[6.0] "This show had a lot of mid, but the last two matches were solid, and three-way match between luchadors was great. [MOTN: Dralistico vs. Hologram vs. The Beast Mortos]"

[8.0] "It was a good show storyline Jamie Hayter vs Saraya Match was not so attractive, but the feud between them made it better. Accepting Perry's Open Challenge by Suzuki set the stage for Shibata and Perry's match. The Castagnoli vs Private Party match was the basis for yuta side to be revealed. And we still saw the formation of a new faction and many other events that were all good. But for the process of some competitions, I will reduce the score. If the competition level was better, it would definitely be the best Collision"

[7.0] "Although there wasn't really anything noteworthy on the show, most of the matches were fairly engaging and had good moments. The later half of the show was great, though the story in the trios match was a bit obnoxious at times and Hangman/Jarrett was kinda hurt by the interferences. Saraya/Hayter was meh, the pacing was too slow and the concept of the match itself wasn't very good imo. The trios match wasn't needed on this show, it was quite a waste of time. The two remaining matches were fine for what they were. In general, I quite enjoyed this episode, so it's above average for me but it definitely had room for improvement."

[8.0] "Good show with some great storytelling in ring, especially the trios match. Jack minoru really developed the heel character of Perry and built for the next match along. Lucha exhibition to show some real fun. Enjoying time being put into the outrunners they're a great duo and need to be pushed considering how popular they are. The same could be said about Mortos, people love him, push him up the card to make the most of it"

[8.0] "This was a good show, especially considering it was taped. The lucha 3 way, lumberjack match, and okada vs sammy were the highlights of the show. The low point of the show was definetly the MxM Collection segment, which I think would have been fine if they hadn't had all those extras come out beforehand, and instead jumped right to the billy gunn part."

[6.0] "Enjoyable opener, as Saraya and Harley are so entertaining, and Jamie Hayter earns a solid win. The second match was forgettable. Big Bill the shining star of a bad match. Brody King squashes Action Andretti (surprising). Jack Perry in his most least interesting TNT title defense thus far. Trios match was decent, more interested in Yuta's story. Great three-way lucha match between Beast Mortos, Dralistico and Hologram. It appears Rush is reconfiguring LFI. Good lumberjack strap match between Hangman and Jeff Jarrett. A fine main event as Okada successfully defends his Continental championship against Sammy G."

[8.0] "Not as good as Grand Slam: Dynamite, but still a great show. Collision is always much better when broadcast live, but then the internet babies cry that live wrestling on a Saturday is a bad idea? It doesnt matter whether its pre-taped or live, the online clowns will find something to complain about. Go watch Grand Slam: Collision, it was fantastic."

[6.0] "Can they hurry up and work out what it is they want to do with Collision already? Ever since Punk was fired, it has been pretty aimless and directionless, with the occasional decent episode mostly being scattered amongst filler and uninteresting episodes."

[2.0] "[2.0] A collision half filled to be special. I liked the BCC fight a little because of the story with Yuta, the Mexican triple threat and Saraya vs Jamie Hayter. I didn't like Perry's fight, it's pretty similar to his reign. Sammy Guevara has too many opportunities to have that history and even more so coming off a suspension. That fight for a chance at the continental title was regular. Squah meh, MxM segment is absolute crap. In the episode there is one of AEW's biggest inconsistencies. Don Callis was supposedly interested in Rush and he joined, but it seems like nothing happened. LFI was frozen since December and by magic they incorporated it, it's stupid. AEW thinks people are stupid, but that's not the case. Preston Vance? Frozen and suddenly they have him in ROH until he leaves because they didn't give a reason for his absence. The Learning Tree vs The Conglomeration is a trash of rivality. I liked the fight between Hangman vs. Jarrett, but this first one is for title rivalries. He beat former world champion Swerve. He must go to for the AEW World Championship or the International Championship very soon."

[6.0] "This was disappointing considering it was hyped up as a special "Grand Slam" episode. Eight matches (plus the long MxM segment) was too much for one show. Most things felt rushed and never kicked in to that next gear. Crowd seemed (reasonably) tired. I'm giving the show a little boost because we did get a **** in the lucha libre showcase that I really enjoyed."

[7.0] "Having heard the rumors that this was a bad show, I was pleasantly surprised. Hayter and plunder helped Saraya to her best match in the company. The Conglomeration Learning Tree bout was the standard fun weekend trios bout. The lucha libre three way was excellent. The strap match and the trios title matches advanced their story-lines very well. The main event was fine, but the wonky finish with the botched GTH block led to a pretty flat finish. The only thing on this show that was bad was the MxM segment, which unsurprisingly considering the people involved, was possibly the worst thing AEW has aired since the Dan Lambert Brandi Rhodes feud."

[5.0] "The card on paper wasn't super strong and the show matched the initial low expectations that I had. Saraya vs. Hayter was surprisingly decent. One of the best Saraya matches in AEW. Conglomeration vs. Learning Tree was meh and Jericho pinning Briscoe was a terrible decision. Just bad booking having the Conglomeration losing and having calling a shot for the ROH title. Perry vs. Suzuki was fine. Perry's character would work so much more if he was a coward champion instead of acting like a badass. BCC vs. PP & Komander was solid. The in-ring action was meh but the storytelling with Yuta not wanting to be like Pac and Claudio but then taking advantage of an injury to win after being disrespected was great stuff. Hologram vs. Dralistico vs. Mortos was the best match of the night. But I don't understand Rush involvement at the end. Like didn't he joined the Don Callis Family not even 1 month ago? And now he's reforming LFI? It makes no sense. Page vs. Jarrett was good although I was hoping for a better ending to their feud. Guevara vs. Okada was a fine yet heatless main event. TK should stop trying to push Sammy. Also another big show where Okada got wasted. Overall: there were a couple of fine matches but the most of the show was skippable and there were a couple of terrible booking decisions."

