| Timeframe | Title | Duration | Details |
| 15.04.2012 - xx.xx.xxxx | FTW World Tag Team Champion (as Bill Carr; with Jim Sullivan) | ? | Matches |
| 11.12.2021 - 23.07.2022 | ROH World Six Man Tag Team Champion (with Bateman and Vincent as The Righteous) | 224 days | Matches |
| 06.04.2019 - 10.05.2019 | REVOLVER World Tag Team Champion (as Bill Carr; with Dan Barry as Team Tremendous) | 34 days | Matches |
| 28.03.2015 - 17.04.2018 | ISW Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Bill Carr; with Dan Barry as Team Tremendous) | 1116 days | Matches |
| 11.07.2015 - 12.12.2015 | CZW Tag Team Champion (as Bill Carr; with Dan Barry as Team Tremendous) | 154 days | Matches |
| 25.10.2014 - 27.03.2015 | ISW Tag Team Champion (as Bill Carr; with Dan Barry as Tremendous Inc.) | 153 days | Matches |
| 27.12.2014 - 28.02.2015 | NYWC Tag Team Champion (2x) (as Bill Carr; with Dan Barry as Team Tremendous) | 63 days | Matches |
| 23.02.2013 - 15.06.2013 | NYWC Tag Team Champion (as Bill Carr; with Smith James) | 112 days | Matches |
| Title | Duration |
| CZW Tag Team Championship | 154 days |
| FTW World Tag Team Championship | 0 (+ ?) days |
| ISDub Ultimate Tag Team Championship (2x) | 1269 days |
| NYWC Tag Team Championship (2x) | 175 days |
| REVOLVER World Tag Team Championship | 34 days |
| ROH World Six Man Tag Team Championship | 224 days |
