Michin

[3.0] "Unfortunately, WWE booking has cast her to be a complete side character over the years. Whatever talents she's had both in-ring and on the mic have not been properly showcased on the main roster in years. Not her fault, but unfortunately it gives her a relatively empty catalog of moments and matches lately. As a result, there's really very little to go off of when evaluating Michin over the past several years."

[6.0] "I love and have a sweet spot for Mia. A veteran who's good in the ring and not terrible on the mic. Mia has accomplished a lot in her long career on the wrestling scene. I hope sooner or later WWE gives her, her flowers and she wins a mid card title for a couple months, because she has always been booked as a jobber at WWE. She's currently carrying her group wrestling wise as BFab is pretty bad and Jade continues to be unsure and botch here and there and I think they should recognize her efforts and rewards her something down the line."

[5.0] "i haven't seen all that much from michin, but i haven't been particularly impressed by what i have. she's just very boring to me in every aspect. i don't even have much to say about her because there really isn't too much to say. i did like her match in tna with rosemary at the very least. she can at least wrestle competently."

[3.0] "After (credit to her) busting her ass on the indies for around 7 years, she made it into TNA, wherein her work just barely reached the proper side of "just okay". Shortly after, she was shoehorned into WWE and immediately, aggressively regressed from a status that was already not great. Her mic work is high school theater class level & she's impossible to take seriously in the "Baddies" stable (The "Baddies? " Really? ), wherein she teams with a wrestler whom is considerably worse than her in a subservient role to a wrestler whom is considerably worse than her. I don't think I've ever seen a match from her that's made me go "Wow! "."

[8.0] "Really consistent wrestler who is another victim of bad booking and has no character nor charisma though her in ring work is actually solid."

[7.0] "Michin is an hidden gem buried under horrible booking and bad decisions. Her in-ring is very much above average but her character really isn't it. Funnily enough, since she's with B-Fab and Cargill you can really see the difference of wrestling between the women."

"Generally my favorite wrestler of all time every match I have seen her in has been fun and it makes me so upset seeing what the WWE is doing with her she is being held back by staying in the WWE and they are wasting her talent."

[4.0] "I give her credit for her stamina and being the workhorse with the amount of matches and time she spends in the ring during tag matches but she's so sloppy and botches a lot and don't even get me started on how she butchers the Styles Clash and The Pele Kick trying to copy AJ Styles"

[3.0] "I mean c'mon... I seriously doubt anybody could name one good match she has had after being in the business for 16 years. I remember her as a character in TNA, and thought she was alright... and then she went to WWE and just.. yeah. Completely void of personality, no pop, not exactly awe-inspiring in the ring either. She's just kind of there. She's at least a pretty solid wrestler but that's all she really has going for her. Have to rate her a 3 based on the 16 years of experience in wrestling yet not one good or memorable match."

[3.0] "I'd give Michin a 3 because while she's reliable in the ring, she still hasn't really broken through as someone who feels important on the roster. She can put on decent matches and always gives effort, but a lot of her work has no standout moments that make you remember her. A big issue is that she often feels like she's there to fill out the division rather than being treated as a serious threat. WWE gives her opportunities here and there, but she rarely gets momentum or a storyline that lets her stand out long-term."

[6.0] "I really liked her a lot initially in TNA when she was with the Dollhouse with Taryn, Marti and Rebel. She was goofy and in a good way, could put together a very good match (watch her stuff with Gail in TNA back in 2015-2016) and she can do some crazy things like hurricanranas and package piledriver in the ring. Her matches with Rosemary and Allie in 2017 were also really good. However ever since 2018 or so, it's been downhill for her ever since. Got lazier in the ring, lost all the spark she had on the mic when being with the Dollhouse in TNA. Her initial WWE run was 1/10 terrible and the less said of her "Reckoning" character the better and her re-hired run is also equally as bad that I wouldn't be surprised if she was gone sooner rather than later at this point."

[0.0] "I don't know if she isn't able to shine on this roster or something in WWE holding her back or might just have lost it because she is not good anymore. She was never a great talker or even as a character but her in ring work was her only good thing and she has declined badly to the point that I truly believe she is the worst worker in WWE currently just behind the Bella Twins who aren't even wrestlers because she has been constantly giving us some horrible performances"

[8.0] "It's insane that Michin never held singles gold in the WWE, she may not be the best promo but she's a workhorse who can do it all from bell to bell."

[4.0] "I dont know what to say like she got some good matches and titles opportunies but I kinda feel like she didnt make it right now when i look at her i dont see any shine or potantial in her and her mic skills and promos are terrible tho"

[5.0] "A good wrestler with zero personality and no mic skills at all. I've seen her do good work but she's been boring for a good while now and I'm not entertained by her even one bit these days. I liked her with the OC."

[5.0] "At times throughout her career she's shown promise but she's lacking some charisma and mic skills. Her time in TNA is the best I've seen from her. Now she has a different name and shakes her ass diva style and does a lot of nothing."

[8.0] "Always have had a very soft spot for Michin. I think she's a very solid character when she's allowed to be and she thrives in hardcore/gimmick matches."

