| # | Date | Promotion | Match |
| 1 | 14.07.2022 |  |
ACW Heavyweight Title: Josh Bishop (c) defeats Matt Justice ACW This Means War 2022 - Event @ Buffalo Wild Wings in Charleston, West Virginia, USA |
| 2 | 16.06.2022 | |
Extreme Rules: Matt Justice defeats Bobby Beverly ACW Speak Of The Devil 2022 - Event @ Buffalo Wild Wings in Charleston, West Virginia, USA |
| 3 | 25.02.2022 |  |
Second Gear Crew And Friends (Allie Katch, Dark Sheik, Gringo Loco & Matt Justice) defeat Team Reefer (Grim Reefer, Jack Cartwheel, Jimmy Lloyd & Jordan Oliver) (10:45) GCW Welcome To Heartbreak - Pay Per View @ Ukrainian Culture Center in Los Angeles, California, USA |
| 4 | 26.06.2021 |  |
The Acclaimed (Anthony Bowens & Max Caster) defeat Matt Justice & PB Smooth (2:53) AEW Dark: Elevation #16 - Online Stream @ Daily's Place in Jacksonville, Florida, USA |
| 5 | 01.12.2019 |  |
Three Way: Willie Mack defeats Jason Kincaid and Matt Justice AML The Day After - Event @ Benton Convention Center in Winston-Salem, North Carolina, USA |
| 6 | 25.01.2019 |  |
Bobby Beverly vs. Matt Justice - No Contest PPW Bring The Pain - Event @ The ArenA in Jeffersonville, Indiana, USA |
| 7 | 17.06.2017 |  |
John Atlas defeats Matt Justice Destiny Invasion - Event @ Battle Arts Academy in Mississauga, Ontario, Canada |
| 8 | 03.06.2017 |  |
Matt Justice defeats Mike Mendoza CKCW Vanished Empire - Event @ Parma, Ohio, USA |
| 9 | 01.05.2017 |  |
Battle Royal: Chris Mayne defeats Ashton Starr and Aspyn Rose and Chris Crunk and Everett O'Connor and Heisenberg Brother #1 and Heisenberg Brother #2 and Jaden Newman and Kiera Hogan and Matt Justice and Matt Knicks and Maxwell Jacob Feinstein and Mr. Sleaze and O'Shay and Owen Knight and Priscilla Kelly and Slade Porter and Stitch Osiris and Sylar Cross and Will Huckaby (16:43) AWE Homegrown 2017 - Event @ Museums Bar in Atlanta, Georgia, USA |
| 10 | 14.10.2016 |  |
Swoggle & Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) defeat Matt Justice & The NOW (Hale Collins & Vik Dalishus) HOH XIX - Event @ The Odeon in Cleveland, Ohio, USA |
| 11 | 11.03.2016 |  |
Matt Justice & Rodney Mack defeat The Dirty Blondes (Leo Brien & Mike Patrick) CWA CW A Night To Remember - Event @ Tippah County Coliseum in Ripley, Mississippi, USA |
| 12 | 24.10.2015 |  |
NYWC Fusion Title: Joe Gacy (c) defeats Matt Justice NYWC House Of Madness 2015 - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 13 | 03.10.2015 |  |
Matt Justice & Sonny Vice defeat Clinton Crooks & David Lawless PWX Do Or Die 2015 - Event @ PWX Wrestleplex in McKeesport, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 14 | 15.08.2015 |  |
Matt Justice defeats Mike Outlaw Saturday Night Live - Event @ Attala County Coliseum in Kosciusko, Mississippi, USA |
| 15 | 27.12.2014 | |
Athletic Inc (Jesse Vane & Matt Justice) defeat The Premiere Gods (Anthony Nese & Papadon) NYWC Tour de Circus - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 16 | 29.11.2014 | |
NYWC Tag Team Title: Milk Chocolate (Brandon Watts & Randy Summers) (c) defeat Athletic Inc (Jesse Vane & Matt Justice) NYWC Draw The Line - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 17 | 25.10.2014 | |
Jesse Vane & Matt Justice defeat Apollyon & Stockade NYWC House Of Madness 2014 - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 18 | 04.10.2014 |  |
Matt Justice defeats Chance Prophet VOW October Onslaught II - Event @ The Ice Mine in Connellsville, Pennsylvania, USA |
| 19 | 27.09.2014 | |
Athletic Inc (Jesse Vane & Matt Justice), Braydon Knight & JT Kasin defeat The A-Listers (Absolute Alvin, Cono, J-Redd & Ultimo Maya) NYWC Till I Colapse - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 20 | 21.08.2014 | |
Team Tremendous (Bill Carr & Dan Barry) defeat Athletic Inc (Jesse Vane & Matt Justice) NYWC Hotter Than Hell - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 21 | 24.07.2014 | |
Athletic Inc (Jesse Vane & Matt Justice) defeat Grim Reefer & Latin Dragon NYWC Trust No One - Event @ NYWC Sportatorium in Deer Park, New York, USA |
| 22 | 21.06.2014 |  |
Matt Conard defeats Matt Justice Remix Pro Freedom Fest - Event @ VFW in Marietta, Ohio, USA |
| 23 | 17.05.2014 |  |
Seth Allen defeats Matt Justice ARW - Event @ Guilford Lake Grille in Lisbon, Ohio, USA |
| 24 | 02.05.2014 | |
Kriss Stark defeats Matt Justice VOW MAXXimum MAYhem - Event @ The Maxx in Uniontown, Pennsylvania, USA |
