[1.0] "Mandy was not that good in the ring and the fact she had such a long reign as NXT Women's champion was mind-boggling... In the ring she had a limited move-set and the moves she did just didn't look good; she focused so much on her looks when she should've focused on getting better in the ring, she always, in my opinion, looked scared to take a good bump and that held her back. I will always believe that she and Sonya should've held the tag team championships at some point, I was never really a fan of them, but they deserved at least one reign. When she went back to NXT and formed Toxic Attraction I thought she would've reignited a fire for supporting her, but she just became unbearable and over-pushed."
[10.0] "I personally loved the Golden Goddess character on the main roster, and I wish they continued with that gimmick. When Mandy Rose was thrown back into NXT, she absolutely made the most of it. She surprised everyone by winning the NXT Title in her first challenge. She continuously defended the championship on TV and on every PLE. She elevated both Gigi Dolin and Jacy Jayne to heights they hadn't ever seen since. Toxic Attraction should have gone on to dominate on the main roster, and I'm super disappointed with how WWE handled her firing. I truly hope she returns someday because I don't think she is done yet, and she can have such an amazing main roster run!"
[1.0] "I will never forgive Mandy for tarnishing the once prestigious NXT Women's Championship. Her seemingly never ending reign did nothing to improve her image. Then she was demanding to give her some "respect" when she was the champion? How can people even respect her if she can't even win on her own? As much as her simps try to tell everyone that she deserves better, Mandy is awful and will forever be a disgrace to the division. I'm glad she got fired and hopefully never comes back. And to all fans of Mandy, remember what AJ Lee said before? 'Talent is not sexually transmitted, ' yeah, reality hurts and Mandy fits that line well lmao."
[10.0] "Mandy Rose single handedly carried that women's division and breathed new life into it while having the best run of her career. She deserved better. Waiting for her return and I for one totally missed her. Wish she make her debut in AEW television and Tony Khan would be fool not to sign her. She's worthy she's more of draw power and rating. She prove she hang with anyone in the NXT roster or with top stars in the company. I dont know why they fired her she deserve much more than that and deserve to be called up to the main roster and push."
[1.0] "Mandy Rose was a terrible Wrestler, her reign of Terror represents how bad the beginning of NXT 2.0 was, interestingly, the Show improved a lot after her departure. She couldn't wrestle, All her defenses, the match she was loaded with or if not the match was boring, Her reign was terrible, a feeling that anyone could win and would be much better than her."
[10.0] "Mandy rose really needs to be respected, she improved a lot since she went down to nxt and showed up to work, not like other champions. she proved she can give WWE womens a new face and new talents to be pushed, she put over roxanne before getting released but people still talk about her. Mandy Rose is the best. she really did her work and she was a gem for shawn michaels but sadly she got released. i really hope shes going to do a full return in ring either impact or wwe because she can fight and deliver some good matched and heel work."
[6.0] "Improved a lot since coming to NxT. Her ring work is decent enough and promo work + mic work is good. People don't give her athleticism and in ring skills enough credit, she might not be on the level of many of the past NXT Women Champions but her work isn't anything to scoff at."
[1.0] "Looks great but was a pretty bad worker, with Sonya Deville having a better look and being a better worker than her and she had some awfully cringe promos. Also got fired due to not caring about breaking rules in regards to a raunchy fan site so clearly didn't have the love for the business some of her peers had."
[3.0] "Am Anfang fand ich sie nicht so schlecht. Zumindest in Tag Team Matches konnte man die Schwächen verdecken. Nur der NXT Run war nichts. Eine lange Regentschaft mit nicht so guten Matches. Wird ehrlich gesagt nicht vermisst bei NXT."
[6.0] "Liked her a lot, just never really got it going until NXT 2.0, she was still pretty fresh in terms of being a wrestler for most he career in the WWE"
[4.0] "Mandy Rose is one of WWE's many attempts at creating the next Trish, but unlike Trish, she never became good in the ring or on the mic and only had real momentum in the company twice, as a face with Otis and feuding with Sonya, and as a heel champion in NXT leading Toxic Attraction. She would have fit in better in the Attitude Era or the PG era, when women like her were pushed and winning titles."
[7.0] "Mandy Rose wasn't bad in the ring and showed a lot of personality, even without possessing show-stopping promo ability. It would be a huge shame if we never saw her wrestle again."