[8.0] "She's an impressive wrestler and one of the best female wrestlers in the indie promotions. She has had incredible matches in TNA, particularly her match against Rosemary. However, in WWE, she is being underutilized. I wish the company would recognize her talent, as well as that of other talented indie wrestlers like Candice LeRae, Piper Niven, and Kay Lee Ray"

[9.0] "Michin is a well-rounded performer known for her athleticism, striking ability, and adaptability across various wrestling styles. From her early days on the independent circuit to her stints in TNA as Jade and now WWE, she has consistently delivered solid in-ring work and connected with fans. Mia Yim stands out for her resilience and passion, overcoming injuries and setbacks while continuing to evolve as a competitor. She has held championships and been part of high-profile storylines, and her presence adds depth to any women's division she joins. Though she has yet to receive a big push in WWE, her talent and work ethic are undeniable, making her a reliable and respected figure in today's wrestling landscape - one capable of bigger things should she get that push"

[8.0] "Mia Yim was incredible throughout her career, but the spotlight only began at the end of her career in TNA and the beginning of WWE/NXT, but her role as Jade in ''DollHouse'' and soon after in a solo career was incredible, people only evaluate here what they saw in WWE, but if they saw her role in TNA they would change their minds because she is an incredible fighter, it's a shame that WWE took so long to hire her."

[4.0] "Really underwhelming character. Her in ring stuff is OKAY, sometimes actively bad in my opinion, and her character, well, there is no character, she just comes out, has an ok match and leaves. It's not necessarily her fault as her booking is pretty poor, but at the same time she hasn't really shown much when she gets the chance"

[7.0] "You know that it's always gonna be a solid match if Michin is involved. She is easily the most consistent wrestler in WWE"

[7.0] "I really like her, one of the most underrated wrestlers, a solid wrestler with good ring skills and mic skills, she just needs a better booking (it's not bad, but she should be a champion asap)"

[5.0] "It's obvious that she enjoys her job, and she's not lacking in talent, but people just don't care about her. That's partly her problem. If you can't offer the audience something more than average wrestling, that's bad. If she was initially positioned as a jobber, I'd even give her a 7, but she's been a contender for the US title for months: the newest title in WWE, which is pretty important, the title needs to be promoted. And how are you going to catch an eye to title if Michin is fighting for it?"

[4.0] "Not sure how her current overall rating is as high as it is. Everything she does is average. Even her finishing move (Eat Defeat) is a copy of Gail Kim who is overall a much better wrestler than her. I think her best persona was as Jade in the Dollhouse when she was one of Taryn Terrell's "associates". Curious that her wrestling style is as "Allrounder". I don't think she really fits the WWE roster particularly because in the WWE you either should have good charisma or good wrestling ability (or be connected to the Samoan Dynasty aka a relative of the Rock), of which she has neither."

[6.0] "I was a fan of Mia Yim during her time in TNA as part of the dollhouse. I feel like she's declined since then. I don't know if it was injuries but she seems less athletic. Her NXT run was decent and then she got put in the terrible Retribution group. When she returned they put her in the OC which seemed forced. They have been using her more on Smackdown and she had a good feud with Jaida Parker in NXT. With how deep the talent is in WWE, I don't think she'll be champion but she is a good utility player."

[6.0] "It's clear that the WWE doesn't know what to do with Michin. While her charisma and acting aren't sensational, the fact remains that she has a certain presence in the ring and really good technical skills. While it's hard to imagine her at the top of the card, especially after her long-standing poor writing and inconsistency at certain points in her career, she definitely deserves a place on the card, whether in the Title Picture dnun a secondary title or forming a solid women's team."

[7.0] "Had a nice run in TNA and was pushed as a star, this followed in NXT but unfortunately nothing much has come out of her main roster run (yet). Would love to see a second NXT run. Very solid in the ring too."

[8.0] "she really fits in the oc so well and i love the relationship they all have. She is a solid performer but unfortunately she hasnt had anything memorable yet but she will soon big things await for her. Her theme is so underrated its so damn good."

[6.0] "I think 6 points is a fair rating for her, she's decent at everything in wrestling but doesn't have a resume of classic matches, or memorable promos, title reigns, etc. She's basically been a utility player but seems like more of a star in smaller promotions like Impact than the WWE. When the NXT women's division was at arguably its peak in 2019-20 she didn't really stand out and was overshadowed by other competitors such as Ripley, Belair, Io, Dakota and Candice."

[7.0] "Michin is good in the ring. On the mic she is solid but not great In WWE she has not been booked well at all. She has proven the ability to star in other promotions such as Impact so there is definitely a future for her."

[7.0] "She's a good wrestler, good enough on the mic and has a good look, overall she's a solid hand, hopefully we'll see more from her this time around I know she has it in her"

[5.0] "I think she's pretty bland and I wouldn't mind seeing her out of WWE. It fights well, but it's so dull, no salt, no shine. I don't know how they like her. She is simply a girl who knows how to use the moves and nothing else. It needed a gigantic gimmick change to please me."

