| 20 | Danny Miles | xx.xx.2022 | ? | | | Matches |
| 19 | Richard Holliday | 13.11.2021 | ? | Long Island, New York, USA | | Matches |
| 18 | Scott Steiner | 23.08.2019 | 813 days | Pawtucket, Rhode Island, USA | | Matches |
| | VACANT | 23.08.2019 | <1 day | | | |
| 17 | Kevin Nash | 10.08.2018 | 378 days | Pawtucket, Rhode Island, USA | | Matches |
| 16 | Flex Armstrong (4) | 31.03.2018 | 132 days | Hagerstown, Maryland, USA | | Matches |
| 15 | The Patriot | 30.03.2018 | 1 day | Altoona, Pennsylvania, USA | | Matches |
| 14 | Flex Armstrong (3) | 11.02.2017 | 412 days | Spartanburg, South Carolina, USA | | Matches |
| 13 | Carlito | 10.02.2017 | 1 day | Raleigh, North Carolina, USA | | Matches |
| 12 | Flex Armstrong (2) | 22.03.2014 | 1056 days | Webster, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 11 | RJ Brewer (3) | 21.03.2014 | 1 day | Plymouth, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 10 | Flex Armstrong | 01.06.2012 | 658 days | San Bernardino, California, USA | | Matches |
| 9 | Shane Douglas (2) | 25.09.2011 | 250 days | Holyoke, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 8 | Jack Maverick | 22.09.2011 | 3 days | Presque Isle, Maine, USA | | Matches |
| 7 | Shane Douglas | 14.08.2010 | 404 days | Webster, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 6 | Spike Dudley | 02.01.2010 | 224 days | Webster, Massachusetts, USA | 2 | Matches |
| | VACANT | 01.08.2009 | 154 days | | | |
| 5 | Justin Credible | 29.03.2009 | 125 days | Webster, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 4 | John Walters (2) | 28.06.2008 | 274 days | Danbury, Connecticut, USA | | Matches |
| 3 | 2 Cold Scorpio | 29.03.2008 | 91 days | Danbury, Connecticut, USA | | Matches |
| 2 | John Walters | 12.05.2007 | 322 days | Springfield, Massachusetts, USA | | Matches |
| 1 | Jay Lethal | 01.12.2006 | 162 days | Chicopee, Massachusetts, USA | 1 | Matches |
#