[2.0] "She should never have been champion. Her in ring skill were far from good. She buried talent twice her skill level. You could see in those matches the other women had to slow down so she could keep up. It was painful to see. She ruiner the title in my eyes. The entire NXT 2.0 was hurting because of her. She held that belt for waaaay too long. Glad she Lost it."
[5.0] "Mandy was a good kind of champion for NXT 2.0, she was all about looks unfortunatley. She had a typical "Stacy from Highschool" heel gimmick and mic work, so there was not many things she could do bad there. Her ring work? Meh, could've been worse, and definetly could've been better. The kind of trouble that she went through that made her lose the title was to be expected tbh. I'm not gonna say she ain't gonna be missed, but I really wont be missing her."
[0.0] "Probably one of the worst high profile (ish) wrestlers in the world. Even with a rating at just under 5, I still think she? s massively overrated. There just isn? t anything even remotely compelling about her whatsoever. Her title reign lasted over 400 days, the 3rd longest in NXT history, and not once did she manage to have a match that wasn? t bad, even against opponents like Io Shirai. Her reign also basically murdered the NXT Women? s Division. I? m not even trying to be a jerk, it? s just that I can? t think of a single redeemable quality Mandy Rose possesses to rate her higher than a 0."
[9.0] "He was already doing a good job on the main roster along with Dana Brooke and after he returned to NXT he just continued to work and improve. Mandy has come a long way since Tough Enough and I'm happy to have watched her grow."
[3.0] "She's had her time to prove herself as a wrestler people can get invested in with an over year long NXT title run, and has just about barely eked out a handful of matches people consider "good", all of which are with some of the most experienced and prestigious wrestlers in the world like Io Shirai and Meiko Satomura. There is noone even close to her when it comes to worst NXT women's champ of all time and it's resulted in the belt dropping in value over the year as the belt trudges on in her possession with not a lot of direction aside from continuing to win. The best we can hope for is her increased platform from her main roster run allows her to put over the younger, better wrestlers in her stable."
[2.0] "When she debuted I had a lot of hopes for her but unfortunately she have not progress since her debut on the main roster. She is taking the NXT Title hostage right now, and I find toxic attraction to be a terrible stabble."
[7.0] "She definetly deserves more credit for her work in the ring. Strong look but could use with acting lessons and more coaching around her promo ability but she's getting there week by week."
[3.0] "Not as bad as some would make her out to be but bad none the less. Ok promo not good in ring ok gimik and a good look. All of that makes her place as nxt 2.0(3.0? ) Womens champ make sense.what a shame"
[6.0] "Consistancy defines her best. Constant improvement both in and out of the ring has truly been a saving grace for Mandy Rose. She may not be the best wrestler out there, but she can carry herself in any kind of matches. Her character work and her promo ability have also improved, much more than what she gets credit for. She seems really at ease nowadays in front of the cameras. For the cons, her wrestling lacks fluidity and she still seems to be afraid to take bumps. Her NXT Women's Championship reign has truly been enjoyable and she managed to become a pretty solid champion character wise. I believe she would thrive much more if coupled with experienced opponents, which will happen inevitably when she returns to the MR."
[4.0] "I'll say this, she has Indeed improved during her time in NXT... but she was pretty awful to begin with, she could only go up. I feel like her improvements are mainly in terms of presence, and yes, she feels like a bigger star. She looks more confident in herself in her entrance and on the mic, but she is still pretty mediocre in the ring and with her promos."
[5.0] "Feel like her NXT improvement is sometimes overstated but she's been given a chance and hasn't completely fumbled it even though I'd like to have seen her drop that belt a while ago"
[0.0] "Sorry aber das diese talentlose Frau einen Frauentitel in der größten und bekanntesten Wrestling Promotion der Welt für satte 300+ Tage halten darf, ist für mich schon fast ein Skandal. Die hat sich in den letzten Jahren null verbessert in Sachen Ringfähigkeiten. Wahnsinn!"
