19 | Sideshow | 16.10.2022 | 530 days | Clearwater, Florida, USA | | Matches |
18 | Anthony Greene | 14.11.2021 | 336 days | Clearwater, Florida, USA | | Matches |
17 | Troy Hollywood | 22.05.2021 | 176 days | Port Richey, Florida, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | 21.05.2021 | 1 day | | | |
16 | Jon Davis (2) | 25.05.2018 | 1092 days | Ybor City, Florida, USA | | Matches |
15 | Eddie Taurus | 14.04.2018 | 41 days | Port Richey, Florida, USA | | Matches |
14 | Jon Davis | 02.04.2017 | 377 days | Orlando, Florida, USA | | Matches |
13 | Martin Stone | 28.05.2016 | 309 days | New Port Richey, Florida, USA | | Matches |
12 | Donovan Danhausen | 27.05.2016 | 1 day | Orlando, Florida, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | 02.05.2016 | 25 days | | | |
11 | Maxwell Chicago | 20.02.2015 | 437 days | Ybor City, Florida, USA | | Matches |
10 | Chasyn Rance | 25.05.2014 | 271 days | Orlando, Florida, USA | | Matches |
9 | Lince Dorado | 14.03.2014 | 72 days | Ybor City, Florida, USA | | Matches |
8 | Gran Akuma | 09.08.2013 | 217 days | Ybor City, Florida, USA | | Matches |
7 | Uhaa Nation | 29.10.2011 | 650 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
6 | Jake Manning | 31.07.2010 | 455 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
5 | Brad Attitude | 03.10.2009 | 301 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
4 | Rhett Titus | 28.03.2009 | 189 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
3 | Chris Jones | 11.10.2008 | 168 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
2 | Sal Rinauro | 09.11.2007 | 337 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | | Matches |
1 | Erick Stevens | 10.03.2007 | 244 days | Crystal River, Florida, USA | 1 | Matches |