[3.0] "Though both decent enough talents, the Heart Throbs' WWE gimmick never got over and they didn't amount to much there. They've since had relatively decent runs on the independent scene, both as a team and later on their own, with Antonio (now known mainly as Thomas Santell) still taking regular bookings today."
[1.0] "Ansatzweise unterhaltsames Tag Team, das im Seilgeviert absolut unterirdisch war. Zum Glück war ihnen kein längerer Run im Main Roster vergönnt."
[4.0] "Corny as they are, I thought they had potential when they appeared in WWE and I pegged them as future champions. Years lather, they proved to be adequate undercard filler in local indy, such as CHIKARA, and know how to make their opponents look good. I'd say they are judged a bit harshly."
[5.0] "These guys are not the greatest tag team ever, but they aren't nearly as bad as people make them out to be. As workers, their in-ring abilities are overlooked (especially Antonio. Check out their match against Regal & Tajiri on YouTube for reference). I can understand why people would hate the gimmick, but they were a competent team who could cut a half-decent promo, far from being one of the worst tag teams ever."
[7.0] "The Heart Throbs score seems rather unfair. A completely workable team that just never made it too far in the big leagues. This team was average and solid at it. If that's the best one can do, one deserves much higher a score."
[6.0] "What the heck is so bad about the Heart Throbs? They are not a team that ever achieved very much success, but I do not think they were bad wrestlers or had a bad gimmick, they just got no push or development. That's not a reflection on them or their skills, which were perfectly fine albeit not extraordinary."
[3.0] "Ok, die Heart Throbs waren sicher nicht das Gelbe vom Ei, man kann ihnen aber zu gute halten, dass sie aus dem grottigen Gimmick mit Sicherheit das Maximum rausgeholt haben. Im Ring sicher auch nichts besonderes, aber da sehe ich in ihnen auch nicht den Totalausfall zu dem sie häufig gemacht werden."
[2.0] "Die Heartbreakers waren recht ungewöhnlich und eine gute Idee aber anscheinend nicht WWE TV reif. Was dann heraus kam war eine miese Musik und 2 Stripper. Es waren übrigens nicht die Dicks obwohl beide Teams die gleiche Bilanz haben."
[2.0] "Wussten bei OVW als Heartbreakers noch glänzend zu unterhalten und wurden wie so viele Talente von WWE durch eine miese Fehlinterpretation des Gimmicks jeglicher Qualität beraubt."