[0.0] "Mandy Rose is the worst NXT Women's Champion in history. Not only is she capable of putting on good matches, but also she is a very boring champion. Better wrestlers like Candice Lerae, Tegan nox, Dakota kai, and even Toni Storm deserved to be Become the champion instead of Mandy and record a more attractive title reign than Mandy.In addition, Mandy became a champion only because of her good looks and has remained a champion until now, and she has put his main focus on selling his photos on the website that he recently opened and instead of creating appeal with wrestling content for more fans. He thinks about being a model and looking more attractive than before"
[4.0] "Having seen her fumble her way through NXT, it's clear Mandy Rose is only good enough to be in a tag team with Sonya Deville. She was actually alright on the main roster and for a time I thought she was developing well. Since Toxic Attraction formed in NXT, she has regressed badly in the ring. She telegraphs, no sells and sandbags constantly, thereby making her opponents look shit even if they're talented. Gets by on a wooden mean girl gimmick, something that has been done many times before in wrestling and much better! Rose has been rewarded with the NXT women's title for no reason. It's funny because the whole purpose of NXT 2.0 was to emphasize younger developmental talent. Mandy has been with WWE for 7 years, she is not a 20-something newbie anymore! Worst champ in that belt's history and a slap in the face of every talented woman who held it before her. The best thing about Toxic Attraction is Gigi Dolin who is the workhorse of that group. More talented and charismatic than the leader. My only hope is once the group is called up to the main roster, HHH books Mandy purely as a manager and keeps the wrestling to Gigi and Jacy."
[1.0] "A very poor champion so far. She does the generic mean girl gimmick, and her in ring skills are well below average considering how long she's been there, on top of being a champion. Her acting is also abysmal. Updating my rating from a 2 to a 1. She still hasn't improved at all, and has gotten progressively more and more selfish in the ring, and has stopped selling in some cases."
[0.0] "Well, maybe I was wrong in giving her 3/10 calling her "charismatic", but it made clear to me that this aspect is very far from her, the wrestlers charisma is not only by their look, but must be inside the ring by showing that the wrestler in front of you is less than you/on your level but she is lack that very much. There is no need to talk about the rest of the rating aspects about her, very bad in-ring worker with a sloppy pick of moves, very weak on the mic and definitely Overpush without deserve."
[6.0] "I think Mandy is decent. Doesn't blow me away in any category but okay and serviceable everywhere. Her biggest asset is sex appeal. Her work with Toxic Attraction is solid."
[0.0] "A bad wrestler, an even worse promo with no charisma and her gimmick is entirely focused on her 'incredible' looks, which to me, she doesn't have, so she really doesn't have any upside at all. The NXT women's title used to be extremely prestigious, being held by great wrestlers who put on fantastic matches, but as of this writing, Mandy has been stinking the joint up as champion for 254 days with a cavalcade of bad matches and wooden, droning promos. In fact, during her time as champ, the only title match or non title singles match she has had that didn't suck was a four way which was carried entirely by Kay Lee Ray and the best women's wrestler of all time, Io Shirai. So not only is she lacking in all of the criteria for a professional wrestler, but her reign of terror like push has destroyed the prestige of what I once considered the top women's title in the industry and turned it into a joke."
"Underrated and under appreciated. Mandy's actually mid pack to lower upper pack in the ring, she sells well, and her core offense is consistent. Consistency is key with Mandy, she's going to always deliver her side in a match, but shouldn't be expected to carry green wrestlers. She's good on the microphone and serves a valuable role. Her return to the main roster will be interesting."
[6.0] "Mandy is not the best wrestler but she is doing well in the ring. Her reign as next women's champion is too long for my taste but it remains correct"
[6.0] "Mandy Rose hasn't been the same wrestler since she split off from and finished her feud with Sonya Deville, I enjoyed her when they were together, but since a move to RAW and being teamed up with Dana Brooke, she regressed quite a lot. Now Rose has been moved back to NXT, and it looks like there's some plans in place, so hopefully this allows her to improve in-ring, because she definitely has a TV friendly look. (June 2022) The improvement has been marginal somewhat, but NXT put the women's title on her, and she's formed Toxic Attraction alongside Gigi Dolin and Jacy Jayne. Her best recent match was against Io Shirai and the former Kay Lee Ray (now Alba Fyre), but she still seems to get lost against talented workers in singles matches."
[5.0] "It took 6 years for Mandy Rose to get over besides a comedy angle. This iteration of her is her best, and it isn't the Generic Blonde WWE loves. I think her promo skills are pretty average and I think she's a better worker than what she gets credit for, but by no means is she good in the ring. She still has potential in her career."
