 # | Champion(s) | Since | Duration | Location | Note | Details |
| 12 | CPA | 09.03.2024 | 41 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 11 | Vargas | 29.04.2023 | 315 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 10 | Deonn Rusman | 19.09.2020 | 952 days | Palmer, Alaska, USA | Matches | |
| 9 | Anthony Bowens (3) | 07.12.2019 | 287 days | Anchorage, Alaska, USA | Matches | |
| 8 | Matt Macintosh | 09.03.2019 | 273 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 7 | Chris Payne | 09.11.2018 | 120 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 6 | Chris Avery Queling | 09.09.2017 | 426 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 5 | Bobby Wayward (2) | 11.03.2017 | 182 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 4 | Anthony Bowens (2) | 11.02.2017 | 28 days | New York City, New York, USA | Matches | |
| 3 | Bobby Wayward | 10.09.2016 | 154 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 2 | Anthony Bowens | 30.04.2016 | 133 days | Rahway, New Jersey, USA | Matches | |
| 1 | Matt Macintosh | 25.01.2016 | 96 days | New Jersey, USA | Matches |
