[6.0] "While I still believe that he's far from perfect, he's been growing on me a ton recently. He's perfectly fine in the ring and I think his character has potential. He's still green at times, but he's only been on NXT for about 3 months, I'm not already expecting him to be on the levels Johnny Gargano was in 2019."
[4.0] "Well, he's certainly not too bad for a rookie. I guess he did deserve to win LFG S2. He looks like a happy guy too. His in-ring action is ok I guess? I mean, considering he just started training 2 years ago. However, I don't like his promos at all. I watched one of his promos, and one of the lines he said was, "Allow me to explain, princess, " and I cringed. His "dark web" gimmick is... stupid honestly? I don't get why they came up with this gimmick. It's like they ran out of ideas. The only thing that's actually decent about him is, again, his ring skill. Everything else about him seems disastrous."
[4.0] "An interesting instagram account but as wrestler he has a lack in his moveset, his personality and gimmick is okay but cringy acting of edgy internet weird guy. He can improve his character but need more time."
[7.0] "Shiloh Hill will be a champion one day. He's got charisma, size, intensity, and a unique character, with in-ring talent to back it all up. He's still a little green, but does not seem even a little out of place next to the NXT vets."
[4.0] "Not much to be impressed with right now. The name Shiloh makes me think of the restaurant scene in Grandma's Boy where David Spade plays the waiter with the same name. Extra points for reminding me of that funny movie."
[3.0] "The winner of LFG is getting a decent push in early 2026, already getting two separate title shots. Unfortunately, I don't really see the vision with him. I'm glad he's getting over with the crowd, but his gimmick and personality feel too much like pure novelty (it doesn't help that he has one of the worst theme songs in the WWE, which admittedly isn't his fault). In the ring, he can do some flashy stuff with his athleticism, but he's so green that it's hard to imagine him putting on a great singles match any time soon. Maybe he'll amount to something, but for now, I unfortunately roll my eyes when I watch him."
[3.0] "Horrible internet gimmick, cringe worthy promo packages, the whole toothless bit that's just tasteless, yet to have a match that is serviceable, let alone good, the fact that he is having title shots on tv this early and this green in to his career purely off merit that's he's "handpicked by Undertaker" sickens me"
[9.0] "By far, one of the most creative and interesting talents of recent years. This man could easily be plugged in to any storyline or any faction or stay solo and he manages to make it very entertaining. I could easily see him joining the Wyatt Sicks, but also could see him playing a major babyface role in NXT for a while. The crowd clearly loves him, and there are so many levels to his creativity that I think will keep him relevant. His in ring skill is great too, very athletic and currently clearly understands how to play the baby role and amp up live crowds or get sympathy. His promos are top notch, there's so much to like about this guy."
[10.0] "I love when he comes to our town for the live events. I dont know if its his vibe or the way he looks but he just feels like one of us so he is fun to cheer for. I hope he gets used well on NXT and moves up to main roster soon. Wishing the best for him"
[9.0] "NGL this mans is nice in the ring. I used 2 have a different favorite in LFG in season one but Ive changedmy opinon. I think I will be him or Harlem that wins iteight. I think only thinng holding him bafk is if he can try to dina sj"
[10.0] "For how green he is he is very solid. I could see him in the Wyatt Sicks or partnering up with the The Righteous at some point. Future Champion for sure. I think he will probably be called up to Raw or Smackdown before a lot of current NXT stars."
[10.0] "Saw him wrestle Trick Williams in Augusta. I was surprised to see how good he was in the mic as a baby face since they usually only show him yelling or doing crazy stuff on LFG. I really liked him as a tough and well spoken guy. Made me want to root for him more than when he seems so unhinged."
[10.0] "He is my favorite wrestler: I could not believe he did not win season 1 of LFG and I hope he wins season 2. He also does more on social media than any other wrestler including main roster. He gets almost as many views as Logan Paul on Instagram which is crazy for how young he is. I cant wait to see if he adds a dark web persona to his character. The sky is the limit with this one. Future Undisputed Champion right here."
[5.0] "Thus far he is brand new to the business & has only worked on the WWELFG training show. So take that into consideration when looking at this review. Of everyone on LFG, he's probably the most well rounded in the ring. That's where he's shined so far. He also has an immediate eye catching look with the missing tooth. The major problem with him is that he has no clue what his character is. He smiles a lot & genuinely seems like a good, happy guy. But in the next breath he's trying to cut a pissed off & yelling promo & trying to get a "hellraiser" nickname over; which seems diametrically opposite from who he really is. If he can find a gimmick that works for him he could make it. But if he doesn't, he won't get very far."
[7.0] "I think they're either the best or second currently on LFG, he's already quite good in the ring in my opinion, and he can definitely talk. He has a presence to him, and he can switch looks between a 2015 Roman and a Wyatt family member just by popping out his tooth. Tyra and him are the two that I think have the potential to be real stars."
[7.0] "Shiloh Hill is still very green in the ring on both WWE LFG and NXT Level Up. He has the look, charisma and athletic ability to be successful in WWE now he just needs to polish his skills and reach his potential."
4x
5x
5x
11x
7x
3x
3x
2x
0x
0x
0x