"[5.0] A bit lackluster show that suffered from a crowded card. Jarrett and Page should have main evented, a fine old school strap match. Fun but not quite fullfilling. I am unsure why BBG had to involve in this match and idk if that sets up a feud between them and Hanger. Sammy and Okada was surprisingly disappointing as Sammy has no momentum and Okada is not involved in upper card matches like Ospreay does. Especially after the bout with Claudio (which we still don't know if they will ever revisit) Okada's stock is going down back again real fast. Three way was the clear MOTN involving 3 very talented but directionless luchadores. Luckily, LFI is back again and now also has Mortos in their ranks. I hope they can finally become a formiddable force in trios division. BCC vs Komander & Private Party was more of the same that we got in Anthony Henry vs. Wheeler Yuta and it worked way better in that match. Komander looks off tagging along with Private Party. I hope Private Party gets more serious from there and receive further opportunities though my guts tell me that won't be the case. Countdown finish to Suzuki vs. Perry was ok and somewhat fresh but the match also involved Suzuki freely hitting with a chair and his classic chops. It works when they work but in this case not quite. Andretti squash does what to who? Idk. They seemingly tease a Top Flight breakup so The Righteous might as well break them up. Tornado Tag is an okay match with an awkward finish that seemingly sets up Briscoe vs Jericho for ROH World Championship? God, I fkn hope not. Glad to see Big Bill was over again. The opener was fun and Hayter looked strong in that but it was all gimmicky with little substance. Could have been booked a bit better but it did more wonders to Saraya than it did to Hayter. Hayter needs to be involved in a serious match from now on. MxM stuff was perhaps the most 'entertainment' stuff they ever did in AEW. I like their backstage interactions but the whole segment was a dread. Billy Gunn has an incredible physique for his age, ngl. Claudio's new theme slaps."

[5.0] "Jamie Hayter vs Saraya: The stipulation of the match was confusing, the match was not that bad but could have been booked differently, glad that Hayter won despite all the rules that Saraya and Harley Cameron kept making [*3/4]. Big Bill, Bryan Keith & Chris Jericho vs Kyle O'Reilly, Mark Briscoe & Orange Cassidy: This was okay, but not that interesting, the result was obvious with The Learning Tree winning this [*3/4]. Brody King vs Action Andretti: An under 2 minute match that should have been longer to allow these more time [*]. Jack Perry vs Minoru Suzuki: There wasn't anything much to this one, good to see Suzuki in AEW even if he was booked not that well, the count out outcome was weakly booked [**]. Claudio Castagnoli, PAC & Wheeler Yuta vs Isiah Kassidy, Komander & Marq Quen: This match was here to just further the Wheeler Yuta angle, nothing more was contributed to this match other than the obvious result for BCC, the match was fine in itself [*3/4]. Hologram vs Dralistico vs The Beast Mortos: A great lucha libre three way match, the match was paced right and the action was solid back and forth from all three, MOTN in my opinion [****]. Adam Page vs Jeff Jarrett: Did not have much interest in this one, the match was not booked in a good way, it was mainly fine, Karen Jarrett getting in the ring was not needed, Page winning was not a good booking decision, should have been Jarrett win [**]. Kazuchika Okada vs Sammy Guevara: This was an okay main event, but not of the calibre these two are capable of, the chemistry was not there much and Sammy jammed his knee which did not help, Okada winning was obvious here [**]"

[7.0] "This show wasn't as good as Dynamite Grand Slam, but I enjoyed the matches here. A lot of good storyline progression, potentially wrapping things up between Hayter and Saraya as well as Page and Jarrett. Jericho/Briscoe, Perry/Shibata, Hangman/Bang Bang Gang, the reformation of the LFI, and what's going on with Yuta are all good-to-great directions. The Outrunners video at Coney Island was nothing short of a masterpiece as well. A good watch."

[5.0] "The womens match, squash match. lucha lads and strap match were all decent but it is a big fat yikes for the rest of the show. This is not the kind of show you put on if you want to persuade the decreasing amount of people in Arthur Ashe to come back next year."

[4.0] "Very weak show, the first half was horrible, the saraya match was decent but her extremely slow pace made the match go a little bit down for me, the learning tree vs conglomeration i only remember the table spot, Brody king vs Andretti was bad but atleast was a squash, Perry vs Suzuki was ok but the decision of the ending was pretty bad. Absolutely loved the story told between yuta and the bcc, the highlight of the show for me. The triple threat was great but beast mortos was kind lost in some moments. The MxM segment... by god that was horrible, the worst aew segment that i ever seen. Jarrett vs Hangman was fun but kind underwhelming looking back at the match that they've had at the Bret Hart tournament. Okada vs Guevara was great but it was short sadly"

[2.0] "Now I say this as someone who generally likes what MxM do, they're funny guys, their streams are funny and they've been pretty funny so far in AEW. But HOLY SHIT that was one of the worst segments in AEW history, whoever okayed that segment needs to be gone, just fucking DREADFULLY BAD, and not only that you've got one of the greatest of all time in Okada in a meaningless pointless heatless match against a guy in Sammy Guevara that NOBODY gives a shit about anymore, TERRIBLE STUFF. A great luchador 3 way, the womens match was fun hardcore bollocks, the stuff going on with BCC and Yuta is very interesting so far, and Adam Page being a sick broken guy is really compelling stuff, the rest of the show is whatever but this show gets a huge thumbs down for the MxM segment alone, never ever ever do something like that again AEW."