[4.0] "Another wrestler whose push and fan-following are totally undeserved relative to her wrestling skill. Her movements are slow, her attacks completely lack impact, and she's usually really sloppy whenever she has to pull off a spot/exchange with someone instead of just being allowed to get 100% of her offence in. The worst part is that she doesn't even look any better when working with far better wrestlers than just the usual sub-par workers in the Impact women's division. She's just bad all around."

[6.0] "I've never been the biggest fan of her in ring, but similarly to Toni Storm, I root for her success in spite of not being enamoured with her technique."

[8.0] "Mia Yim is an excellent wrestler. She's talented, oozes charisma and is also not bad on the eyes either. She definitely should've been a champion in WWE."

[6.0] "Closer to a 6.5 than a 6, good ring skills and some charisma unfortunately can? t make up for lackluster mic skills and kinda no gimmick, I like Mia Yim and her work in NXT especially but GOD she should not have gone to the main roster, if her gimmick was fleshed out more, maybe with an NXT women? s title reign she would easily be an 8-9/10"

[6.0] "She is only average at best. She has never done anything that stood out for me. She can have good matches against good opponents."

[8.0] "As Mia Yim, she had a really solid run on the indies for many years, competing in many countries against a great range of opponents. She had a nice run in TNA/Impact as Jade, including a good feud with Rosemary. While not among the top pushed stars in NXT, Yim had good TV matches and took some crazy bumps along the way. Now she's a member of RETRIBUTION using the name Reckoning, it's still early days to see how she takes to this role, but given her track record, she'll make the most of it."

[8.0] "Mia is a very experienced, gifted & talented worker. She wrestled in many places and promotions. I like her because you see her passion. In WWE - Did she have a perfect 5 star match? No. But she showed that she can deliver with great energy (Her Street Fight with Candice or the Ladder Match with Io). I don't know if WWE will make her a top star. But she would be ready if they gave her a chance (in my opinion)."

[7.0] "I've been a big fan of Mia Tim for a very long time. She started wrestling with a high flying lucha-esque style, but her moveset has diversified so much. She can strike, fly around, and is strong as well. She is all around a versatile wrestler, and always delivers a good match."

[10.0] "Mia Yim is a hero, a role model for domestic violence survivors like myself! I met her in person back in nova Pro Wrestling and she? s a sweetheart. Her mother still remembers me to this day. All in all she? s amazing in this business and for this business. I could see her becoming champion in wwe"

[8.0] "I have been a fan of Mia Yim since she was wrestling as Jade and was part of The Dollhouse. She has also been very entertaining in the ring and a credible threat. Her ladder match against Io Shirai is my favorite match of hers. I think a few more months in NXT will help mold her immensely."

[10.0] "She's one of my favorites, she's very skilled and diverse in the ring and has an amazing moveset, it's very rare to see a female wrestler who can do 450 Splashes, Package Piledrivers & a Corkscrew Moonsault, other moves like her finisher Protect Yo Neck, Seoul Food (aka Eat Defeat), Overhead Belly To Belly and Springboard Tornado DDT are amazing too"

[6.0] "Besides seeing some potential for more, she can't impress me more. It doesn't help that her cringe-worthy basic character just limits her freedom. She's solid in the ring, but at the current standards she doesn't seem competitive enough to me."

[7.0] "I think Mia is... fine. But she's missing a bit of that "it factor" in my eyes. She's someone who I don't feel really makes an impression with the crowd to get to the next level. I think after she falls short against Shayna at the upcoming Takeover, she'll likely be the female version of Kassius Ohno -- someone who's good in the ring & who can act as an enhancement talent for the people coming into NXT who likely have more to offer. That's not a bad role to have & I think Mia would be good for the company with that."

[7.0] "Mia Yim is very close to being the total package as women wrestlers go. She can do just about everything; sell, work, look good, etc. Talking might be my only knock against her but I don't put a lot of stock in talking because wrestling's where it's at in my book. It is unfortunate that Yim recently lost her Shine title but she is going to TNA so I guess she had to drop it before getting fully signed. Nikki Roxx dropped her WSU title in a similarly before heading to Dixie land. I only hope Mia has better luck in TNA then Roxxi did."

[9.0] "Jade/Mia Yim is a great all around talent who truly can be a huge star in any promotion she is in and can excel in multiple roles."

[8.0] "A charismatic presence and good all-around in-ring talent, Mia Yim cut her teeth on the independent circuit and earned singles and tag accolades in SHINE. She was formally introduced on the national stage in ROH, where she served as a valet for one iteration of the Embassy stable, but her in-ring national introduction came in TNA where, as Jade, she was brought in as part of the Dollhouse stable. Though meant as a backup character, her talent allowed her to stand out, and with the stable now history she's become a new breakout star in the Knockouts division with a reign as Knockouts Champion already under her belt. A valuable addition to any women's division, and sure to be a prominent player in the years to come."

[8.0] "Mia Yim, currently going as Jade in TNA is a very prominent women's wrestler in today's independent scene. She's a skilled wrestler and has a different look, she might lack some natural charisma, but she makes up for that in other ways."