"I have been talking up Tatum in my comments and this is a good example of why NXT is failing with her. Pick a lane and stay there with a character. These fans from the other side of the US paid to see a minor league product, yet they don't believe in the minor league girls against the WWE champions. This was silent. They pretty much squash Tatum doing a 450 splash. Who cares, right? All the women do that shit. Right? Sad that the best showing from Gigi is something where she barely shows up.."
[3.0] "*.75 Not good stuff here sloppy ugly just not good whatsoever these ladies capable of much better not even debatable, genuinely stunned & bewildered why this has such a decent rating for such a shit match, it was uhly & sloppy throughout so I'm confused"
[6.0] "Even though the result was never in doubt, Gigi & Tatum proved a good point as the underdogs that almost took the titles off the newly minted champs. At certain moments, the chemistry between these teams was odd, but the recovery from such spots was nicely done, thanks to the experience of Liv & Gigi. I'm not sure if this reign will be as lengthy as their previous stints, but it feels cool to see Liv & Raquel being the prominent figures of the women's tag division. 3 out of 5 stars!"
[6.0] "A good enough tag match but clunky at times. Liv and Gigi seemed to have the most experience, but raquel and tatum had some bad exchanges. Overall they both work good as a tag teams and with a little more working together they could pull off a better match in the future."
[6.0] "Solid match for the women's tag team titles. This was just a filler defense for Liv and Raquel so there wasn't any suspense over who was going to win, but still it was nice for Gigi and Tatum to get this opportunity. Decent action with the challengers getting a fair amount of offense against the champions. Liv and Raquel eventually pull off the victory to retain. 6/10"
[6.0] "(Grade:C/***) A nice little title defense against the newly crowned Judgement Day(still baffled they lost it and gain it within 24 hours) and good on Liv & Raquel for their 3-day matches streak! Tatum & Gigi looked good here too, showing off that drive and intensity to try and win the belts but end with no prize. Tatum continues to impress me especially with that apron moonsault on Liv & Raquel which they got all knees on that one as well as the 450 splash. Also, I be forgetting how long Gigi been in the business like OG Evolve days and she still keeping up the work."
[10.0] "Three matches three nights in a row, Liv & Raquel are WORKING and it's for the good of this women's division, which has really taken off over the last year and is a solid continuation of the foundations laid by Bianca & Jade. A good match with very solid and energetic action, totally what I expected. Chemical X are a lot of fun.""Liv Morgan has been the MVP of the Women's Division this year, and in this match, Liv Morgan & Raquel Rodriguez both had solid outings against Gigi Dolin and Tatum Paxley."
[8.0] "Liv and Raquel are Killing it, they Wrestled on Sunday, had an Amazing match yesterday again, and Today they did so well with Gigi and Tatum, I also really like them, and i think that they are such a fun tag team, and they did so well at there Eliminaton Match at Stand and deliver. The Two teams had some chemistry with one another, and they sold each others moves so well. I think that they should bring Back the NXT women's Tag Titles and give them to Tatum and Gigi. The ending was amazing with Gigi selling that ObLIVion so well."
[6.0] "The Women's Tag Team Championship match was okay, despite several botches. The tag champs did their part, but given that Gigi and Tatum aren't real contenders for the title, there was zero suspense. Looking forward, I don't mind if the backstage interaction with Zaruca might build something for the future. It can be a banger!"
[8.0] "Definitely not better than last nights tag match but man Liv is on some run as a champ, giving bangers while elevating the title, I did hate the Mania booking but this, despite the rocky moments was still very enjoyable."
[7.0] "Liv Morgan has been the MVP of the Women's Division this year, and in this match, Liv Morgan & Raquel Rodriguez both had solid outings against Gigi Dolin and Tatum Paxley. This was a fine opener for the show. And The Judgement Day retained against Gigi Dolin and Tatum Paxley."
[6.0] "Liv and Raquel were not losing the titles twice in three days, so that took a lot of suspense away from this match. Solid bout though, with Tatum Paxley showing signs of improvement."
[7.0] "Three matches three nights in a row, Liv & Raquel are WORKING and it's for the good of this women's division, which has really taken off over the last year and is a solid continuation of the foundations laid by Bianca & Jade. A good match with very solid and energetic action, totally what I expected. Chemical X are a lot of fun."