| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 30.03.2024 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Niles Plonk CSW We're Not In Kansas Anymore - Event @ KCMO National Guard Armory in Kansas City, Missouri, USA |
| 2 | 29.03.2024 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Lenny Mephisto SLA Battle Of Spaulding II - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 3 | 24.03.2024 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Mike Bailey Grandel Wrestling - Event @ The Grandel in St. Louis, Missouri, USA |
| 4 | 16.03.2024 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Storm Grayson RPW Extravaganza 3 - Event @ Big Apple in Manitowoc, Wisconsin, USA |
| 5 | 08.03.2024 |  |
Destination Title: Davey Vega (c) defeats Gary Jay by Count Out Fountain City Pro Light It Up - Event @ Ball Event Center in Olathe, Kansas, USA |
| 6 | 24.02.2024 |  |
Unsanctioned Pro Tag Team Title #1 Contendership: The Ody (Chris Copeland & Jack Andrews) defeat Unsigned And Don't Care (Aaron Williams & Gary Jay) (8:36) by referee's decision Unsanctioned Pro Royal Flush 3 - Pay Per View @ Valley Dale Ballroom in Columbus, Ohio, USA |
| 7 | 23.02.2024 |  |
Robert Anthony defeats Gary Jay (9:06) AAW Legacy - The 20th Anniversary Event - Event @ Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois, USA |
| 8 | 17.02.2024 | |
Luke Langley defeats Gary Jay CSW No One Rides For Free - Event @ National Guard Armory in Lenexa, Kansas, USA |
| 9 | 26.01.2024 | |
Laynie Luck defeats Gary Jay SLA Gateway To Anarchy 2024 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 10 | 30.12.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats David Ali (6:52) AAW Windy City Classic XVIII - Event @ Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois, USA |
| 11 | 18.11.2023 | |
Shazza McKenzie defeats Gary Jay SLA Megaticket 2023 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 12 | 17.11.2023 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy (7:03) ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X18 - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 13 | 28.10.2023 | |
Chi-Town Rumble: Ren Jones defeats Aaron Arsenal and August Matthews and Chico Suave and Conan Lycan and Davey Bang and Gary Jay and Gnarls Garvin and Hartenbower and Heather Reckless and Isaiah Moore and Jah C and Jake Something and Joey Avalon and John E. Bravo and Koda Hernandez and Levi Everett and Maggie Lee and Perch and Robert Anthony and Russ Jones and Sabin Gauge and Sean Logan and Silas Young and Solomon Tupu and Sorta Incredible Iverson and Tony Rican and Victor Iniestra and Warhorse and Xavier Walker AAW Unstoppable 2023 - Event @ Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois, USA |
| 14 | 28.10.2023 | |
Lumberjack: Silas Young defeats Gary Jay (10:58) AAW Unstoppable 2023 - Event @ Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois, USA |
| 15 | 27.10.2023 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Delmi Exo GRIND Celebration Day II - Online Stream @ Pulaski Club in Easthampton, Massachusetts, USA |
| 16 | 26.10.2023 |  |
Mortar defeats Gary Jay (3:19) Wrestling Open #95: Are You Afraid Of The Dark? - Online Stream @ White Eagle in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 17 | 12.10.2023 | |
Masato Tanaka defeats Gary Jay (19:08) SLA Canvas Of Dreams - Event @ Elks Lodge in Granite City, Illinois, USA |
| 18 | 30.09.2023 | |
Dak Draper defeats Gary Jay CSW A Glitch In The Matrix - Event @ National Guard Armory in Lenexa, Kansas, USA |
| 19 | 29.09.2023 | |
Six Way Scramble: Jake Something defeats Gary Jay and Isaiah Moore and Koa Laxamana and Levi Everett and Silas Young (6:58) AAW The Chaos Theory 2023 - Event @ Joe's on Weed Street in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 20 | 20.09.2023 |  |