[7.0] "Mandy Rose is probably by WWE standards the full package, given her great figure and natural aura as a heel champion. Although her, in-ring work is passable, her presence as leader of Toxic Attraction is evidently helping to put Gigi and Jacy over too. Ultimately, she is extremely similar to Britt Baker over in AEW. However, the key difference here is that Mandy is improving the women's division as a whole by improving the presentation of everyone around her as opposed to suffocating it by pushing herself to the point where no one comes out looking better."
[5.0] "She's not good in the ring but she can deliver on the mic and deliver a good promo. She has shown potential but her character can be one dimensional at times. Her story with Otis was a certain highlight. Overall, she's a solid supporting player overall. She's improved a lot since coming in as well and not nearly as bad as perceived. Her strength is also pretty impressive when she gets to show it. I don't think she gets enough time on the main roster and easily gets lost in the shuffle but in NXT she's been able to rediscover her character and get back on track."
[6.0] "I've always been baffled by the hate Mandy Rose receives from people online. I don't really think she's that bad. Her ring worm on the main roster ranged from solid to poor, however since returning to NXT she has been steadily improving in the ring. She has some solid power based offense and can sell decently as well. On the microphone, she can talk, but she's pretty basic and monotone. Overall I think she's solid, and the rating she has on this site doesn't do her justice at all."
[6.0] "I've always viewed Mandy as a poor man's Trish Stratus and my perception hasn't changed much. I used to defend her when everyone trashed her on the main roster, she has never been particularly bad in the ring but she ain't great either. Her run in NXT is pretty generic and her title reign has been without credible title defenses. Her in-ring work hasn't improved much either. 6/10"
[5.0] "She has had some pretty awesome gimmicks throughout her time in WWE and occasionally shows glimpses of great in-ring work but is well below the standard for a champion (currently NXT Women's Champ). She is quite powerful."
[6.0] "I think she's worth more than the sum of her parts, she does have the throwback quality of being a model, but the thing is, she's improved a ton the past year by comparison. She knows how to work a crowd, psychology has gotten better to make up for a lack of great ringwork. And her promo game is getting better too (and can occasionally outshine her stiff acting)."
[8.0] "Someone who i don't think gets enough credit. A lot are quick to write her off as just a "diva" but in realty she is a very good athlete. Her charisma is very high and her gimmick work is great."
[1.0] "While she isn't completely terrible in the ring, it's pretty obvious they only gave her the NXT Women's title at this time in an attempt to boost ratings for NXT 2.0 and bring in younger men. It's having the opposite effect. In terms of ring and character work, while she has improved marginally, that's not good enough to be a top champion of a brand. There are several other women on that show right now who should be champion over her, as they bring a lot more to the table in pretty much every single metric."
[7.0] "Two years ago, this would be a 4/5, the in-ring work wasn't great and it wasn't a stretch to say she was given her opportunities for her looks and athleticism, as opposed to her in-ring ability. However, with her more recent NXT run and picking up the title, she has shown that she has improved leaps and bounds and is able now to carry matches and not look out of place with the top level athletes such as Raquel Gonzales, the former champion. Her recent work with Toxic Attraction has been excellent and has made it that the women's division of NXT is must-watch if you want to see the show."
[7.0] "After many years being little more than just another pretty face in the crowd (she had the charisma but not the in-ring skills), she's finally developing into a rather solid worker. Her return to NXT has really paid dividends."
[10.0] "I really love Mandy Rose and feel like she had the potential to be a major star in the company, especially following the angles with Otis and her great SummerSlam match with Sonya Deville. She's charismatic, an incredibly likeable babyface, has a great look and wonderful major offence and every time she stepped in the ring, she made significant improvements. If she'd been given direction afterwards, I'd root for her to win a world championship. Plus, it's undeniable that in a dismal time for WWE, she created an emotional connection, which can't be denied."
[7.0] "I would say her rating is confusing, but it? s not really since wrestling fans like to dismiss any improvements conventionally attractive models make. Mandy is good in the ring and has enough charisma to get by. I? m very interested to see what she does after her feud with Sonya."
