[8.0] "If you like the Broken Hardys then this show was good. Definitely one of the weirder shows Impact put on but the early matches were short enough. The World title match was good with the situation and Tag Team Apocalypto was fun but once again kind of weird. Overall an enjoyable show built around one premise and one match."

[10.0] "I've watched this episode in 2020 and in my pov it's just a masterpiece. I'm always will come back to that episode. I'm enjoyed a lot. Incledible action, the set was very good. The moment when Ricky Morton insult Broken Matt make me laught so match. Incledible. Amazing. DELIGHTFUL."

[10.0] "I understand this is not everyone's cup of tea, but I really had a blast with this show. The Spud stuff was funny, ODB was a nice surprise and the Vanguard 1 stuff was fun, Itchweeed was... interesting, haha. The title match was pretty tame until the went outside the ring, then some really crazy stuff went down. We didn't even get a finish in the end, though technically I suppose the match could STILL be going on... ? Apocalypto itself was insane as expected but loads of fun, just pure enjoyment, some of it cool, much of it silly, but I had a wonderful time with it. They probably couldn't do this on a regular basis but as a special episode, it was a lot of fun."

[1.0] "Wow . This was some GLOW level garbage . I understand The Hardys are the only thing approaching National level big time stars left on the roster and they have some pull but come on . The money marks took a beating on this one . I know as of this posting TNA has been thrown another life line but this episode shows a company begging for .... Deletion . This is the definition of the inmates running the asylum . The only decent thing was the World title match (boy is that a joke ) and they even ruined that . Did even end ? I am starting to think this whole thing was a way to get TNA to pay for Matt's drone . This was basically everything bad about wrestling . Matches worth watching : none ."

[10.0] "This show was just awesome fun. The matches can't really be rated, all I can say is that they were stupid fun. Lashley and Edwards had a good match in the midst of all the crazy shit. Apacolypto was my favorite of all the Deletion matches. Super fun for 40 minutes straight . Lived up to the hype for me"

[8.0] "Like the Final Deletion and Great War matches, the Total Nonstop Deletion episode could be described as a work of surrealist performance art as much as it could be as a pro wrestling show, and as such it's hard to rate it as a wrestling show per say. While I'm sure not everyone's cup of tea, though, I found the show and, in particular, the Tag Team Apocalypto match one hell of an enjoyable watch - the main event in particular was a wild ride with plenty of action, fun cameo appearances, in-jokes and "WTF" moments to keep it entertaining through its nearly-45 minute runtime. Although there were maybe not as many surprise guest tag teams involved as one might hope for, I did like the Rock 'n' Roll Express (and, for a quick cameo, Road Warrior Animal) showing up to put the stamp of approval on the proceedings from some of tag wrestling's great legends. The rest of the card featured what was actually a good if inconclusive World Title match (though, since the laws of time and space apparently don't apply at the Hardy compound, it still might be going on), and other fun stuff with the rest of the Hardy pantheon (even Maxel and Itchweeed) getting their time to shine. They can't do this kind of thing too often, but two or three fits of insanity like this a year with plenty of build leading into them should allow the gimmick to continue for awhile yet. I'm still not entirely sure what exactly I watched, but I enjoyed it."

[10.0] "Possibly the greatest wrestling event ever devised. Truly expands the boundaries of wrestling itself and is reminiscent of the bygone era of island deathmatches and pool deathmatches we truly deserve back into wrestling; didn't care about the "prestige" of the talent who showed up because everyone who showed up did their jobs perfectly. Would've given this a 3 if the Young Bucks showed up anyways."

[8.0] "If you allow yourself to revel in the insane fever dream joy of it all, this is a very enjoyable show. If TNA continues to exist for the Hardys to do their thing, the wrestling world is better for it."

[10.0] "It's like if Twin Peaks was a wrestling show. Literal insanity, I loved every minute of this show, BROKEN Matt Hardy has been the best thing in wrestling by far in 2016 (I never thought if say that) It's not everyone's cup of tea. But my god, I loved it."

[9.0] "Accepting the fact that it did not deliver all that great tag team names the Hardys promised, the Apocalypto Tag Team match was entertaining and unique. Well, Broken Matt would say delightful! The whole show is different, it's something you can love or hate, but it has to make an impression on the fans. It's the peak of everything related to the Final Deletion and the Broken Hardys characters. I had a lot of fun, more than in any Wrestling shows I've watched in 2016. Impressive episode, maybe you'll hate it, maybe you'll love it. My only disappointment is how they treated Lashley vs Edwards, the change from the ring to the recorded outside match was too much to bear."

[9.0] "Maybe we didn't have as much star power as we expected, but when you got The Rock N' Roll Express, Road Warrior Animal, Swoggle, The Bravados and The Hurricane, you can't complain much. Furthermore, Matt did a great job, and everything was really entertaining. Maybe next year we get the Bucks."

[7.0] "It was a fun show, the tag team apocalypto felt a little long, but besides that, I really enjoyed it"

[9.0] "This was just an incredibly fun spectacle. Tag Team Apocalypto felt like it ran a little long, and we never got a conclusion to the World Heavyweight championship. But those were small complaints in the grand scheme of things. This was more fun than two hours of free wrestling has any right to be. Comedy, drama, and an absolutely insane 40+ minute tag team match. What we did get of the Eddie Edwards and Lashley match was actually pretty good, too."