Dr. Britt Baker DMD vs. Hikaru Shida vs. Nyla Rose vs. Riho

[6.0] "This was sloppier than I expected from a match involving Riho and Shida, yet Baker looked better than usual. It's like her skill infused everyone else. Still, it was quite fun, and made Riho look good with the win."

[8.0] "A very good match here but it's crazy how Nyla Rose and Hikaru Shida look better and way more relevant to carry this division than Riho and Baker. Riho is not solid enough and Baker is clearly not ready for the big spot. The title belongs to Rose or Shida. Period."

[6.0] "I thought this was a solid four way here. For me, the MVP of this match was Nyla Rose; I thought she did great here. Shida was also a joy here. There was some fun moments with weapons in this match. I couldn't tell you a thing Britt Baker did in this match. Riho retains her title by rolling up Britt."

[7.0] "This was made on short notice and the women made the most of it, some fantastic stuff here and a fantastic four way."

[5.0] "Rose and Shida went through a table. Baker and Riho were just there. This was pretty much an average bout."

[6.0] "***1/4 rating. Solid match. Slightly entertaining match thanks mostly to Hikaru Shida & Riho. Nyla is still bad, very sloppy. Baker's slowly improving."

[6.0] "Enjoyable match I thought everyone played their roles well although Baker still looks incredibly green, Rose did a great job as the dominant monster throughout and Shida put in an exceptional performance and finally Riho as the underdog champion."

[4.0] "Riho (c) -vs- Dr. Britt Baker DMD -vs- Hikaru Shida -vs- Nyla Rose - (AEW Women's Title) [**] All kinds of sloppy, but the energy was high anytime Rose wasn't bumping blowing all the air out, falling hard like a lump of meat. The dynamic here really showed the challenge of too light and too heavy. Can be incorporated into the story of the match, but it's equally troublesome in regards to the illusion. But overall, it was fine and Rose got to put little Riho devastatingly through a table."

[3.0] "A typically trashy match from the AEW women. The only decent action was, as always, provided by Shida. Baker was frankly an embarrassment, she can't even make a forearm to the back look convincing. Rose was okay and used a natural power advantage well, but was puffed out after any exertion. Riho is a fetish wrestler and needs to be binned off sharpish and never seen again. There are some talented female wrestlers on the roster, but they weren't in this match, which will only increase the amount of viewers who skip the women altogether. Statlander and Gibbs may be green, but along with Kong and Shida, they could scrape together a few decent matches. I can only think those enjoying the AEW women's matches so far must be having a wank rather than rating the actual wrestling."

[7.0] "Surprisingly fun, sloppy in spots but overall quick and well laid out. Shida came off as the biggest star off the four in the match."

[6.0] "Pretty soild *** star definition here. It didn't overstay welcomed but never reached the next level, either. The action was quite solid with all normal stuff from multi-women match. Nothing new here. Fine watch on a TV show."

[9.0] "Very much enjoyed this, easily my second favorite match on the show. I still haven't seen much to justify the push of Baker but the other three looked fantastic here, Riho has done very well but Shida or Nyla would be poised to be a great champion as well. The women of AEW continue to impress whether they're appreciated or not, though the division could use more meaningful stories and booking for sure."

[8.0] "Very good match. Riho got a standing ovation coming out, Shida also got a pretty good response during the match. Nyla did some cool power and athleticism spots and killed Shida on the outside with a brutal looking senton. The story of the match made sense and the finish continues to play off the tenacity and resiliency of the champion. The post match was effective and you feel like there's still a lot of stories to be told between these 4 women."

[7.0] "The hot crowd and this being a four way helped make this match memorable for me. The fact that it was just a stand-in for the Statlander/Riho match was quickly forgotten, as all four women went full speed to keep the energy up. Britt Baker, while clearly being the less experienced wrestler in the match, had a good showing, too, while Shida was awesome. Nyla Rose looked good, too, although I still am not 100% on board with her character or wrestling style. Riho was Riho, which is really not meant as a compliment or a critique, but in the limited doses of her offense, it was fine. She would make a great accordeon in another life, though. Glad the champion won in the end, as I hate the idea of titles changing hands in multi-person matches."