Gary Jay defeats L-Ride The Forge Student Showcase - Event @ Utopia Studios in St. Louis, Missouri, USA |
| 21 | 10.09.2023 |  |
MV Young defeats Gary Jay NAP Hath No Fury - Event @ Ellenberger Park Indoor Rink in Indianapolis, Indiana, USA |
| 22 | 31.08.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Silas Young (9:15) AAW The Art Of War 2023 - Event @ Berwyn Eagles Club in Berwyn, Illinois, USA |
| 23 | 26.08.2023 | |
Mixed: Gary Jay & Shazza McKenzie defeat Kenzi James & Percy Drews RPW Heatwave 3 - Event @ The Watering Hole in Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA |
| 24 | 11.08.2023 | |
Three Way Hardcore: Tommy Vendetta defeats Alex Colon and Gary Jay (8:58) Unsanctioned Pro 26: Counterfeit - Pay Per View @ VFW Hall in Maybee, Michigan, USA |
| 25 | 06.08.2023 |  |
Yuya Uemura defeats Gary Jay (10:47) Inspire AD Rule In Hell - Online Stream @ Empire Control Room & Garage in Austin, Texas, USA |
| 26 | 29.07.2023 |  |
MCPW Heavyweight Title: Aaron Orion (c) defeats Gary Jay MCPW Attitude - Event @ Kaliseum Recreation Complex in Kalkaska, Michigan, USA |
| 27 | 28.07.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Mike Outlaw (11:05) SLA Circus Maximus X-8 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 28 | 16.07.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Shazza McKenzie Grandel Wrestling Fight For Allison - Event @ Pop's Nightclub in Sauget, Illinois, USA |
| 29 | 09.07.2023 | |
Five Way Scramble: Gary Jay defeats Cam Cole and Korey O'Neal and Shimbashi and Victor Analog (10:36) Inspire AD Ecstasy Of Gold: 10 Years In The Making - Online Stream @ Empire Control Room & Garage in Austin, Texas, USA |
| 30 | 24.06.2023 | |
The Premier (Campbell Myers & SK Bishop) defeat Davey Vega & Gary Jay CSW Coronation - Event @ National Guard Armory in Lenexa, Kansas, USA |
| 31 | 09.06.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Brogan Finlay SLA Giant's Woke, Eyes Open - Online Stream @ Spaulding Club Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 32 | 27.05.2023 |  |
wXw Shotgun Title: Laurance Roman (c) defeats Gary Jay (8:26) wXw We Love Wrestling #46 - Online Stream @ The Dome in London, England, UK |
| 33 | 21.05.2023 |  |
Alton Thorne defeats Gary Jay (9:27) KCW One Last Dance With Death - Event @ Vines Bar in Derby, Derbyshire, England, UK |
| 34 | 20.05.2023 |  |
NORTH Ultraviolent Title: Clint Margera (c) defeats Gary Jay NCL.36 / Let The Cannons Fly 4 - Event @ Anarchy Brew Co in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, England, UK |
| 35 | 14.05.2023 |  |
Three Way: Isaac North defeats Gary Jay and Joe Wade TCW Other Worlds - Event @ The Parish in Huddersfield, Yorkshire, England, UK |
| 36 | 13.05.2023 |  |
Sam Steel defeats Gary Jay IWU Civil War - Event @ Kettering Buccleuch Academy in Kettering, Northamptonshire, England, UK |
| 37 | 21.04.2023 |  |
The Rejects (John Wayne Murdoch, Nick Depp & Reed Bentley) defeat Aaron Williams, Gary Jay & Lord Crewe (10:54) XCF Legendary - Online Stream @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 38 | 15.04.2023 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Kayla Kassidy PPW/MidwestTerritory.com Pawcade 4: The Final Chapter - Online Stream @ Our Lady Of Perpetual Hops in New Albany, Indiana, USA |
| 39 | 14.04.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy by referee's decision SLA As Seen On Anarchy - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 40 | 08.04.2023 |  |
Charlie Kruel defeats Gary Jay PWK Thy Kingdom Come II - Event @ The Century Center in South Bend, Indiana, USA |
| 41 | 26.03.2023 | |
T-Ray defeats Gary Jay Inspire AD No False Metal - Event @ Empire Control Room & Garage in Austin, Texas, USA |
| 42 | 25.03.2023 |  |
