| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 06.07.2018 |  |
Sless The Crimson Flash (Sless Taylor) defeats Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling Live! - Matinee Show - Event @ Willard City Park in Willard, Ohio, USA |
| 2 | 06.07.2018 | |
Billy Taylor defeats Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling Live! - Evening Show - Event @ Willard City Park in Willard, Ohio, USA |
| 3 | 06.07.2018 | |
Nicholas Valentino defeats Billy Taylor Olde Wrestling Live! - Evening Show - Event @ Willard City Park in Willard, Ohio, USA |
| 4 | 24.06.2017 | |
Nicholas Valentino defeats Bill Taylor by DQ Olde Wrestling Calamity At Bellevue Community Days: Matinee Show - Event @ Robert Peters Park in Bellevue, Ohio, USA |
| 5 | 24.06.2017 | |
Dr. Jacob Omen defeats Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling Calamity At Bellevue Community Days: Evening Show - Event @ Robert Peters Park in Bellevue, Ohio, USA |
| 6 | 28.08.2016 | |
Felino de Rojo & ThunderKitty defeat Nicholas Valentino & The Bearded Lady Olde Wrestling And Yet Another Extravaganza Of Wrestling Exhibitions - Event @ Huron County Fairgrounds in Norwalk, Ohio, USA |
| 7 | 15.05.2015 |  |
Dustin Batdorff Invitational 4 Semi Final: Marion Fontaine defeats Nicholas Valentino by Punktrichterentscheid DBi 4 - Event @ Rivertree Christian Church in Massillon, Ohio, USA |
| 8 | 08.05.2015 | |
Nicholas Valentino defeats Guy Jennings Olde Wrestling Speakeasy Spectacular 2015 - Event @ Mahall's in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 9 | 28.09.2014 | |
Battle Royal: Bill Taylor defeats Bryan Castlellini (Bryan Castle) and Derek Oster and Dr. Jacob Omen and Gregory Iron and Guy Jennings and Jeff King and Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling Another Extravaganza Of Wrestling Exhibitions - Event @ Huron County Fairgrounds in Norwalk, Ohio, USA |
| 10 | 01.08.2014 | |
Darin Corbin defeats Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling Speakeasy Spectacular - Event @ Mahall's in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 11 | 29.09.2013 | |
Thunderkitty defeats Nicholas Valentino Olde Wrestling An Extravaganza Of Wrestling Exhibitions - Event @ Huron County Fairgrounds in Norwalk, Ohio, USA |
