. It has certainly paid dividends as she's now half of the NXT women's tag team champs."
3x
3x
27x
59x
35x
26x
10x
6x
1x
1x
0x