36 Man Rumble: Levi Everett defeats Adam Slade and Alice Crowley and Anakin Murphy and Arthur McArthur and Blair Onyx and Brayden Lee and Calvin Tankman and Chase Holliday and Chase Oliver and Crash Jaxon and Damian Chambers and Dan The Dad and Darius Latrell and Ezio Orlandi and Gary Jay and Haley Dylan and Jacob Gotch and Joey Gotch and Kevin Blackwood and Kobe Durst and Matt Brannigan and Matt Knicks and Myung Jae Lee and Percy Davis and Rachel Armstrong and Regan Lydale and Sam Holloway and Shazza McKenzie and Space Monkey and Steph De Lander and Tom Lawlor and Tony Adams and Trevor Outlaw and Trik Davis and ZDP (38:45) BLP Observe This, Brother!! - Pay Per View @ RDS Gym in Crown Point, Indiana, USA |
| 43 | 24.03.2023 | |
Six Way Scramble: Gnarls Garvin defeats Axel Rico and Brayden Lee and Crash Jaxon and Damian Chambers and Gary Jay AAW: EPIC 19th Anniversary Show - Event @ 115 Bourbon Street in Merrionette Park, Illinois, USA |
| 44 | 18.03.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Jake Something Grandel Wrestling STL Vs. The World 2 - Event @ The Grandel in St. Louis, Missouri, USA |
| 45 | 17.03.2023 |  |
Tommy Vendetta defeats Gary Jay (7:24) No Man's Land If It Bleeds - Online Stream @ H2O Wrestling Center in Williamstown, New Jersey, USA |
| 46 | 18.02.2023 | |
Aaron Williams & Gary Jay defeat Miracle Generation (Dustin Waller & Kylon King) (7:58) BLP All My Friends Are Enemies - Pay Per View @ RDS Gym in Crown Point, Indiana, USA |
| 47 | 27.01.2023 | |
1 Called Manders defeats Gary Jay (9:56) SLA Gateway To Anarchy 2023 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 48 | 21.01.2023 | |
Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy MCPW Sweet 16 - TV-Show @ Kaliseum Recreation Complex in Kalkaska, Michigan, USA |
| 49 | 31.12.2022 |  |
B3CCA defeats Gary Jay (13:49) Limitless High Strung - Online Stream @ White Eagle in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 50 | 31.12.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Rip Byson GRIND All We Are - Online Stream @ White Eagle in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 51 | 30.12.2022 | |
Fred Yehi defeats Gary Jay (10:35) AAW Unstoppable 2022 - Event @ Logan Square Auditorium in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 52 | 17.12.2022 |  |
Camaro Jackson defeats Gary Jay ZERO1 USA How The Lowlifes Stole Christmas! - Event @ Burguess Osbourne Auditorium in Mattoon, Illinois, USA |
| 53 | 19.11.2022 | |
Gateway Heritage Title: Derek Neal (c) defeats Gary Jay SLA Mega Ticket 2022 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 54 | 18.11.2022 | |
Joe Black defeats Gary Jay (5:31) ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X13 - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 55 | 12.11.2022 | |
Death: Aaron Williams defeats Gary Jay (10:35) ICW No Holds Barred Volume 36 - Online Stream @ SuperKrazee Entertainment Center in Westville, New Jersey, USA |
| 56 | 11.11.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Lord Crewe XCF Resurrection - Online Stream @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 57 | 29.10.2022 | |
Unsigned And Don't Care (Aaron Williams & Gary Jay) defeat Anakin Murphy & Kayla Kassidy Mouse's Wrestling Adventures - Fright Night IV - Online Stream @ Our Lady Of Perpetual Hops in New Albany, Indiana, USA |
| 58 | 22.10.2022 | |
Texas Death: Thomas Shire defeats Gary Jay (17:17) Grandel Wrestling From Dusk Till Dawn - Event @ Pop's Nightclub in Sauget, Illinois, USA |
| 59 | 15.10.2022 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy KOBK Die Young - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 60 | 08.10.2022 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Gabriel Skye BSP October Rust - Online Stream @ H2O Wrestling Center in Williamstown, New Jersey, USA |
