 Year | Item |
| 1996 | Shawn Michaels |
| 1995 | Perro Aguayo Sr. |
| 1994 | Atsushi Onita |
| 1993 | Atsushi Onita |
| 1992 | Sting |
| 1991 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1990 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1989 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1988 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1987 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1986 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1985 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1984 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1983 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1982 | Hulk Hogan |
| 1981 | Tommy Rich |
| 1980 | Dusty Rhodes |
