[5.0] "The September 18th, 2025 edition of ROH was simply barebones. The only interesting thing happening on this show to me was Matt Mako, Janai Kai & Shane Taylor Promotions. 7 of the brand's champions didn't even show up on this show. It lacked star power or any good stories. Another negative I have is the countless amounts of Pure Matches and squashes spread out around the show. Main Event was decent and had some fun moments. Overall, a poor show. [**.5]"

[6.0] "A solid show with way to many and to short matches, but mostly they were enjoyable to not bad and if then the short time helped"

[4.0] "A random win for Mistico in a match littered with interference. Three Pure Rules matches out of eight total (two of which continuing the push for the Women's Pure Title and trying to justify its need while the other two women's titles go missing.) Random enhancement wins for the likes of Mortos and Satnam. A QTV segment which might be worse than the predictable matches. The Shibata/Mako and STP matches were both pretty solid but not enough to give these anything more than what is the usual standard from this show. The feeling of matches for the sake of matches with little build to any of them continues to be an issue for this show."

[8.0] "This is the best ROH episode in a long time. This week's Ring of Honor episode is the best in a long time. Viva Van/Olympia I feel overachieved. Mako/Shibata was the most grappling focused match Shibata's had in a long time, Mortos/Angels was a sprint, the best wrestler on the indies - CPA took on Satnam Singh & the Infantry continue to be some of the easiest to watch stables in wrestling. Wrestling variety hour"

[3.0] "BORING. this show was bad, even the good matches were just there the rest was REALLY REALLY BAD, I wish these show were like when they started it or like those action dean shows"