| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 09.11.2012 |  |
PWS Heavyweight Title: The Rahway Reaper (Matt Hardy) defeats Kevin Matthews (c) (0:59) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWS The Show Must Go On - Event @ Rahway Senior Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
| 2 | 12.10.2012 | |
PWS Heavyweight Title: Kevin Matthews (c) defeats Larry The Marvelous One (0:10) PWS House Party 5 - Event @ Rahway Rec Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
| 3 | 12.10.2012 | |
PWS Heavyweight Title: Kevin Matthews (c) defeats Starman PWS House Party 5 - Event @ Rahway Rec Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
| 4 | 14.09.2012 | |
PWS Heavyweight Title Falls Count Anywhere: Kevin Matthews (c) defeats Sami Callihan PWS Saved By The Ring Bell - Pay Per View @ Rahway Recreation Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
| 5 | 02.06.2012 | |
PWS Heavyweight Title Ladder: Kevin Matthews defeats Sami Callihan (c) (15:04) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PWS Five Year Anniversary Weekend - Tag 2 - Pay Per View @ Rahway Rec Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
