Chavo Guerrero vs. Finlay vs. Mark Henry vs. Matt Hardy vs. The Miz

[7.0] "A solid opener with the Championship Scramble being an interesting concept. The fans definitely were wanting to see Hardy get the win here and it was a fun moment at the end to see him making sure that no one was going to get a final pinfall and ensure his title win. This was a good match and it stayed entertaining basically from start to finish. Solid 3 stars."

[7.0] "The Championship Scramble is a fun match, and so was this one. The crowd was super over to Hardy here, and they were thrilled when he won the title. ***1/2"

[5.0] "This was pretty middling and inconsistent in quality as a match, largely due to the fact that Mark Henry drags this down a ton. All the action that doesn't include him is very solid and sometimes quite interesting, and then when he takes over it's bear hug city, his heat segments were just total slogs. I'm not really a fan of this stipulation at all because the pinfalls basically don't count at all until the very end, it can make the finish interesting but for me it's just too difficult to get into the match. Much closer to Dave than Cagematch on this."

[5.0] "The stipulation seemed interesting and the ECW guys got the advantage of going first, so it still felt fresh here. I really liked how Matt was defending his fall and that they didn't go for some kinda multimen spotfest, but it was still a chaos at times."

[5.0] "This match was quite the mix bag. Some moments were awfully dull - bear hug spots 15 minutes into the match? Mhhmmm. It did liven up when Finlay entered and led to a rather chaotic (yet enjoyable) final 3/4 minutes or so. Matt Striker is just horrible on commentary, hard to listen to and detracting from the match. With that said, this turned into a solid match as it progressed (**1/2)."

[7.0] "FINALLY ECW actually gets to show what they can do on PPV. Granted about half of this match is rest holds and that doesn't make for exciting viewing, but you really feel the Scramble part of this match come into play after Finlay comes in. I love the story of Matt Hardy being interim champion and then Mark Henry coming in and ruining his day for a few minutes. Mark Henry plays a great rival for Matt in this match. The last few minutes of this match are insane, Mark going for pins left and right and Matt doing everything he can to stop him while also having to fend off the others. The crowd are going BANANAs for everything because it's so much frantic fun. Luckily the finish saved this match and actually put it over three star territory for me. ***1/4"

[5.0] "Same thing I said about the other Scramble matches. I don't consider it a good stipulation and it's not a mini-Rumble. Great work from The Miz here, but it's not an interesting match and it's very bland overall. Also it's nice to see Mark Henry, Guerrero and Finlay having a good in-ring work. The ending is good because Matt Hardy finally gets the title win. **1/2"

[5.0] "Not a big fan of this match type. This is just a normal multi man match, the only good thing was Matt Hardy winning is first "major" title."