| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 16.04.2016 |  |
IWA East Coast Heavyweight Title Three Way: Chance Prophet defeats BJ Whitmer (c) and Ron Mathis - TITLE CHANGE !!! IWA East Coast The Whole Shebang - Event @ King's Way Outreach Center in Nitro, West Virginia, USA |
| 2 | 24.06.2014 | |
IWA East Coast Heavyweight Title: BJ Whitmer (c) defeats Aaron Williams IWA East Coast Pondo's Birthday Bash 2 - Event @ Campbell's Creek, West Virginia, USA |
| 3 | 15.03.2014 | |
IWA East Coast Heavyweight Title: BJ Whitmer (c) defeats Michael Elgin IWA East Coast We're Back ...And Better Than Ever - Event @ King's Outreach Center in Nitro, West Virginia, USA |
| 4 | 27.10.2012 | |
IWA East Coast Heavyweight Title: BJ Whitmer (c) defeats Facade IWA East Coast All That Glitters - Event @ Kings Way Outreach Center in Nitro, West Virginia, USA |
| 5 | 29.09.2012 | |
IWA East Coast Heavyweight Title: BJ Whitmer defeats Necro Butcher (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! IWA East Coast Worlds Collide - Event @ King’s Way Outreach Center in Nitro, West Virginia, USA |
