[6.0] "I didn't like this quite as much as others but it was definitely better than expected, since generally I am really not feeling Credible as champion. I do like Sandman and he came out swinging, if you will, and the match ended up pretty decent."
[8.0] "As a snapshot of late-era ECW TV, I'm not sure you can do much better. Very entertaining, and a strong post match seg where Dreamer spikes his balls on barbed wire. 4."
[8.0] "This match was pretty hilarious, when dusty interfered i knew the chaos was about to be amped up. From a wrestling perspective its really not one of the greatest or most hardcore ecw matches ive seen but for sheer entertainment this match deserves a high rating"
[8.0] "It starts off just being a decent brawl but shortly ends up turning into an amazing and fascinating clusterfuck. The overbooking here was incredible. There was so much outside interference and switching of refs it was impossible to keep up. Just pure chaos from beginning to end. To cap it all off Credible gets piledrived on barbed wire and gets his head busted open to finish the show. I have no idea whether it was objectively any good but it was incredibly entertaining."