[4.0] "Paige returning was extremely obvious. They built to her tag a lot, just for it to feel anticlimactic. Upping to a 4 after rewatch. Lash is the standout still, but others did some decent things."
[5.0] "Not a great match. Very short but that's not the girls fault. They tried their best for the time they were given. Wrong winners too. It should have been Lyra and Bayley. Paige returning was a fun moment though."
[1.0] "this match was bad, like really bad, it was messy, didn't make sense, they had no time... just bad things, except the return of Paige, execution of the moves was poorly done, no story in the match, only that we need Brie to tag Paige so she can have her hot tag and then win, just bad. if I had an MVP would probably be Nikki Bella! just kidding Lyra was the best in the field, but that's not because of the match that's caused she's LYRA DANIELSON"
[3.0] "Mid but overall had a fun moment and some solid work throughout. Crazy how bad Charlotte was though, and BayLyra barely being in the match at all is embarrassing."
[4.0] "Paige's return really trumped over anything else in the match because the match itself was very substandard. It served its purpose but it should have been better. Got too less time to amount to anything. **"
[4.0] "Boring bland and ultimately passable. It could've been way worse, it could've done literally anything. This match was exceeded by its entrances, and nobody came out in a different position to where they were prior, and while I'm not surprised by that result, I am unimpressed with the match they presented. The action was good, it just didn't feel connected at multiple points, and it felt like the communication in Ring was too visible to the audience. It wanted to be a fun party match, but it was less fun than the prior match and never exceeded the surprise return (which was rushed and could've been announced better). Shame for the Irresistible Forces reign to end like this since I've been really enjoying them lately."
[2.0] "Awful match. Boring, with many botches, inaccuracies. The only good thing was seeing Paige again, but other than that, the match sucked. Nia Jax is always one of the worst out there, it seems like there is no way for her to improve. But it's not as if the others were much better. Overall a forgettable match."
[3.0] "I really didn't enjoy this match that much because, honestly, it felt messy from beginning to end. And that's a real shame, because the rivalry surrounding these titles had been genuinely good and brought a refreshing feeling to the division. I'm quite disappointed that the match didn't live up to the intensity of the feud. It's even more frustating because, for once, in this kind of match, every team involved felt credible and had something genuinely good to offer in the ring."
[7.0] "Once again, should've been longer, should've had a video package. That said, Paige's return felt like a big deal and is a "Mania Moment" I'll fondly remember for a long time. I rate fade-in to fade-out based on personal enjoyment, and this match had a bunch of my faves, a great surprise, a fun result, and served it's role as another highlight on a card with several of them. Plus, I thought the match was good. Different strokes etc."
[3.0] "The match was pretty average, I mean, with Nia and the Bella sisters, it was obviously just okay. The match was clearly designed to showcase Paige's return, and it showed; she was the only one with real moves and the only one who truly shone during the match. However, to have a returning player win on the DAY of her comeback? Especially with a title on the line? ! I really don't understand that decision."
[6.0] "It was a specifically good match, and with Paige returning, the result was expected. (I felt sorry for Bayley and Lyra; Bayley missed out on her WrestleMania moment once again). Paige looked great, and I'm curious to see what's next for her. Nia Jax and Lash Legend also played their parts well. The entrances and gears for Charlotte and Alexa Bliss were also awesome"
[6.0] "This match was okay, everyone had heard Paige was returning so it lost it's overall hype. It was over in a flash, Paige did okay, but won't be a match I will remember to go down in history!"
[6.0] "I thought that this match was honestly pretty decent, it probably should have had just a few more minutes but overall it was pretty good. Paige's return saved the hype for this match. If it was just as advertised, this match would have still had the amount of hype it had coming into Mania, which was none. I think that the main moment in the match which was the Paige hot tag, was pretty good. Paige also looked like she didn't have much ring rust, and had a really good spot with Charlotte. I am kinda glad that they didn't showcase Nia as much because I don't think she was the greatest person in the match. They also made the right call with Paige and Brie Bella, but I am kinda confused on how this tag team will dissolve."
[5.0] "Paige's return was impressive and came as a surprise to me. It was a good tag team match. Paige's positioning was great, but the way Alexa was humiliated prevents me from giving the match a high rating. No matter who Paige is, she's no match for Alexa Bliss. They could have brought in Lash Legend or Nia Jax."
[5.0] "This was a match that should've had big moments but it wasn't exciting by any means. However it was without a doubt the feel good moment of the night. Welcome back Paige! So good to see her again in a WWE ring."
[9.0] "Maybe I'm overreaching the match grade, but I was also one of the very few viewers who was not spoiled in advance that Paige would replace Brie Bella, so when I heard Paige's theme, I was genuinely excited, which got me hooked into this match. The match itself was fast-paced, high action and engaging, and that is the kind of matches I enjoy. Seeing Paige win with her good friend Nikki with the support of Brie was genuinely a feel-good moment for me. The match was short, but also very fun when it happened. Avoid social media. These returns, when kept secret, make it feel more special. We need more of that."