| 61 | 07.10.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Davey Vega SLA Surprise! You're Dead! - Event @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 62 | 02.10.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Hoodfoot Unsanctioned Pro 22: Wrestlestock Fallout - TV-Show @ 5035 Northwest Pkwy in Hilliard, Ohio, USA |
| 63 | 01.10.2022 | |
Six Way Scramble: Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy and Billie Starkz and Kevin Giza and Lobo Okami and Lord Crewe Unsanctioned Pro 21: Wrestlestock - TV-Show @ 5035 Northwest Pkwy in Hilliard, Ohio, USA |
| 64 | 24.09.2022 | |
Turbo Graps 24 First Round: Kylon King defeats Gary Jay (6:14) BLP Turbo Graps 24 - Part 1 - Online Stream @ RDS Gym in Crown Point, Indiana, USA |
| 65 | 01.09.2022 | |
Six Way Scramble: Gnarls Garvin defeats Ace Perry and Dante Leon and Gary Jay and Gringo Loco and Laredo Kid (8:44) AAW Destination Chicago 2022 - Event @ Logan Square Auditorium in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 66 | 20.08.2022 | |
Charlie Tiger defeats Gary Jay (10:01) Unsanctioned Pro 20: Bash At The Fake Beach 2 - TV-Show @ Merchant Building in Delaware, Ohio, USA |
| 67 | 13.08.2022 |  |
Unsigned And Don't Care (Aaron Williams & Gary Jay) defeat Heroes Of Our Time (Joey Marx & Mason Conrad) (6:22) FU This Thing Of Ours - Online Stream @ Thornton Distilling Company in Thornton, Illinois, USA |
| 68 | 12.08.2022 |  |
Moonshine Mantell defeats Gary Jay Red River In The Heat Of The Night - Event @ MPX Event Center in Bedford, Texas, USA |
| 69 | 29.07.2022 | |
Gateway Heritage Title: Derek Neal defeats Gary Jay (c) - TITLE CHANGE !!! SLA Circus Maximus X-7 - Event @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 70 | 23.07.2022 | |
Death: Hardway Heeter defeats Gary Jay (11:20) ICW No Holds Barred Volume 29 - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 71 | 22.07.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Joe Black (7:38) ICW No Holds Barred Pitfighter X11 - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 72 | 15.07.2022 |  |
ICW Alternative Title: Eric Dillinger (c) defeats Gary Jay (15:03) ICW All American Violence - Event @ Da Bar in West Allis, Wisconsin, USA |
| 73 | 09.07.2022 |  |
Gary Jay defeats Anakin Murphy (7:55) ZOWA Summertime Rolls - TV-Show @ Sterling Moose Lodge in Sterling, Illinois, USA |
| 74 | 07.07.2022 | |
Dimitri Alexandrov defeats Gary Jay Inspire AD Brutes In A Glass Cathedral - Event @ Pinballz Lake Creek in Austin, Texas, USA |
| 75 | 01.07.2022 | |
Jay Freddie defeats Gary Jay (20:22) GRIND Doctor, Doctor - Online Stream @ Pulaski Club in Easthampton, Massachusetts, USA |
| 76 | 30.06.2022 | |
Open Door War: Pedro Dones defeats Bobby Orlando and Brad Hollister and Gary Jay and Ryan Clancy and Tyree Taylor (10:41) Wrestling Open #26 - Summer Stunner - Online Stream @ White Eagle in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 77 | 25.06.2022 | |
Unsigned And Don't Care (Aaron Williams & Gary Jay) defeat DTA (Aaron Orion & Isaiah Broner) (15:17) MCPW Hell Night - TV-Show @ Kaliseum Recreation Complex in Kalkaska, Michigan, USA |
| 78 | 18.06.2022 | |
Dingo Invitational Second Round: Gary Jay defeats Adrian Surge (9:05) SLA Dingo Invitational - Tag 2 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 79 | 18.06.2022 | |
Dingo Invitational Semi Final: Thomas Shire defeats Gary Jay (11:44) SLA Dingo Invitational - Tag 2 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 80 | 17.06.2022 | |
Dingo Invitational First Round: Gary Jay defeats Jeremy Wyatt SLA Dingo Invitational - Tag 1 - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 81 | 11.06.2022 | |
