| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 18.05.2021 |  |
WWE NXT North American Title Steel Cage: Bronson Reed defeats Johnny Gargano (c) (15:29) - TITLE CHANGE !!! WWE NXT #577 - TV-Show @ Capitol Wrestling Center (WWE Performance Center) in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 2 | 08.04.2021 | |
WWE NXT North American Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Bronson Reed (16:23) WWE NXT TakeOver: Stand & Deliver 2021 - Tag 2 - Premium Live Event @ Capitol Wrestling Center (WWE Performance Center) in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 3 | 14.02.2021 | |
WWE NXT North American Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Kushida (24:51) WWE NXT TakeOver: Vengeance Day 2021 - Premium Live Event @ Capitol Wrestling Center (WWE Performance Center) in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 4 | 30.12.2020 | |
WWE NXT North American Title: Johnny Gargano (c) defeats Leon Ruff (14:12) WWE NXT #558 - TV-Show @ Capitol Wrestling Center (WWE Performance Center) in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 5 | 06.12.2020 | |
WWE NXT North American Title Triple Threat: Johnny Gargano defeats Damian Priest and Leon Ruff (c) (17:30) - TITLE CHANGE !!! WWE NXT TakeOver: WarGames 2020 - Premium Live Event @ Capitol Wrestling Center (WWE Performance Center) in Orlando, Florida, USA |