[6.0] "A solid match that was full of action and a happy ending as Paige and Brie Bella became the new Women's Tag Team Champions, thanks to Nikki beating up Charlotte Flair with the crutch on the floor. It's one of those things where if you bring in a substitute in a match like this, then you often see that person win a title in a match like this. I thought if Nikki Bella was healthy, then The Bella Twins were going to win, but with Nikki out, I thought maybe WWE would delay that title change because it's not The Bella Twins winning together. However, it still works fine with Brie and Paige. I don't mind it at all. I would have liked to see the match get more time to tell more of a story, but they did do a nice job of building to Paige's hot tag."
[6.0] "Paige's return was a lot of fun to see! It was a pleasant surprise for this match and I thought this match was very clean and well put together especially the finish with Paige getting the win for her team to win that tag titles with Brie Bella! Truthfully I thought this match would have been a better opener for the show it would have done a great job setting the tone for what was to come in the show the crowd was into it and it had great high spots and good pace my favorite part of the match was when Paige and Charlotte had their moment together!"
[6.0] "Again I think this match was good. The fact that all four teams had a member legal at all times gives away that they were never gonna go long nor did they want to plan a match that would require multiple tags but for what it was it worked. Paige's return gave a good structure for the start of the match as her tag was constantly cut off. Everyone else looked pretty good despite how little chances to shine they got. When Paige finally got in the crowd lit up and she looked as solid as she did in AEW. Highlight of he match was Paige and Charlotte Flair throwing down with some really nice looking forearms. Paige and Brie Bella pick up the feel good win. It's again nothing special and didn't get enough time but it was fun"
[3.0] "[1.25*] - It's impossible to say that this match didn't have good build-up over the weeks. Bayley & Lyra Valkyria and Charlotte Flair & Alexa Bliss had the best interactions during their feud, and it was to be expected that the same would happen in this match. I would have been happy if either of them had won, especially Bayley after the last year. Only eight minutes isn't enough time to showcase much between four tag teams, it was practically one minute for each wrestler to give themselves a chance to shine before the end. Paige returned and won the title with Nikki working as a heel while they were babyfaces (? )"
[5.0] "The woman here all looked and performed great but the time in the match really hurt it. 8 minutes to highlight 8 women is just not going to help anyone. A great moment for Paige but shadowed by the disrespect the wrestlers are being shown."
[4.0] "Saraya's return here was the only major highlight in this match, it was the most interesting whenever she was in the ring as her character has not had the chance to be ruined by WWE's creative. The match was clunky as they decided the rules would be that four women would be in the ring at once instead of the standard two, leaving awkward segments where people are obviously waiting for spots"
[5.0] "I'm glad Paige got her Wrestlemania moment but I tuned out of this fairly short match about two minutes before she even tagged in. What a waste of Charlotte and Alexa's amazing cosplay entrance. There was so much going on in the ring with, usually, four women in at a time but, apart from some great Lash Legend moments, none of the chaos was entertaining. Every woman in this match, except maybe Brie Bella, was capable of so much better than this botch-filled snoozefest."
[3.0] "I hate the decision to put the title on paige when she literally just came back. There are way more talented wrestlers, of the likes are Bailey and Lyra. I would've loved to see them have the belt and put on great matches. I hope Brie and paige drops the belt soon."
[4.0] "This match was really a mess as the competitors had to scramble to accommodate the return of Paige at the last minute. The match kind of felt all over the place but was not necessarily boring. Paige and Charlotte staring down was cool, but the match was pretty short. Rampaige on Alexa Bliss gives the returning Paige the belts immediately with Brie Bella. Rating: **"
[5.0] "Good moment with Paige's return. Think this match was too short making the match feel a little rushed and a little sloppy. Was kind of surprised they gave Paige and Brie the titles even though until Nikki was injured, I expected the Bellas. Just expected a little more from this match other than a good return home moment."
[7.0] "a fun, chaotic, action packed fatal 4 way championship match with an amazing return and moment for paige, honestly couldnt have asked for more as i went into this match with incredibly low expecations"
[3.0] "Really short as everything else on this card, felt like an old Divas era match where they try to fit as many people possible into a match and nothing happens."
[4.0] "Another match I was not looking forward to and got me all confused when Paige returned. Even more confused, I became when she won the titles. I guess it's a moment. The match was fine. Nothing noteworthy except for the face off between Paige and Flair. Also the absolute disgust in Alexa's face when Charlotte came out with even bigger wings, lol."
[6.0] "I expected that it will be dynamic action, where everyone had an enough time to shine and particulary that was like this, besides the time what can be bigger to that match. We got a return of Paige and she won the titles with Brie on her first match. I have a neutral position to this."
