Chelsea Green vs. Dr. Britt Baker DMD vs. Madison Rayne vs. Tessa Blanchard

[7.0] "This was a lot of fun to watch. These four ladies went above and beyond in trying to entertain the fans. Chelsea Green showed signs of becoming a breakout star here with her persona. With a few more minutes, this could have been great, but the sudden ending hurt it just a bit."

[6.0] "Uneven involvement from the female wrestlers, but a good match in which Chelsea Green was particularly in form. Less so for Madison Rayne. In-ring quality: 1.75/4. Stakes: 0.5/2. Justification: 0.5/1. Place on the card : 1/1. Suspense: 1/1. Bonus/malus: none. Total: 5.75/10. Match seen on AEW Plus."

[6.0] "Chelsea Greens gimmic is so odd but of course the inaguraual, longest reigning and greatest US champion could make it work. Also that destroyed by Chelsea was awesome."

[7.0] "A solid match where everyone involved had a good performance, especially Blanchard. The finish was awkward especially considering the live crowds reaction to it in real time. Solid 3 stars."

[5.0] "Kinda meh match, nothing special, nothing to great or too crazy. I mean it was enjoyable but again nothing special. This one could swap places with the opener"

[8.0] "The first match to be that good at this point. After that I was really into this event and it seemed to be the same for the audience. Nice performance by these four women."

[7.0] "The finish of the match was weird, but the match itself is actually a pretty solid and fun four way with all four women involved."

[6.0] "This was a great match that did a lot to showcase Baker, even though she didn't win. They wisely kept her mostly in with Green and Blanchard, since everything fell apart a bit when Rayne got involved."

[7.0] "Great match that let all these entertaining women compete. All of the women in this match are great and got good time to wrestle."

[6.0] "great match and showing for all four of them, crowd got pretty loud for the big spots, it's a shame about the ending though because the match was really picking up"

[6.0] "Good match that felt self-aware because everyone watching already knew that women can wrestle really well."

[6.0] "Good game. Big exposure given to Chelsea Green during this match. The finish is most likely botched with Baker trying to break the pinfall even though it was validated by the referee. (3*1/4)"

[6.0] "A definite early highlight of All In, with four wrestlers of varying fame in 2023 showing why they all belonged on this card in 2018. Chelsea Green was one of the top character workers in women's wrestling and is back in that position today. Britt Baker has become one of the biggest stars in AEW and showed early signs of potential here. Madison Rayne has been a staple of women's wrestling since The Beautiful People and has earned respect across the board. And Tessa Blanchard was well on her way to superstardom. Some fun spots and crowd interactions made this a definite highlight of the show. 3.25 stars, 6.5 out of 10."

[6.0] "This one had its moments, though it did get sloppy at times. I thought Blanchard came across as looking like a million bucks. The match was starting to really click before the botched ending, shame it ended on that note. ***"

[7.0] "This started out slow but developed into a good match by the end. It was clear that Tessa and Madison were the best wrestlers in the match and also that Chelsea's gimmick limited her performance somewhat. Britt was green but the four way match type covered for some of the slip-ups."

[6.0] "Everyone worked really hard. Tessa killed it and was easily the best worker in the match. There were some moments that felt disjointed but they stuck to the plan and got a standing ovation. The finish confused the crowd as they thought the pin was broken up."

[7.0] "What a great female talent was appreciated in the ring, this time in this fight we could see something at the height of what was coming in this PPV, however I was very shocked by the end, on TV it did not look too powerful the final blow of Tessa to win, however I liked it a lot."

[5.0] "This match is just sloppy and not very good. Can't help but feel either a tag match or a singles with two of these women would've worked alot better. **1/2"

[3.0] "Bad advert for womens wrestling, very clunky and lots of botches, lots of stupid fustrating momments where pin breakups should've been alot crisper and quicker. Some okay momments although."

[6.0] "Going into it, this match didn't have the highest of expectations. But all four women delivered one of the better matches of the night, albeit one with a botched finish."

[8.0] "I thought this match was the 5th best of the night. Easily best women's match that I've seen in person. They blew the roof off the place. It's too bad that the ending was kind of flat. ****"

[6.0] "All things considered it was a fine match. There were a few good spots but along with those came the botches. The finish was very odd as well. Also, while this doesn't affect my ranking, Tenille is one of the most underrated workers out there today but the commentary table is just NOT a place for her at all. ***"

[7.0] "This was pretty good, although the finish was flat. Tessa Blanchard and Chelsea Green stood out in this match. Great, nonstop action and good work from all involved. ***1/4"

[5.0] "This was really botchy in places and was a bit messy here and there. Some fun stuff but this didn't really work fully as an entire, cohesive match for me. The only women's match on the card being a 4-way isn't something I love but with the length this show went already, I can excuse it. Not bad but I wasn't really blown away. (**3/4)"

[7.0] "A good match, particularly Blanchard looked very good. I felt Madison was a bit off at times, and maybe Britt as well, rather with they'd put Tenille Dashwood in instead of on commentary, but still they delivered something enjoyable for the fans."

[5.0] "I did not really care about the match that much but it was ok for sure not the best match of the night (That one for me is Okada vs Marty) but it was just ok the botches kinda ruined the match ** 1/2"

[5.0] "Average match. There are some botches and it is a spotfest with finishers and kickouts spamming. Crowd is on fire during the match and Tessa Blanchards takes the spolight that she deserves. The Chelsea's Canadian Destroyer is good. ***"

[10.0] "I firmly believe this was the best women's wrestling match I have ever seen taking place on American soil. It was perfectly paced, with great action. Everyone looked good, and as much as people have been talking about Tessa, and she is really awesome, it was Green who came out of this match looking like a much bigger star than she was before. I loved the way she embraced her character from TNA, changing into something new and interesting. That's the way you get booked."

[6.0] "A good show by all four in the ring; Tess and Chelsea particularly looked good. Britt Baker generally looked okay but did have a couple of botches. Still a fun match."

[7.0] "A very good four way match that let everybody get their piece in and shine. Also, good spot on the card where we hadn't seen everything yet and could allow the competitors to shine and get some high spots in, and the crowd wouldn't be burnt out from anything. Blanchard & Baker stood out and at the top of the class when it comes to woman's wrestling. Green was entertaining and over with the crowd, and Rayne was the veteran glue in this whole thing. Really good match."