| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 28.06.2019 |  |
PPW Tag Team Title Four Way Lethal Ladder: The Lifers (Bobby Beverly & Matthew Justice) defeat Awesome Odyssey (Chris Copeland & Jack Andrews) and The Hooligans (Devin Cutter & Mason Cutter) and The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW Dysfunctional - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 2 | 24.05.2019 | |
PPW Tag Team Title The Rejects' Invitational Final: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) (c) defeat The Lifers (Bobby Beverly & Matthew Justice) PPW The Rejects' Invitational - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 3 | 26.04.2019 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) (c) defeat The Gym Nasty Boyz (Timmy Lou Retton & White Mike) PPW Turn My Swag On - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 4 | 22.03.2019 | |
PPW Tag Team Title Loser Leaves Town 30 Minute Iron Man: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) (c) defeat IFHY (Johnathan Wolf & Shawn Kemp) [4:3] PPW Mask Off - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 5 | 25.01.2019 | |
PPW Tag Team Title: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) (c) defeat Gustavo Aguilar & JDL PPW Bring The Pain - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 6 | 16.11.2018 | |
PPW Tag Team Title Best Two Out Of Three Falls: The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch & Reed Bentley) defeat IFHY (Johnathan Wolf & Shawn Kemp) (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! PPW Go To Sleep - Event @ Jeffersonville Arena in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
