# | Title | Promotion | Rating | Votes |
1 | The Undertaker vs. Shawn Michaels | 9.64 | 128 | |
2 | The Undertaker vs. Kane | 8.99 | 76 | |
3 | The Undertaker vs. Batista | 8.29 | 68 | |
4 | Mankind vs. The Undertaker | 9.30 | 62 | |
5 | Brock Lesnar vs. Undertaker | 8.60 | 46 | |
6 | The Undertaker vs. The Big Show | 3.78 | 36 | |
7 | Steve Austin vs. The Undertaker | 6.70 | 32 | |
8 | The Undertaker vs. Triple H | 8.44 | 31 |