[0.0] "No sign of improvement. None. While she doesn? t botch, she? s slow and clunky in the ring. Her matches are nothing but a few slams and a knee. Liv Morgan came up at the same time and is miles ahead of Rose now. I thought maybe she? d add to her moveset now that she? s face but the few times she? s been in the ring since then, it? s the same old, same old. With all the time off, she could be at the PC training and working on something new but she? s too busy shaking her a** on Tiktok and promoting her outside ventures. She? s all looks which wouldn? t be a bad thing if she had charisma... but she doesn? t. Let? s not even get into her robotic voice. The only thing likable about her is Otis and once that angle is done, she? s done as well. Just reunite her with Sonya because Mandy will not make it as a solo star."
[3.0] "Hat den richtigen Look und ansonsten nicht viel zu bieten. Sei es In Ring-Können, schauspielerische Darbietung, Mic Work, Ausstrahlung oder sonstwas, nirgends könnte man behaupten, dass sie da groß was mitbringen würde."
[5.0] "Not really sure what to say about Mandy Rose. She's got some decent offense but still fumbles around and isn't improving in-ring or on the mic, at least not to a large degree. It's tough when you compare to Sonya Deville who has been improving quite a lot in recent months. Normally I try to partially look at each wrestler in a bubble (not everyone can be Daniel Bryan or Manami Toyota) but it's tough when one half of the former partnership is flourishing so much more, and the push Sonya's getting really showcases this. I'm willing to give Mandy credit because as I stated, her strikes are solid, but that's about it. She needs to round out her kit more, or focus a lot more on her strengths. I don't like when someone is simply eye-candy, bc she's capable of much more I feel."
[8.0] "Weird to think she's so low. Has always been a good worker and actor. Her stories atm are good. I'm guessing people judged her on looks or either right at the beginning."
[4.0] "Für meinen Geschmack die hübscheste Wrestlerin derzeit in der WWE. Im Ring ist sie akzeptabel und in der Undercard und im Team mit Sonya Deville bisher ganz gut aufgehoben. Man merkt in letzter Zeit dass sie sich stetig etwas verbessert und auch man Mikro wirkt sie etwas sicherer. Dennoch ist Mandy Rose zur Zeit bei den Women in der WWE leider eine der schwächeren."
[2.0] "Sie ist jetzt seit knapp 4 Jahren aktiv und ich sehe immer noch nicht, warum sie einen Platz in der WWE haben sollte. Ihre Matches sind immer noch schlecht und werden auch nur marginal besser, weshalb sie mittlerweile sogar von vielen NXT-Rookies, die weniger lang aktiv sind als sie selbst, überholt wurde. Selbst im Tag Team mit Sonya wirkt sie wie ein Fremdkörper, besonders da ihre Partnerin tatsächlich reale Fortschritte zeigt."
[6.0] "I think Mandy does not get enough credit she is extremely talented she has the look and the strength her ring skills are improving each week and her knee strike is so realistic"
[4.0] "As an athlete, Mandy is very talented, but she seems like a women who would've been more successful in the Divas era. She lacks mic skills, and her gimmick is the reason why the women's revolution began in the first place. The worst thing they did with her was putting her in the Smackdown Women's Title picture, especially against Asuka. Asuka has faced incredibly talented women with strong gimmicks (e. g. Ember Moon, Nikki Cross, Ruby Riott, etc. ), so trying to portray Mandy as a credible threat came across as greatly ridiculous."
[5.0] "It went upwards for her very fast since she made it to the WWE. In her TE season about two women were more than just a diva, neither of them was Mandy (Amanda). It's not a surprise that she somehow evolved. However it's surprising how from NXT to her debut in the main-show she became a pretty good wrestler with a fitting personality. Only in recent times she lacks in both in-ring work and character work - she seems not interested in the scene of wrestling or she's a bit distracted. Both wouldn't surprise me in the life of a WWE superstar who enjoys the non-wrestling privileges of the WWE."
[10.0] "Its SO popular to hate on someone being beautiful and justify it by ''Oh I was bullied by beautiful people'' Mandy is ALWAYS improving, getting better and learning, shes learning on the job on and off and she never gets worse unlike some others. Lately she mix in athelicism like cartwheels and stuff. Her finisher is impressive, her mic skills are alright but sometimes screws up on backstage segments. her face is always priceless in reactions and she stays in character very well. if you look back a few years she was Diva-Great, in a couple she might be top-tier great."