Davey Vega defeats Gary Jay (5:48) AAW Crush And Destroy - Pay Per View @ Logan Square Auditorium in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 82 | 04.06.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Jeffrey John (11:17) Unsanctioned Pro 19: Don't Try This At Home IV - TV-Show @ Valley Dale Ballroom in Columbus, Ohio, USA |
| 83 | 29.05.2022 | |
Hardcore: Mad Dog Connelly defeats Gary Jay ZERO1 USA - Event @ Burgess Osbourne Auditorium in Mattoon, Illinois, USA |
| 84 | 28.05.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Jacques Kennedy ZERO1 USA - Event @ Burgess Osbourne Auditorium in Mattoon, Illinois, USA |
| 85 | 20.05.2022 |  |
Freelance Rumble: Storm Grayson defeats Aaron Payne and Alfonso Gonzalez and Angel Escalera and Blair Onyx and Chicago Brawler and Chico Suave and Chris Castro and Dan Perch and Dan The Dad and Darin Corbin and Ethan Price and Gary Jay and GPA and Guerrera De Brisenas and Isaias Velazquez and Kenny Sutra and Kylie Rae and Laynie Luck and Levy Cruise and Marino Tenaglia and Matt Knicks and Philly Collins and Project MONIX and Rylie Jackson and Sabin Gauge and Sean Galway and Wes Barkley and Xavier Sky (63:26) Freelance Over The Top - Online Stream @ Logan Square Auditorium in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 86 | 07.05.2022 |  |
NWP Higher Ground Title / NWP Crossroads Title Unification: Austin Connelly (c) [Higher Ground] defeats Gary Jay (c) [Crossroads] (9:06) - TITLE CHANGE !!! NWP Right Here Right Now - Online Stream @ West Vigo Community Center in Terre Haute, Indiana, USA |
| 87 | 06.05.2022 | |
Gateway Heritage Title Anarchy Rules: Gary Jay (c) defeats John Wayne Murdoch (19:55) SLA Fight To Live - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 88 | 30.04.2022 | |
Gateway Heritage Title Ladder: Gary Jay (c) defeats Aaron Williams (13:32) Grandel Wrestling STL Vs. The World - Event @ The Grandel in St. Louis, Missouri, USA |
| 89 | 23.04.2022 |  |
Jaden Newman defeats Gary Jay (12:32) TWE 423 - Online Stream @ TWE Arena in Red Bank, Tennessee, USA |
| 90 | 22.04.2022 | |
Storm Grayson defeats Gary Jay (9:26) Freelance Thrash Unreal - Online Stream @ Logan Square Auditorium in Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 91 | 16.04.2022 | |
The REP (Dave McCall & Nate Carter) defeat Unsigned And Don't Care (Aaron Williams & Gary Jay) (12:15) BSP Demanufactured - Online Stream @ H2O Wrestling Center in Williamstown, New Jersey, USA |
| 92 | 09.04.2022 | |
NWP Crossroads Title: Gary Jay (c) defeats Victor Analog (11:46) NWP Talk Of The Town - Event @ West Vigo Community Center in Terre Haute, Indiana, USA |
| 93 | 02.04.2022 | |
Bryan Keith defeats Gary Jay Inspire AD God Forgives, Inspire Does Not - Event @ St. Jude Hall in Arlington, Texas, USA |
| 94 | 02.04.2022 |  |
MPX Title: Tatum Manning (c) defeats Gary Jay MPX vs. The World - Event @ MPX Event Center in Bedford, Texas, USA |
| 95 | 01.04.2022 | |
Bucky Collins defeats Gary Jay (7:16) ZOWA Guavamania 2 - Event @ Cover All Bases in Arlington, Texas, USA |
| 96 | 19.03.2022 |  |
Limitless World Title: Alec Price (c) defeats Gary Jay (7:25) Let's Wrestle Volume 16: Playing For Keeps - Online Stream @ Morgan Hill Event Center in Hermon, Maine, USA |
| 97 | 18.03.2022 | |
Ryan Mooney defeats Gary Jay (12:05) GRIND Price Of A Mile - Online Stream @ Pulaski Club in Easthampton, Massachusetts, USA |
| 98 | 17.03.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Brandon Williams (3:45) Wrestling Open #11 - Online Stream @ White Eagle in Worcester, Massachusetts, USA |
| 99 | 04.03.2022 | |
Gateway Heritage Title Anarchy Rules: Gary Jay (c) defeats Anthony Henry (18:03) SLA Motivation - Online Stream @ Spaulding Hall in Alton, Illinois, USA |
| 100 | 26.02.2022 | |
Gary Jay defeats Don't Die Miles ZERO1 USA - Event @ Burgess-Osbourne Auditorium in Mattoon, Illinois, USA |
