| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 20.12.2009 |  |
Feast Or Fired: Abdul Bashir and Big Rob and Kevin Nash and Samoa Joe defeat Cody Deaner and Consequences Creed and Eric Young and Homicide and James Storm and Jay Lethal and Kiyoshi and Robert Roode (9:19) TNA Final Resolution 2009 - Pay Per View @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 2 | 08.12.2009 | |
Tatanka defeats Jay Lethal (3:26) TNA iMPACT #286 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 3 | 03.11.2009 | |
Jim Neidhart defeats Jay Lethal (1:30) TNA iMPACT #281 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 4 | 25.10.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat The World Elite (Abdul Bashir & Kiyoshi) TNA House Show - House Show @ Time Warner Cable Theatre in Green Bay, Wisconsin, USA |
| 5 | 24.10.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Abdul Bashir & Kiyoshi TNA House Show - House Show @ Racine, Wisconsin, USA |
| 6 | 23.10.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Abdul Bashir & Kiyoshi TNA House Show - House Show @ Chicago, Illinois, USA |
| 7 | 21.10.2009 |  |
TNA X-Division Title: The Amazing Red (c) defeats Jay Lethal (3:47) TNA Xplosion #272 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 8 | 20.10.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title #1 Contendership Ultimate X: The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (7:24) TNA iMPACT #278 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 9 | 18.10.2009 | |
Ultimate X Qualifying: The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (5:51) TNA Bound For Glory 2009 Preshow - Online Stream @ UCI Bren Events Center in Orange County, California, USA |
| 10 | 07.10.2009 | |
Dark: Jay Lethal defeats Maverick TNA iMPACT #276 - Dark Match @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 11 | 03.10.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title: Samoa Joe (c) defeats Jay Lethal TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Dublin - House Show @ O2 Arena in Dublin, Ireland |
| 12 | 02.10.2009 | |
Abdul Bashir defeats Jay Lethal TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Winterthur - House Show @ Eventhalle Deutweg in Winterthur, Schweiz |
| 13 | 30.09.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Three Way: Samoa Joe (c) defeats Jay Lethal and Suicide TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Hannover - House Show @ AWD-Hall in Hannover, Niedersachsen, Deutschland |
| 14 | 29.09.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Abdul Bashir TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Dortmund - House Show @ Westfalenhalle in Dortmund, Nordrhein-Westfalen, Deutschland |
| 15 | 26.09.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title: Samoa Joe (c) defeats Jay Lethal TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Chemnitz - House Show @ Chemnitz Arena in Chemnitz, Sachsen, Deutschland |
| 16 | 25.09.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Abdul Bashir TNA First Impact Tour 2009 - Nürnberg - House Show @ Arena in Nürnberg, Bayern, Deutschland |
| 17 | 22.09.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title #1 Contendership Five Way Ladder: The Amazing Red defeats Abdul Bashir and Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal and Kiyoshi (3:57) TNA iMPACT #275 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 18 | 01.09.2009 | |
D'Angelo Dinero defeats Jay Lethal (5:20) TNA iMPACT #272 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 19 | 01.09.2009 | |
Dr. Stevie defeats Jay Lethal (3:52) TNA Xplosion #265 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 20 | 30.08.2009 | |
Eric Young defeats Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Bell County Expo Center in Belton, Texas, USA |
| 21 | 29.08.2009 | |
Eric Young defeats Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Abilene, Texas, USA |
| 22 | 28.08.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Abdul Bashir & Kiyoshi TNA House Show - House Show @ San Angelo, Texas, USA |
| 23 | 17.08.2009 | |
Dark: Jay Lethal defeats Slugga TNA iMPACT #269 - Dark Match @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 24 | 16.08.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title #1 Contendership Steel Asylum: Daniels defeats Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin and Consequences Creed and D'Angelo Dinero and Jay Lethal and Suicide and The Amazing Red (16:33) TNA Hard Justice 2009 - Pay Per View @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 25 | 20.07.2009 | |
The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (4:58) TNA Xplosion #257 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 26 | 18.07.2009 | |