[3.0] "Another product of the broken Tough Enough system. During that show she was consistently pretty low on the totem pole & she probably had never seen a single wrestling match in her life before being on that show. But she's blonde & looks like a model, so she passed the Vince McMahon test. To her credit, she's about a million times better in the ring than what I was expecting. That said, she's nothing special. Her character is about as basic as you can get, as she's just "the hot one". I just don't think I'll ever buy in to Mandy."
[2.0] "She can't wrestle. She gets by by being pretty. She has joined the group of women who when they appear on screen I hit fast forward. The differences between the top women and the rest is stark and Mandy shows that more than any other talent."
[4.0] "Mandy Rose is a common WWE case where she was brought up from development far too soon and with little direction. Compared to other womens wrestlers on the roster she just looks silly in the ring and can barely keep up or go a minute without botching most times. She's ok on the mic. I don't blame her for this because her sudden push to the main roster wasn't her decision but nonetheless."
[6.0] "She is working extremely hard and her offense in the last few matches I watched was believable and looked good. She was apparently hired for her looks, but I do not really care, as she is already miles ahead than many of the women in the 2000s that were hired for being blonde or good-looking. I admire effort and she has shown that she cares about improving and working hard, that's most important to me. Her character and micwork needs work, but honestly, at this point I am happy if she focusses on her in-ring work improvements."
[5.0] "She has good looks, but that? s about it. She seems to have only been brought up to be on Total Divas. She? s not as terrible as Eva Marie but certainly not as great as Asuka."
[0.0] "Some of the reasons for this rating might not be Mandy's fault, but who knows? What I know is when I first saw her I had guarded optimism, because despite being a non-wrestler, she was beautiful, strong and agile. Then WWE decided to hold her back in NXT for the most bizarre reason: To avoid being tagged as a "NXT girl". Huh? Don't all the girls, and pretty much all the wrestlers, go through NXT? How is that detrimental? She got rushed to the main roster. Now, Mandy is bulkier, more of an enforcer now, and subsequently less attractive and less agile. She never got time to develop critical character and in-ring skills first; she was always treated with kid gloves in NXT, told she'd be a star on the main roster. How's that going? Not well, if you ask me. I think she had some potential, but it's more or less squandered now. She needs a rebrand quickly. All she has right now is some, but not as much as before, sex appeal (her gimmick, which plays this up, hurts her too) and some power. NOTE: Was going to give her 2 or 3 points, but after reading three inmates admit in their comments that they were giving her a 10 to boost her score - with zero other justification - I might as well give her nothing to combat that attitude!"
[0.0] "Mandy rose for sure is the worst female on smackdown live she is not fun to watch in the ring at all She bores the hell at of me and when She is on most of the time I go to the bathroom (most likely what other people do anyways) anyways I give her 0 one of if not the worst womens wrestler I have ever seen."
[7.0] "Rose is probably my biggest surprise of 2018, as of yet. I expected her to fall flat on her face, but she's quickly become a solid wrestler. She's got a lot of strength and I think that's helped her excel."
[3.0] "Im Ring ist sie einfach noch sehr grün. Sie ist sicherlich keine Katastrophe aber mehr als die Standardmoves beherrscht sie nicht und sie kann auch nichts besonders gut. In einem Stable okay aber als Singles Wrestlerin sehe ich sie nicht. 2 Punkte in dem Bereich. Micwork wirkt nicht komplett schrecklich aber nicht wirklich sicher und überzeugend. 3 Punkte in dem Bereich. Vom Charisma her in Ordnung mit durchaus ganz guter Mimik aber das war es dann auch. Hat ein irgendwie nicht wirklich definierbares Gimmick und zieht kaum Reaktionen. Zeigt auch keine wirklichen Charaktereigenschaften ob Heel oder Face. Insgesamt 4 Punkte in dem Bereich und somit 3 Punkte gesamt."
[7.0] "I am nothing but impressed by Mandy Rose so far. While she was relegated to losing matches on NXT television, and wrestling live events, Rose has shown she is willing to put the effort necessary to improve as a wrestler. She has a quiet confident charisma about her, and is a far better striker than I had imagined. Can't wait to see her get more television time. Her work on the main roster has been hit or miss, but mostly hit so far. She looks amazing, as a fierce intensity, and you can see the passion she has for sports entertainment. It's only a matter of time before she becomes the big bad of the women's division"
[6.0] "Mandy Rose ist nicht, wie viele User in den Kommentaren behaupten, eine zweite Eva Marie. Im Ring ist sie durchschnittlich und macht sich im Main Roster gut, obwohl ein Aufstieg ins Main Roster viel zu früh kam. Und es muss nicht sofort heißen, dass jede attraktive Wrestlerin eine zweite Eva Marie sein muss."
