31 | Kyle Fletcher | 15.12.2023 | 132 days | Garland, Texas, USA | | Matches |
| VACANT | 08.11.2023 | 37 days | | 6 | |
30 | Samoa Joe | 13.04.2022 | 574 days | New Orleans, Louisiana, USA | | Matches |
29 | Minoru Suzuki | 01.04.2022 | 12 days | Garland, Texas, USA | | Matches |
28 | Rhett Titus | 11.12.2021 | 111 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
27 | Dalton Castle | 19.11.2021 | 22 days | Philadelphia, Pennslyvania, USA | | Matches |
26 | Dragon Lee (2) | 11.07.2021 | 131 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
25 | Tony Deppen | 30.04.2021 | 72 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
24 | Tracy Williams | 26.03.2021 | 35 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | 5 | Matches |
23 | Dragon Lee | 13.12.2019 | 469 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
22 | Shane Taylor | 09.05.2019 | 218 days | Toronto, Ontario, Canada | 4 | Matches |
21 | Jeff Cobb | 29.09.2018 | 222 days | Las Vegas, Nevada, USA | | Matches |
20 | Punishment Martinez | 16.06.2018 | 105 days | Dallas, Texas, USA | | Matches |
19 | Silas Young (2) | 07.04.2018 | 70 days | New Orleans, Louisiana, USA | 3 | Matches |
18 | Kenny King (2) | 10.02.2018 | 56 days | Atlanta, Georgia, USA | | Matches |
17 | Silas Young | 15.12.2017 | 57 days | New York City, New York, USA | | Matches |
16 | Kenny King | 22.09.2017 | 84 days | Las Vegas, Nevada, USA | | Matches |
15 | KUSHIDA | 14.05.2017 | 131 days | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
14 | Marty Scurll | 20.11.2016 | 175 days | Bethnal Green, Greater London, England, UK | | Matches |
13 | Will Ospreay | 18.11.2016 | 2 days | Liverpool, Merseyside, England, UK | | Matches |
12 | Bobby Fish | 08.05.2016 | 194 days | Chicago Ridge, Illinois, USA | | Matches |
11 | Tomohiro Ishii | 19.02.2016 | 79 days | Tokyo, Japan | | Matches |
10 | Roderick Strong (2) | 23.10.2015 | 119 days | Kalamazoo, Michigan, USA | | Matches |
9 | Jay Lethal (2) | 04.04.2014 | 567 days | New Orleans, Louisiana, USA | | Matches |
8 | Tommaso Ciampa | 14.12.2013 | 111 days | New York City, New York, USA | | Matches |
7 | Matt Taven | 02.03.2013 | 287 days | Chicago Ridge, Illinois, USA | | Matches |
6 | Adam Cole | 29.06.2012 | 246 days | Baltimore, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
5 | Roderick Strong | 31.03.2012 | 90 days | Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA | | Matches |
4 | Jay Lethal | 13.08.2011 | 231 days | Chicago Ridge, Illinois, USA | 2 | Matches |
3 | El Generico | 26.06.2011 | 48 days | New York City, New York, USA | | Matches |
2 | Christopher Daniels | 10.12.2010 | 198 days | Louisville, Kentucky, USA | | Matches |
1 | Eddie Edwards | 05.03.2010 | 280 days | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA | 1 | Matches |