| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 16.12.2012 |  |
Jay Lethal defeats Rhino (9:33) ROH Final Battle 2012 - Pay Per View @ Hammerstein Ballroom in New York City, New York, USA |
| 2 | 03.11.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Chris Silvio ROH Wrestling #64 - TV-Show @ Rostraver Ice Gardens in Belle Vernon, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 3 | 13.10.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Davey Richards (23:31) ROH Glory By Honor XI - Online Stream @ International Centre in Mississauga, Ontario, Canada |
| 4 | 06.10.2012 | |
ROH World Title: Kevin Steen (c) vs. Jay Lethal - No Contest (22:00) ROH Killer Instinct - Event @ Rahway Recreation Center in Rahway, New Jersey, USA |
| 5 | 22.09.2012 | |
Survival Of The Fittest 2012 Final Six Way Elimination: Jay Lethal defeats Adam Cole and Davey Richards and Michael Elgin and Mike Mondo and Roderick Strong (21:26) ROH Wrestling #58 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 6 | 22.09.2012 | |
Survival Of The Fittest 2012 First Round: Jay Lethal defeats QT Marshall (6:26) ROH Wrestling #56 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 7 | 15.09.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Homicide (14:34) ROH Death Before Dishonor X - Pay Per View @ Frontier Fieldhouse in Chicago Ridge, Illinois, USA |
| 8 | 08.09.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Adam Page (13:08) ROH Caged Hostility - Event @ Metrolina Tradeshow Expo in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 9 | 11.08.2012 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Jay Lethal defeats Tommaso Ciampa [2:1] (15:14) ROH Boiling Point 2012 - Pay Per View @ Rhode Island Convention Center in Providence, Rhode Island, USA |
| 10 | 03.08.2012 | |
Jay Lethal vs. Matt Taven - No Contest ROH Wrestling #50 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 11 | 03.08.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title #1 Contendership Six Man Mayhem: Mike Mondo defeats Jay Lethal and Mike Bennett and Roderick Strong and TJ Perkins and Tommaso Ciampa ROH Wrestling #49 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 12 | 14.07.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Mike Mondo (15:18) ROH Brew City Beatdown - Event @ Turner Hall Ballroom in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, USA |
| 13 | 30.06.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Kyle O'Reilly (10:25) ROH Live Strong - Event @ Rostraver Ice Garden in Belle Vernon, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 14 | 29.06.2012 | |
Jay Lethal & The All-Night Express (Kenny King & Rhett Titus) defeat Jimmy Jacobs, Kevin Steen & Steve Corino ROH Wrestling #47 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 15 | 24.06.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title Three Way Elimination: Roderick Strong (c) defeats Jay Lethal and Tommaso Ciampa (13:08) ROH Best In The World 2012 - Hostage Crisis - Pay Per View @ Hammerstein Ballroom in New York City, New York, USA |
| 16 | 15.06.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Michael Elgin (12:31) ROH The Nightmare Begins - Event @ Charleston Civic Center in Charleston, West Virginia, USA |
| 17 | 19.05.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Mike Mondo (12:34) ROH The Battle Of Richmond - Event @ Greater Richond Convention Center in Richmond, Virginia, USA |
| 18 | 18.05.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Chris Silvio (5:51) ROH Wrestling #40 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 19 | 18.05.2012 | |
Dark ROH World Title #1 Contendership Four Corner Survival: Roderick Strong defeats Adam Cole and Jay Lethal and Mike Bennett ROH Wrestling #37 - Dark Match @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 20 | 12.05.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Tommaso Ciampa (10:53) ROH Border Wars 2012 - Pay Per View @ Ted Reeve Arena in Toronto, Ontario, Canada |
| 21 | 29.04.2012 | |
Best Two Out Of Three Falls: Jay Lethal defeats Roderick Strong (19:33) [2:1] ROH Rising Above 2012 - Event @ Hara Arena in Dayton, Ohio, USA |
| 22 | 28.04.2012 | |
Lucha Rules: The Colony (Fire Ant, Green Ant & Soldier Ant) defeat Adam Cole, Jay Lethal & TJ Perkins (15:08) ROH Unity - Event @ Frontier Fieldhouse in Chicago Ridge, Illinois, USA |
| 23 | 07.04.2012 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Ricky Reyes (3:42) ROH Wrestling #34 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 24 | 31.03.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title: Roderick Strong defeats Jay Lethal (c) (13:19) - TITLE CHANGE !!! ROH Showdown In The Sun - Tag 2 - Pay Per View @ War Memorial Auditorium in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA |
| 25 | 30.03.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title: Jay Lethal (c) defeats Kyle O'Reilly (11:28) ROH Showdown In The Sun - Tag 1 - Pay Per View @ War Memorial Auditorium in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, USA |
| 26 | 04.03.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title: Jay Lethal (c) vs. Tommaso Ciampa - Time Limit Draw (15:00) ROH 10th Anniversary Show - Young Wolves Rising - Pay Per View @ Hammerstein Ballroom in New York City, New York, USA |
| 27 | 03.03.2012 | |
March Mayhem Final Four Way Elimination: Tommaso Ciampa defeats Adam Cole and Jay Lethal and Mike Bennett (13:44) ROH Wrestling #29 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 28 | 03.03.2012 | |
March Mayhem Qualifying: Jay Lethal defeats Roderick Strong (15:37) ROH Wrestling #26 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 29 | 17.02.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title Proving Ground: Jay Lethal defeats BJ Whitmer (14:31) ROH Rise & Prove - Event @ Cincinnati Masonic Center in Cincinnati, Ohio, USA |
| 30 | 04.02.2012 | |
Blind Destiny Challenge: Jay Lethal defeats Kenny King (7:01) ROH Wrestling #25 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 31 | 04.02.2012 | |
ROH World Title: Davey Richards (c) defeats Jay Lethal (18:07) ROH Wrestling #23 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
| 32 | 21.01.2012 | |
Proving Ground: Tommaso Ciampa [C] defeats Jay Lethal (15:20) ROH Underground - Event @ Norfolk Scope Exhibition Hall in Norfolk, Virginia, USA |
| 33 | 20.01.2012 | |
ROH World Title: Davey Richards (c) defeats Jay Lethal (22:10) ROH The Homecoming 2012 - Event @ Pennsylvania National Guard Armory in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 34 | 07.01.2012 | |
ROH World Television Title: Jay Lethal (c) defeats Mike Bennett (11:09) ROH Wrestling #20 - TV-Show @ Du Burns Arena in Baltimore, Maryland, USA |