[3.0] "Cool to see Paige back in WWE but it makes me slightly concerned about WWE's plans for her moving forward. I'm not a big fan of WWE pushing older stars over younger talent so hopefully that isn't something that happens. I say that like her and Brie didn't win the tag titles which was the last thing I wanted to happen :/"
"Paige's return was nice, but the match was a bit sloppy and just busywork until the finish, which I thought was quite poorly executed. Also, given that this situation is very similar to last year's (Someone can't make the Mania card and has to be replaced by a returning Wrestler), I can't call it inspired."
[2.0] "When Paige walked out I couldn't help but laugh. Someone who was ok before injuries and is now washed up teaming with someone who was never any good. In a way it perfectly sums up the current product. This whole match does. Nothing special, belts no one cares about and don't mean anything and is ultimately filler. It is almost comical that WWE wanted nothing to do with her when she wanted to return but suddenly it's ok again. Gosh I wonder why..."
[5.0] "Not enough time given to a really talented group of ladies. Paige's return was cool, but for her and Brie to actually win the titles makes the least sense out of the 4 teams. Obviously, the Bellas were supposed to win prior to the injury, but they should have pivoted. It wasn't a bad match or anything; it was just a match that happened."
[4.0] "This was the most fine match of all time. Youd think a 8 woman fatal 4 way tag team match would get more than 8 minutes noting the all faces in the match but it was just another wrestlemania 42 night 1 disappointment. Sure, the Paige return was "cool" but it was super expected."
[5.0] "Hard to believe with how blazing hot this division was a short 4-5 months ago, this is the payoff for it at "the biggest stage". Cool to see Paige return but to sacrifice Bayley (and by extension Lyra) again at the altar of cheap pops is unfortunately pretty par for the course at this point. How you give any flavor of fatal four way under 10 minutes is beyond me."
[3.0] "Everything wrong with women's wrestling not only in WWE, but in the United States right now is on full display here. Lyra and Bayley were absolute workhorses in 2025, they kept losing tag matches when they could have gone after singles titles. They had the perfect opportunity to give them the tag titles as a full circle moment, and guess what happens? They lose. Why? Because for the 2nd time in a row, Bayley gets screwed over for the sake of a return. Paige is not needed in WWE either. This is a complete step backwards. The match itself was very forgettable. Barely got any time and it felt super rushed. I genuinely cannot remember any moves that half the people in this match did. The cameraman falling down during this sums this up as a whole. *1/2"
[3.0] "**1/2 meh match, they tried, there was effort from the wrestlers but they were hardly going to do anything better, there were some rough moments and time limited the opportunities the participants had, Paige returned and didn't look bad, the ending was strange, Nikki remembers that there's no disqualification and interferes at the end by attacking Charlotte and distracting Alexa, which Paige takes advantage of to hit her finisher on Alexa after reversing her Twisted Bliss and winning the titles"
[6.0] "Welcome back, Paige! She looked very good in her return with textbook offense, capping off with a cool face-off against Charlotte. Otherwise, it was a nice tag clash where every team had their moment to shine at the same time (which needs to be the permanent fix for multi-team matches), especially Lash for her first 'Mania. The return made the result obvious, but in a good way, as her presence at this time would greatly help the division. 3 out of 5 stars!"
[1.0] "[0.5 Stars] The WWE have shown us time and time again, through their actions, that they do not give a shit about the WWE Women's Tag Team titles and so, why should we? Well, lemme tell ya, matches like this certainly don't do anything for the cause."
[5.0] "Once Paige returned (which is a nice moment for her and got a good reaction) there was only ever going to be one team winning. The stuff in ring wasn't bad, but it wasn't really good either. They weren't given much time and I thought the finish just made Alexa look stupid. I can understand her being distracted initially by Charlotte getting hit by the crutch on the outside, but she stood on the top rope for what felt like eternity looking back and forth conflicted as to whether she should just hit her move and win the match or help her partner on the outside. It telegraphed that Paige was going to counter the twisted bilss, which she did, and got the win. Nice moment for Paige, match was fine."
[4.0] "Paige's return was probably the most memorable moment of the whole show. As it was it was kind of just "there", with them not really having much time to tell a proper story in there (a problem the women suffered with all weekend). Breezy and to the point. If other women's matches had been given more time over the weekend then this would being more of a sprint wouldn't be as egregious"
[2.0] "Paige returning after almost a decade is cool... but that's about it. Lash Legend pretty much owns this match as that big bad boujee bully, but it's still an 8-minute mess packed with a bunch of mishaps. On top of that, Brie and Paige winning is a slap to the face of the division if you ask me. That's the payoff after months of building-up the division? I don't care about Brie's incompetent butt and a returning Paige getting their "WrestleMania moment", this is just distasteful. *1/2"
[3.0] "All points for Paige, I loved that return and the fact she won the title means we will get more of her. other than this, it was a terribly short match, 8 wrestlers and 8 minutes at WrestleMania. What the hell is happening. It's enough for the likes of Flair to be included in tag division, let her fight for other things too."
0x
1x
4x
15x
88x
196x
187x
95x
11x
3x
0x