Three Way: Chris Sabin defeats Jay Lethal and Suicide TNA House Show - House Show @ Joel Coliseum in Winston-Salem, North Carolina |
| 27 | 17.07.2009 | |
Three Way: Chris Sabin defeats Jay Lethal and Suicide TNA House Show - House Show @ Freedom Hall Civic Center in Johnson City, Tennessee, USA |
| 28 | 12.07.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Eric Young TNA House Show - House Show @ Syracuse, New York, USA |
| 29 | 11.07.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Three Way: Homicide (c) defeats Jay Lethal and Suicide TNA House Show - House Show @ Hamburg, New York, USA |
| 30 | 10.07.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Abdul Bashir TNA House Show - House Show @ Hamilton, Ontario, Canada |
| 31 | 09.07.2009 | |
Eric Young defeats Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Jamestown, New York, USA |
| 32 | 25.06.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Abdul Bashir & Kiyoshi (4:58) TNA Xplosion #255 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 33 | 24.06.2009 | |
Jay Lethal vs. Jethro Holliday - No Contest TNA iMPACT #262 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 34 | 24.06.2009 | |
Dark: Jay Lethal defeats Johnny Gargano (3:16) TNA iMPACT #262 - Dark Match @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 35 | 21.06.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title King Of The Mountain: Suicide (c) defeats Alex Shelley and Chris Sabin and Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal (23:35) TNA Slammiversary 2009 - Pay Per View @ Palace Of Auburn Hills in Detroit, Michigan, USA |
| 36 | 19.06.2009 | |
Chris Sabin defeats Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Grand Rapids, Michigan, USA |
| 37 | 14.06.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Three Way: Suicide (c) defeats Homicide and Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Kearney, Nebraska, USA |
| 38 | 13.06.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Three Way: Suicide (c) defeats Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Council Bluffs, Iowa, USA |
| 39 | 12.06.2009 | |
Eric Young defeats Jay Lethal TNA House Show - House Show @ Saint Joseph, Missouri, USA |
| 40 | 27.05.2009 | |
Alex Shelley & Jay Lethal defeat Team 3D (Brother Devon & Brother Ray) (7:41) TNA iMPACT #259 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 41 | 27.05.2009 | |
Team 3D (Brother Devon & Brother Ray) & Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) & The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) (0:26) TNA iMPACT #260 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 42 | 24.05.2009 | |
Eric Young & Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Abdul Bashir & The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) (13:45) TNA Sacrifice 2009 - Pay Per View @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 43 | 22.05.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Abdul Bashir TNA House Show - House Show @ Amarillo, Texas, USA |
| 44 | 21.05.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) TNA House Show - House Show @ Oklahoma City, Oklahoma, USA |
| 45 | 26.04.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) TNA House Show - House Show @ Columbus, Ohio, USA |
| 46 | 25.04.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) TNA House Show - House Show @ The Eastwood Expo Center in Niles, Ohio, USA |
| 47 | 24.04.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) TNA House Show - House Show @ The Phantasy Theatre in Lakewood, Ohio, USA |
| 48 | 22.04.2009 | |
Eric Young & Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat Kiyoshi & NO LIMIT (Naito & Yujiro) (3:41) TNA Xplosion #246 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 49 | 21.04.2009 | |
Team 3D Invitational Tournament Quarter Final: Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (5:20) TNA iMPACT #252 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 50 | 19.04.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Elimination Xscape: Suicide (c) defeats Abdul Bashir and Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal and Kiyoshi (11:37) TNA Lockdown 2009 - Pay Per View @ Liacouras Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 51 | 17.04.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title: Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) (c) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) TNA House Show - House Show @ Elmira, New York, USA |
| 52 | 30.03.2009 | |
Abdul Bashir, Kiyoshi & NO LIMIT (Naito & Yujiro) defeat The Latin American Exchange (Hernandez & Homicide) & Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (3:55) TNA iMPACT #249 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 53 | 17.03.2009 | |