[5.0] "Mandy Rose is a mixture of two eras of women's wrestling. She's ethereally beautiful, she has the model look and physique, rivaling those of the pre-Women's Revolution women. However, she's shown she wants to be good in the ring, and she's actually nailed down the aspect of having a ring presence and being a believable character. She's still pretty far behind in the ring and didn't get the seasoning she needed before she came up. But much like Alexa Bliss -- if she can nail the character and develop into a good mic worker I think the WWE has something with Mandy Rose."
[3.0] "Einen Punkt für die bisher mehr als dürftigen Leistungen von Mandy Rose scheinen mir angebracht. Im Moment sehe ich in ihr maximal eine Eva Marie 2. 0 wenn man das in ein Gimmick verpackt kann sie es damit vielleicht ein bisschen höher schaffen. Ihre Ringfähigkeiten limitieren sie aber nun mal sehr stark, so dass mehr als 1 Punkt einfach (noch? ) nicht drin ist. // Update 12. 02. 2018 // + 2 Punkte für ihre Arbeit bei Absolution und vor Allem an der Seite von Goldust in der Mixed Match Challenge."
[10.0] "Man some fans have no patience why give her a low rating when she hasn't been on NXT TV very often. She only been wrestling on NXT House Shows, so far she has done alright with the limited time we have seen her on NXT TV."
[5.0] "I think anyone giving 10 at the minute is being a bit too generous. She is improving there is absolutely no doubt about that. I wouldnt call her a blonde Eva Marie, Eva didnt care, Mandy wants to learn and grow in the business. I think she does have a big future but shouldnt be put ahead of females like Liv"
[7.0] "I've only seen one televised match of hers, and it was against a great wrestler in Ember Moon/Athena, but I was impressed. For someone with no real background in wrestling and with well under a year of experience, Mandy has passable charisma, decent selling, and surprisingly great strikes. For now I'll give her an optimistic 7/10 because of a very good first impression."
[1.0] "Hier mal wieder ein klassisches Beispiel für eine Person, die nur wegen ihres Aussehen in der WWE ist. Einfach untalentiert, mag vielleicht ganz sympathisch sein, ist für eine so große Company aber einfach ungenügend."
[2.0] "Wow what do we have here? Oh its an Eva Marie 2. 0. Well Mandy Rosa does not deserve to be where she is because she didnt even win Tough Enough. She didnt impress me their either. Her in ring ability lacks a whole lot but I think she can improve in a few years as she is still fairly new to wrestling in."
[7.0] "I believe in Mandy! I'm sure that she can be a great Diva ! She is strong , more than sexy and powerfull! Hope to see her evolution and her WWE Debut ! Like the people are saying everytime , she's certainly the next Trish Stratus !"
"Auf YouTube gibt es ein Match von WrestleMania Axxess zu sehen in dem sie gg. Alexa Bliss im Ring steht. Ich traue mich es fast gar nicht zu schreiben, aber dieses Match war an Live-Event-Standarts gemessen mindestens solide bis unterhaltsam. Für eine Frau mit weniger als 20 Matches z. Zt. ist das Match sogar als überraschend gut zu bewerten. Von daher teile ich definitiv nicht die Bedenken, dass man eine zweite Eva Marie serviert bekommt (wobei auch sie sich verbessert, wenn auch nicht im wünschenwerten Rahmen. Aber das ist eine andere Baustelle. ). Ist sie nur wegen ihrer Optik bei der WWE? Jupp, keine Frage. Aber sie hat erkennbar Potenzial udn man sollte auch sie ein Auge haben, nicht nur weil sie schnuckelig aussieht."
[1.0] "Come on! The only reason she is signed to WWE and features on Total Divas, is because VKM has a crush on her, Naomi must be spitting feathers knowing she was shoved off the show for this Eva Marie clone. Why do WWE insist on hiring these people? As per usual with the Women's division one step forward (New Belt/Ditching the Diva tag) then five steps back!"
