 # | Title | Timeframe | Winner | Rating | Votes |
| 1 | Midwest Classic | 10.11.2024 | Jack Sirius | ||
| 2 | Insane 8 2024 | 18.08.2024 | Orin Veidt | ||
| 3 | Insane 8 2023 | 20.08.2023 | Dr. Redacted | ||
| 4 | Insane 8 2022 | 31.07.2022 | Eric Dillinger | ||
| 5 | Insane 8 2021 | 29.08.2021 | Neil Diamond Cutter | ||
| 6 | Hardcore Death Match Challenge 2021 | 29.05.2021 | Mickie Knuckles | ||
| 7 | Insane 8 2020 | 30.08.2020 | SHLAK | ||
| 8 | ICW Alternative Title #1 Contendership Tournament | 23.02.2020 | Neil Diamond Cutter | ||
| 9 | Insane 8 2019 | 18.08.2019 | Orin Veidt | ||
| 10 | Milwaukee's Best Tournament | 19.05.2019 | Orin Veidt | ||
| 11 | Hardcore Death Match Challenge | 31.03.2019 | Orin Veidt | ||
| 12 | Insane 8 2018 | 19.08.2018 | Orin Veidt | ||
| 13 | Insane 8 2012 | 20.01.2012 | Chase McCoy | ||
| 14 | Insane 8 IV | 19.11.2010 | Chase McCoy | ||
| 15 | Best Of The Midwest III | 28.08.2009 | Mickey McCoy | ||
| 16 | Insane 8 III | 13.02.2009 | Danny Havoc | ||
| 17 | Best Of The Midwest II | 25.05.2008 | Ego Fantastico | ||
| 18 | Best Of The Midwest | 13.07.2007 | Justin Dredd |