20 Man Steel Cage Gauntlet: Samoa Joe defeats Abdul Bashir and Abyss and AJ Styles and Alex Shelley and Booker T and Chris Sabin and Consequences Creed and Eric Young and Hernandez and Homicide and Jay Lethal and Jeff Jarrett and Kurt Angle and Matt Morgan and Naito and Rhino and Scott Steiner and Shane Sewell and Yujiro (42:30) TNA iMPACT #248 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 54 | 15.03.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Ultimate X: Suicide defeats Alex Shelley (c) and Chris Sabin and Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal (14:12) - TITLE CHANGE !!! TNA Destination X 2009 - Pay Per View @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 55 | 14.03.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) defeat NO LIMIT (Naito & Yujiro) TNA House Show - House Show @ Cincinnati, Ohio, USA |
| 56 | 13.03.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title: Jay Lethal defeats Robert Roode (c) by DQ TNA House Show - House Show @ Louisville, Kentucky, USA |
| 57 | 24.02.2009 | |
Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) & The Latin American Exchange (Hernandez & Homicide) defeat Booker T, Scott Steiner & The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) (4:51) TNA iMPACT #246 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 58 | 23.02.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Four Way Ladder: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Chris Sabin and Consequences Creed and Jay Lethal (5:05) TNA iMPACT #244 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 59 | 10.02.2009 | |
Tag Team Street Fight: The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (6:01) TNA iMPACT #243 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 60 | 09.02.2009 | |
The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (4:29) TNA iMPACT #242 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 61 | 08.02.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title: Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) (c) defeat Lethal Consequences (Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal) (15:43) TNA Against All Odds 2009 - Pay Per View @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 62 | 27.01.2009 | |
Eric Young & Jay Lethal defeat The Motor City Machine Guns (Alex Shelley & Chris Sabin) (4:15) TNA iMPACT #241 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 63 | 24.01.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Four Way: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Doug Williams and Eric Young and Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 6 - House Show @ Wembley Arena in London, England, UK |
| 64 | 22.01.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Four Way: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Consequences Creed and Eric Young and Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 5 - House Show @ Braehead Arena in Glasgow, Scotland, UK |
| 65 | 21.01.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title Four Way: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Consequences Creed and Eric Young and Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 4 - House Show @ LG Arena in Birmingham, West Midlands, England, UK |
| 66 | 20.01.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 3 - House Show @ Evening News Arena in Manchester, England, UK |
| 67 | 17.01.2009 | |
TNA X-Division Title: Alex Shelley (c) defeats Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 2 - House Show @ National Stadium in Dublin, Ireland |
| 68 | 16.01.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title: Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) (c) defeat Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal TNA Maximum Impact Tour - Tag 1 - House Show @ National Stadium in Dublin, Ireland |
| 69 | 13.01.2009 | |
Jay Lethal defeats Cute Kip (3:32) TNA Xplosion #231 - Online Stream @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 70 | 12.01.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title #1 Contendership: Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal defeat Abyss & Matt Morgan (9:20) TNA iMPACT #238 - TV-Show @ Universal Studios in Orlando, Florida, USA |
| 71 | 11.01.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title Three Way: Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) defeat Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal (c) and Abyss & Matt Morgan (15:22) - TITLE CHANGE !!! TNA Genesis 2009 - Pay Per View @ Bojangles Coliseum in Charlotte, North Carolina, USA |
| 72 | 09.01.2009 | |
TNA World Tag Team Title: Consequences Creed & Jay Lethal (c) defeat Beer Money Inc. (James Storm & Robert Roode) TNA House Show - House Show @ Wilson, North Carolina, USA |
